Liberal MP Andrew Hastie’s open stance on 25% gas profit tax amid global energy crisis
Consensus Summary
Liberal MP Andrew Hastie has signaled openness to a 25% tax on gas profits, aligning with Greens and Senator David Pocock’s push for a windfall tax amid rising global energy prices fueled by Iran’s actions in the Strait of Hormuz. Both sources confirm Hastie’s sympathy toward public anger over multinational gas corporations’ profits, referencing Norway’s sovereign wealth fund as a model for Australia. While both articles agree on the $120 million Santos shipment and the $3.2 trillion Norwegian fund, the Guardian adds leaked budget plans and warnings from the International Energy Agency about investor concerns, contrasting with NEWSCOMAU’s focus on public support and internal Liberal Party dynamics. Hastie’s stance risks clashing with senior Liberals like Angus Taylor, who oppose new taxes, and his comments on US-Iran tensions are absent from NEWSCOMAU.
✓ Verified by 2+ sources
Key details reported by multiple sources:
- Andrew Hastie, Liberal MP and shadow minister for sovereign capability, is open to a 25% tax on gas profits, reportedly modelled by Treasury on request of the Department of the Prime Minister and Cabinet
- The Greens and former Climate 200-backed Senator David Pocock have championed a 25% export tax on gas profits, with the Greens estimating it could raise $17 billion per year
- Hastie referenced Norway’s sovereign wealth fund, which has assets worth over $3.2 trillion ($US2.2tn), as a model for Australia
- Hastie stated that 'multinationals don’t have a social licence' and 'have had a really good run of our wealth here' during an interview with The Guardian
- The Iranian regime’s actions in blocking the Strait of Hormuz have contributed to the global energy crisis, per warnings from the US and Israeli-led bombings of Iran
- Santos reportedly negotiated $120 million from a single shipment of gas, as cited by Greens senator Steph Hodgins-May
Points of Difference
Details reported by only one source:
- The Australian Council of Social Service (ACOSS) welcomed Hastie’s comments, emphasizing the financial strain on low and modest incomes while gas corporations profit
- Hastie also acknowledged anger among Australians about wealth inequality, including housing affordability, in addition to gas profits
- The article mentions the Greens’ statement about households facing 'energy bill shock' due to soaring gas prices
- Budget leaks suggest the Albanese government is modelling a flat 25% tax on gas profits alongside possible changes to the petroleum resource rent tax (PRRT) and corporate income tax
- Hastie’s position could put him at odds with senior Liberals, including opposition leader Angus Taylor and shadow treasurer Tim Wilson, who warned new taxes would 'freeze investment and private jobs growth'
- Hastie criticized US President Donald Trump’s 'overconfidence' in launching attacks on Iran, stating the enemy always has a vote and Iran is using the Strait of Hormuz strategically
- The International Energy Agency’s head, Fatih Birol, warned the Albanese government that sudden changes to corporate taxes would 'spook investors'
Contradictions
Conflicting information between sources:
- NEWSCOMAU reports the Greens estimate a 25% Petroleum Resource Rent Tax (PRRT) increase could raise $17bn per year, but the Guardian does not explicitly mention this figure or the PRRT increase in its consensus facts
- The Guardian states budget leaks suggest the Albanese government is modelling a 25% tax on gas profits, while NEWSCOMAU attributes the modelling to Treasury on request of the Department of the Prime Minister and Cabinet without mentioning leaks
- The Guardian highlights Hastie’s potential conflict with senior Liberals like Angus Taylor and Tim Wilson, while NEWSCOMAU does not mention this internal Liberal Party tension
- The Guardian includes Hastie’s criticism of Donald Trump’s Iran policy and the post-cold war rules-based order, which is not present in NEWSCOMAU
- NEWSCOMAU cites ACOSS’s Cassandra Goldie welcoming Hastie’s comments, while the Guardian does not reference ACOSS or its chief executive
Source Articles
Liberal MP’s big call on Greens’ gas tax
Liberal frontbencher Andrew Hastie says he’s open to a 25 per cent tax on gas profits as multinationals reap huge gains from Iran war price spikes....
Andrew Hastie open to 25% tax on gas profits and says multinationals have ‘had a really good run’ on Australian wealth
Exclusive : Speaking with the Australian Politics podcast, the Liberal frontbencher says a sovereign wealth fund would set Australians up for generations to come Follow our Australia news live blog fo...