← Back to Stories

AFL preliminary final bottle-throwing incident sparks bans and backlash

By Updated 23 September 202610 articles from 4 independent sources

Consensus Summary

The AFL’s preliminary final between Hawthorn and Brisbane descended into chaos on Saturday night as angry Hawthorn fans hurled bottles, cans, and even food at umpires as they left the MCG. The incident followed a controversial free kick against Jarman Impey for holding the ball with 30-40 seconds remaining, which led to Brisbane’s winning goal and a nine-point victory. Police evicted 10 people from the game, fined five for poor behavior—including a 40-year-old Croydon man fined $418 for throwing a bottle—and reported five assaults. The AFL responded by announcing a minimum five-year stadium ban for any identified bottle-throwers, while the Melbourne Cricket Club threatened lifetime bans. The match itself was hailed as one of the greatest preliminary finals ever, featuring nine lead changes and a dramatic comeback by Brisbane from a five-goal deficit in the final quarter.

The unrest stemmed from a series of contentious umpiring decisions, with the Impey free kick being the most controversial. Hawthorn players, including co-captain James Sicily and defender Tom Barrass, were fined $10,000 and $5,000 respectively for confronting the umpires post-match. The AFL Fans Association condemned the behavior, stating that while passion is part of the game, throwing objects crosses a dangerous line. The incident also involved younger fans, including a 6-year-old Lions supporter hit by a can and an eight-year-old child who had nachos thrown at them. The AFL and MCC security are now collaborating with Victoria Police to identify those responsible, using CCTV footage and witness statements.

Key figures in the aftermath included Hawthorn coach Sam Mitchell, who expressed disappointment at the fan behavior while acknowledging the emotional intensity of the moment. Mitchell stated that he wanted to 'scream with rage' but emphasized that throwing objects was unacceptable. Umpire Hayden Meyer, who made the controversial Impey call, described feeling 'threatened' by the abuse and said he had received an apology from Barrass but not from Sicily. The AFL’s response was swift, with league officials condemning the actions as dangerous and disrespectful. Former umpire Ray Chamberlain backed the free kick decision, calling it a 'courageous' call that umpires must make in high-pressure moments. The incident has also sparked broader discussions about fan behavior in Australian sport, with calls for stricter enforcement and education on respectful conduct.

While most outlets agree on the core facts—such as the fines, bans, and the Impey free kick—there are differences in emphasis and detail. The ABC and THEAGE highlight the involvement of a 34-year-old Seaford man expected to be charged for throwing a plate of food, while 7NEWS focuses more on the younger victims, including the 6-year-old hit by a can. The ABC also reports that the MCC is considering lifetime bans, whereas 7NEWS and THEAGE only mention the AFL’s five-year ban. Additionally, the ABC provides more specific police details, such as the five assaults and the use of CCTV footage, while THEAGE emphasizes the Premier of Victoria’s condemnation of the behavior. These differences reflect varying priorities in coverage, with some outlets focusing on legal consequences and others on the human impact of the incident.

The fallout from the incident continues as the AFL and MCC prepare for the grand final between Brisbane and Fremantle, scheduled for Sunday afternoon. Extra police and security measures are in place to prevent a repeat of Saturday’s unrest. The AFL has also reiterated its stance that such behavior will not be tolerated, with officials warning that those identified will face severe penalties. Meanwhile, Hawthorn players and fans are left grappling with the aftermath, with some expressing regret over the actions of a small but vocal minority. The incident serves as a stark reminder of the fine line between passionate fandom and unacceptable conduct, with stakeholders across the sport united in their call for respect and safety at AFL games.

✓ Verified by 2+ sources

Key details reported by multiple sources:

  • A 40-year-old Croydon man was fined $418 for throwing a bottle during the Hawthorn-Brisbane AFL preliminary final at the MCG.
  • The AFL announced a minimum five-year stadium ban for any identified bottle-throwing fans.
  • Hawthorn players James Sicily and Tom Barrass were fined $10,000 and $5,000 respectively for umpire abuse after the match.
  • A 6-year-old Lions supporter was hit by a can and taken to hospital, and an eight-year-old child had nachos thrown at them.
  • The controversial free kick against Jarman Impey for holding the ball with 30-40 seconds remaining led to Brisbane’s winning goal.
  • Police evicted 10 people from the game and issued penalty notices, including five fines for poor behavior.
  • The match took place on Saturday night, with the umpires targeted as they left the field.
  • The AFL and MCC security are working with Victoria Police to identify the bottle throwers.
  • The game was described as one of the greatest preliminary finals ever, with nine lead changes.
  • Hawthorn coach Sam Mitchell condemned the fan behavior, calling it disappointing and dangerous.
  • The AFL grand final is scheduled for Sunday afternoon, with Brisbane facing Fremantle.
  • A 34-year-old Seaford man is expected to be charged for allegedly throwing a plate of food at a woman and child.
  • A 56-year-old Tullamarine man was fined $418 for throwing a bottle onto the field.
  • The incident occurred during the AFL preliminary final at the MCG, with bottles and cans thrown at umpires as they left the field.
  • The AFL Fans Association condemned the behavior, stating it was an 'ugly look for our game.'

