NSW council proposes permanent four-day workweek for non-essential staff
Consensus Summary
Murrumbidgee Council in regional NSW is exploring a permanent four-day workweek for non-essential staff to cut costs and improve productivity without raising rates. The proposal, led by general manager John Scarce, would compress 35–38 weekly hours into Monday–Thursday shifts, targeting annual savings of around $1 million through reduced travel and operational efficiencies. Both sources confirm the council’s vast 7000-square-kilometre area and the 160 km daily travel average for road crews, though ABC specifies 160 km/day while NEWSCOMAU notes round trips. Essential services like water and emergency response would remain unaffected. Scarce argues the change could attract staff and meet community demands for expanded services, such as weekly waste collection. While ABC highlights a failed four-day week trial by Launceston City Council and cites Per Capita’s global research on health and productivity benefits, NEWSCOMAU frames the debate nationally, contrasting union support (ACTU) with business skepticism (Australian Chamber of Commerce). Both articles agree the move is about efficiency, not service cuts, but ABC leans on staff and health outcomes, while NEWSCOMAU focuses on logistical and financial sustainability.
✓ Verified by 2+ sources
Key details reported by multiple sources:
- Murrumbidgee Council in south-west NSW is proposing a Monday-to-Thursday four-day workweek for depot, office, and library staff
- The council’s general manager is John Scarce, who estimates annual productivity savings of around $1 million from reduced travel time (160 km/day average for road crews)
- Staff would maintain their standard 35 or 38-hour weekly hours but compressed into four days
- Essential services (water, sewerage, animal control, emergencies) would remain operational with staff on call or rostered
- The council spans approximately 7000 square kilometres and faces rising operational costs without rate increases
- The proposal is part of broader national debates about four-day workweeks, with mixed views from unions and business groups
Points of Difference
Details reported by only one source:
- Wesa Chau (Per Capita) cited a 2023 trial of 70 global organisations where 92% of men and 60.7% of women reported positive health impacts, and 96% of employers saw improved performance
- Launceston City Council abandoned a similar four-day week plan in February 2024 due to ratepayer and stakeholder backlash
- Scarce mentioned the proposal could help recruit staff by addressing community demand for weekly waste collection (currently fortnightly)
- The council’s offices in Darlington Point, Coleambally, and Jerilderie would implement the change, excluding Scarce’s role and childcare/caravan park operations
- The council estimates $1.1 million annual savings from reduced travel and equipment mobilisation (up to 26 round trips annually averaging 160 km)
- The proposal aims to improve responsiveness by concentrating staff hours rather than spreading them across rostered days off
- ACTU president Michele O’Neil supported shorter weeks, calling them ‘good for both workers and employers’
- Australian Chamber of Commerce CEO Andrew McKellar warned the four-day week could ‘put the cart before the horse’ without proven productivity gains
- The council explicitly stated the model is not about reducing services but delivering them ‘more efficiently and sustainably’
Contradictions
Conflicting information between sources:
- ABC reports Launceston City Council abandoned its four-day week plan in February 2024, but NEWSCOMAU does not mention this event
- ABC states the council’s average daily travel for road crews is 160 km, while NEWSCOMAU rounds this to ‘up to 160 km round trip’ (implying 320 km/day)
- ABC highlights Scarce’s exclusion from the four-day week as a specific detail, but NEWSCOMAU does not mention this
- NEWSCOMAU emphasizes the council’s focus on ‘customer service’ hours (35/week) being delivered via longer daily opening times, while ABC does not mention this
- ABC cites Per Capita’s global trial data (92% men, 60.7% women reporting health benefits) as a direct quote, but NEWSCOMAU does not reference this research
Source Articles
‘Outside the box’: Radical 4-day week plan
One council is examining a four-day working week that aims to maintain essential services, reduce travel costs, and avoid increasing rates for residents....
Fridays off: NSW council wants to move to a four-day working week
Millions of Australians are about to enjoy two consecutive four-day working weeks due to the Easter long weekend. One council in regional NSW wants to make that a permanent set up....