Swastika vandalism at Sydney Jewish bagel shop ahead of Passover opening
Consensus Summary
A swastika was vandalized into the window of Lox in a Box, a Jewish-owned bagel shop in Sydney’s Paddington neighborhood, on 21 March 2024—weeks before its scheduled opening on 9 April. Owner Candy Berger, who is the granddaughter of a Holocaust survivor, discovered the symbol after removing protective paper from the windows, describing the moment as deeply traumatic and tied to the timing of Passover. Police confirmed the incident as malicious damage and launched an investigation, while Berger praised community security efforts. The vandalism follows a surge in antisemitic incidents in Sydney’s east, including the 17–18 December 2023 shooting at a Bondi beach Hanukah event that killed 15 people and prompted closures of Jewish businesses like Avner’s Bakery. Both articles highlight the emotional toll on Berger and the broader community, with one-star Google reviews and online harassment targeting Jewish-owned businesses after the attack. While both sources agree on the core facts, discrepancies include the exact date of the Bondi shooting and phrasing in Berger’s statements, though the overarching narrative of rising antisemitism remains consistent.
✓ Verified by 2+ sources
Key details reported by multiple sources:
- A swastika was etched into the window of Lox in a Box, a Jewish bagel shop on Oxford Street, Paddington, Sydney, on Saturday 21 March 2024
- The shop’s Paddington location was being renovated for an opening on 9 April 2024
- Owner Candy Berger is the granddaughter of a Holocaust survivor and discovered the swastika when removing brown paper covering the windows
- NSW Police launched an investigation into the malicious damage, with initial inquiries confirming the incident occurred on 21 March
- The incident follows a wave of antisemitic incidents in Sydney’s east, including car fires, house vandalism, and the Bondi beach Hanukah shooting on 17 December 2023
- Avner’s Bakery in Surry Hills permanently closed after the Bondi shooting, citing ongoing antisemitic harassment and safety concerns
- Lox in a Box’s Bondi, Coogee, and Marrickville stores closed on 18 December 2023 following the Bondi shooting
- Candy Berger reported receiving an influx of one-star Google reviews with antisemitic undertones after the Bondi attack
Points of Difference
Details reported by only one source:
- Berger posted a message on Instagram saying the swastika was discovered ‘earlier this week’ (implied 25–28 March) and referenced ‘the pogrom at Bondi’
- The Guardian included a direct quote from Berger’s Instagram: ‘In the wake of the pogrom at Bondi one thing has become clear – it is no longer possible to make outwardly, publicly, proudly Jewish places and events safe in Australia’
- The Guardian mentioned the shop’s three existing locations (Bondi, Coogee, Marrickville) explicitly as ‘sites in Coogee and Marrickville’ (implied Bondi as well)
- The Guardian cited Ed Halmagyi’s statement about Avner’s Bakery facing ‘almost ceaseless antisemitic harassment, vandalism and intimidation’ over two years
- The Guardian noted the shop’s windows were ‘covered with brown paper after painting’ and Berger ‘did not discover the Nazi symbol until she removed the covering earlier this week’
- News.com.au reported Berger’s Instagram post addressed to 37,000 followers, detailing the emotional impact with phrases like ‘Our literal blood, sweat and heart’
- The article emphasized the ‘calculated’ timing of the vandalism in relation to Passover, quoting Berger’s words: ‘A time where we remember that the Jewish people have been marked before’
- News.com.au explicitly stated the Paddington store was the ‘fourth store’ for Lox in a Box (implying three prior locations)
- The article included a direct quote from Berger: ‘I won’t pretend this didn’t shake me … I’ve held onto gratitude, because I love what I do’
- News.com.au urged the public to contact Crime Stoppers (1800 333 000) for information about the incident, a detail not mentioned in the Guardian
Contradictions
Conflicting information between sources:
- The Guardian refers to the Bondi shooting as occurring on 17 December 2023, but the headline in Article 1 states it happened on 18 December 2023
- The Guardian describes the swastika as ‘found scratched into the window’ while News.com.au calls it ‘etched into the glass’
- The Guardian implies the swastika was discovered ‘earlier this week’ (25–28 March) without specifying the exact date, while News.com.au does not provide a timeline for discovery beyond Berger’s Instagram post
- The Guardian states Lox in a Box has ‘sites in Coogee and Marrickville’ (implying Bondi as well), while News.com.au explicitly calls Paddington the ‘fourth store’ (suggesting Bondi, Coogee, and Marrickville were the first three)
- News.com.au quotes Berger as saying ‘Our literal blood, sweet and heart’ in her Instagram post, while the Guardian does not include this exact phrasing
Source Articles
Swastika found scratched into window of Jewish bagel shop in Sydney
Police investigate damage at Lox in a Box, Paddington, latest in string of alleged antisemitic incidents in wake of Hamas attack of 7 October 2023 and Israel’s war in Gaza Follow our Australia news li...
‘Like a punch’: Vile symbol etched into Lox in a Box storefront before opening
A popular Sydney cafe was preparing for the grand opening of its new venue when the police were called in over a sickening incident....