Australia's illegal tobacco market dominates consumption, undermining excise revenue and public health policies
Consensus Summary
Australia’s illegal tobacco market has surged to dominate consumption, with 80% of cigarettes and vapes in 2025 sourced illegally, up from just 12% in 2017. The Australian Bureau of Statistics (ABS) attributed this to a 40% rise in nicotine consumption over the same period, despite population growth of only 14%, while household spending on legal tobacco dropped to 2016 levels. Steep excise hikes—tripling legal prices since 2016—have driven smokers to cheaper black-market products, costing the federal budget billions annually. Both sources agree the market is fueled by illegal imports, primarily from Asia and the Middle East, with border seizures rising from 480 million cigarettes in 2016 to over 2.66 billion in 2025. Experts and state leaders, including NSW Premier Chris Minns, argue the excise policy has failed, either by pushing smokers to crime or straining enforcement resources. While the Albanese government resists excise cuts, opposition parties and some public health officials advocate for reform, though law enforcement officials dismiss the idea as ineffective against organized crime.
✓ Verified by 2+ sources
Key details reported by multiple sources:
- 80% of cigarettes and vapes consumed in Australia in 2025 were illegal, up from 12% in 2017
- Nicotine consumption in Australia increased by 40% between 2017 and 2025, while population growth was 14%
- Household spending on legal tobacco products in 2025 fell to levels similar to 2016, despite prices tripling since then
- The Australian Bureau of Statistics (ABS) used nicotine metabolite concentrations in wastewater samples to estimate illegal tobacco consumption
- The federal budget downgraded tobacco excise revenue by $8 billion over the next five years due to illegal market growth
- Illegal cigarettes sell for about $25 a pack, while legal packs cost over $50 (25 sticks at $1.52 excise per stick)
- More than 2.66 billion illegal cigarettes were seized at the border in 2025, up from 480 million in 2016
Points of Difference
Details reported by only one source:
- Treasury estimated excise evaded ranges from $7.7 billion to $11.8 billion annually (Illicit Tobacco and E-cigarette Commissioner report)
- Treasurer Jim Chalmers called excise reduction 'sceptical' in achieving goals, while Assistant Customs Minister Julian Hill dismissed the idea entirely
- The excise tax on cigarettes now accounts for more than 80% of the total cost of a pack
- Historical excise hikes included a 25% increase in 2010 and annual 12.5% increases from 2013–2020, in addition to twice-yearly earnings-based increases
- The Coalition is open to reducing tobacco excise to encourage legal market use, but the Albanese government has resisted this approach
- NSW Health Minister Ryan Park called the excise disparity a 'public health failure' and noted states must dedicate more resources to enforcement and healthcare
- NSW Premier Chris Minns called for an overhaul of tobacco excise, stating it no longer works as tax or health policy
- NSW introduced a new penalty for landlords of shops selling illegal tobacco, with a maximum penalty of $1.5 million and 7 years in prison for commercial possession
- Victoria introduced fines of up to $370,000 or 15 years in jail for selling illicit tobacco under new penalties
Contradictions
Conflicting information between sources:
- The ABC states the Illicit Tobacco and E-cigarette Commissioner’s report estimated illegal cigarettes and vapes made up 60% of the total market, while both sources agree ABS data shows 80% of consumption was illegal in 2025
- The Guardian mentions a $6.9 billion hole in the federal budget from illegal tobacco, while the ABC cites a $8 billion downgrade in excise revenue over five years (not annual)
Source Articles
ABS estimates 80pc of tobacco consumed in Australia last year was illegally sourced
The experimental estimates are based on "nicotine metabolite concentrations" detected in wastewater samples, combined with data showing a collapse in spending on legal cigarettes and vapes.
Australians are spending less to consume more nicotine as illegal tobacco trade explodes
Australian Bureau of Statistics estimates nicotine consumption rose 40%, with illicit sources accounting for 80% of all tobacco Follow our Australia news live blog for latest updates Get our breaking news email , free app or daily news podcast Australians are consuming more nicotine than they were eight years ago but are spending less, new data from the Australian Bureau of Statistics shows, as 80% of the cigarettes smoked by the nation last year were cheaper illegal products. The analysis relea