Liberal MP Andrew Hastie’s shift on 25% gas profit tax amid energy crisis
Consensus Summary
Liberal MP Andrew Hastie has unexpectedly signaled openness to a 25% tax on gas profits, aligning with Greens and crossbench calls amid rising energy costs driven by Iran’s blockade of the Strait of Hormuz. Both sources confirm Treasury is modeling the tax, which could raise billions for a sovereign wealth fund modeled after Norway’s $3.2 trillion fund. Hastie acknowledges public frustration with corporate profits and supports budget balance discussions, though gas companies and senior Liberals oppose the tax. The Guardian adds Hastie’s criticism of US President Trump’s Iran strategy and warnings about investor reactions, while Newscomaustralia highlights community support from groups like ACOSS and Greens’ criticism of Santos’ profits. No factual contradictions exist beyond differing emphasis, with both sources agreeing on key figures and events.
✓ Verified by 2+ sources
Key details reported by multiple sources:
- Andrew Hastie, Liberal MP and shadow minister for industry and sovereign capability, is open to a 25% tax on gas profits as part of a sovereign wealth fund proposal
- The Albanese government’s Treasury is modelling the effects of a 25% flat tax on gas profits, alongside potential changes to the petroleum resource rent tax (PRRT) and corporate income tax
- Norway’s sovereign wealth fund has assets worth over $3.2 trillion ($US2.2tn)
- Iran is blocking the Strait of Hormuz, threatening global oil supply and worsening the energy crisis
- Gas giants have signaled they will oppose any new tax, with the Australian Energy Producers warning it would harm Australia’s economy and energy security
- The Greens estimate a 25% increase to the PRRT could raise $17 billion per year
- Andrew Hastie referenced public anger over corporate profits and wealth inequality, including housing affordability
Points of Difference
Details reported by only one source:
- Andrew Hastie criticized US President Donald Trump for being 'overconfident' in launching attacks on Iran, stating the US underestimated Iran’s ability to retaliate via the Strait of Hormuz
- Hastie mentioned the post-Cold War rules-based order is 'dead' and the 'peace dividend'—basis of Australia’s trade and prosperity—is buried
- Shadow Treasurer Tim Wilson warned that new taxes would 'freeze investment and private jobs growth' and the International Energy Agency head Fatih Birol cautioned sudden tax changes would spook investors
- Hastie’s position could put him at odds with senior Liberals, including Opposition Leader Angus Taylor
- The Australian Council of Social Service (ACOSS) welcomed Hastie’s comments, stating low-income households are struggling while gas corporations profit
- Greens senator Steph Hodgins-May criticized Santos for negotiating $120 million from a single gas shipment, calling it 'greed-driven'
Contradictions
Conflicting information between sources:
- The Guardian reports Hastie believes Trump was 'overconfident' in launching attacks on Iran, while Newscomaustralia does not mention this critique
- The Guardian highlights Hastie’s potential conflict with senior Liberals like Angus Taylor, but Newscomaustralia does not reference this internal Liberal Party tension
- The Guardian includes a direct quote from Fatih Birol warning about investor spooking, while Newscomaustralia does not mention this warning
- The Guardian attributes the $3.2 trillion figure for Norway’s sovereign wealth fund to both sources, but Newscomaustralia does not elaborate on the geopolitical implications of Iran’s actions in the Strait of Hormuz
- The Guardian mentions Hastie’s broader critique of the post-Cold War order, which is absent from Newscomaustralia’s coverage
Source Articles
Andrew Hastie open to 25% tax on gas profits and says multinationals have ‘had a really good run’ on Australian wealth
Exclusive : Speaking with the Australian Politics podcast, the Liberal frontbencher says a sovereign wealth fund would set Australians up for generations to come Follow our Australia news live blog fo...
Liberal MP’s big call on Greens’ gas tax
Liberal frontbencher Andrew Hastie says he’s open to a 25 per cent tax on gas profits as multinationals reap huge gains from Iran war price spikes....