How the outlets covered it

4 outlets reported this story. 7News published first; ABC News followed 18 h later.

Times are when each outlet published, from its own feed, in Sydney time. Outlets whose feeds don’t give a publish time are listed last. See how this works.

Points of Difference

Details reported by only one source:

7News
  • A 400-game AFL umpire, Chris Donlon, stated that the free kick call against Impey was a 'great call' and that umpires must get big moments right.
  • Box Hill won their VFL grand final on Sunday, which Mitchell and players attended.
  • An eight-year-old child had nachos thrown at them, and the child’s mother expressed fear about returning to the MCG.
  • Xander McGuire reported that Sicily used 'every sort of expletive in the book' when confronting the umpire.
  • A 6-year-old Lions supporter was hit by a full can and taken to hospital for stitches.
ABC News
  • A 34-year-old man is expected to be charged with aggravated unlawful assault and discharging a missile for throwing a plate of food at a woman and child.
  • Umpire Hayden Meyer felt 'threatened' by player abuse and said he received an apology from Tom Barrass but not from James Sicily.
  • The MCC threatened lifetime bans for those involved in the bottle-throwing incident.
  • Police revealed that five people were fined, including one for bottle-throwing, and five others were assaulted at the MCG.
  • The ABC reported that the incident occurred on Saturday night, with the umpires targeted as they left the field after the match.
  • The ABC noted that the AFL and MCC are preparing for a full house for the grand final, with extra police and Public Order Response Team members on duty.
The Age
  • A 47-year-old woman and an eight-year-old child were allegedly targeted with a plate of food thrown at them.
  • The match review officer determined that the usual fines did not meet the seriousness of the offense, leading to higher penalties for Sicily and Barrass.
  • The article mentioned that the MCG security team is investigating the incident and has zero tolerance for such behavior.
  • The Premier of Victoria, Ben Carroll, condemned the behavior, calling it 'not the Victorian way' and stating that it could have caused catastrophic injuries.
The Guardian
  • The Guardian noted that the match was one of the all-time great AFL finals, with the biggest noise at the MCG being the booing after the siren.
  • The article highlighted that ruckman Lloyd Meek swore while speaking to reporters in the rooms post-match.

Where the reporting differs

Details that conflict, or appear in only some outlets:

  • The ABC states that a 34-year-old Seaford man is expected to be charged for throwing a plate of food, while 7NEWS and THEAGE do not mention this specific individual by name.
  • The ABC and THEAGE mention a 47-year-old woman and an eight-year-old child being targeted with a plate of food, but 7NEWS only mentions the eight-year-old child having nachos thrown at them.
  • The ABC reports that the MCC is considering lifetime bans, while 7NEWS and THEAGE only mention a minimum five-year ban from the AFL.
  • The ABC states that five people were fined, including one for bottle-throwing, while 7NEWS and THEAGE mention that 10 people were evicted and five fined, but do not specify the exact number fined for bottle-throwing.

Source Articles

7NEWS

AFL to hit bottle throwers with years-long stadium ban after preliminary final furore

Victoria Police have given an update as they investigate a number of incidents after the preliminary final.

7NEWS

Hawthorn’s heartbreak laid bare before ‘angry’ coach Sam Mitchell leads team huddle

‘Part of me wanted to break down in tears, part of me wanted to scream with rage, part of me wanted to throw chairs.’

ABC

Umpire felt 'threatened' by player, fan abuse after unruly AFL finale

Victoria Police has spoken to three spectators in relation to ugly incidents stemming from the fiery finale to Hawthorn's preliminary final against Brisbane at the MCG.

7NEWS

Injured Lions fan, 6, taken to hospital after being hit by can as Sam Mitchell speaks out on MCG ‘disappointment’

Sam Mitchell has condemned the behaviour from unruly Hawthorn supporters, and his own leaders, as young Lions fans got caught in the crosshairs.

THEAGE

Mitchell says MCG wasn’t safe when angry Hawks fans erupted

Hawthorn coach Sam Mitchell has called out a group of fans who abused umpires at the MCG on Saturday night, and has turned the spotlight on three of his players who he said reacted like “stunned mullets” when Jarman Impey was tackled.

GUARDIAN

Hawks coach wanted to ‘scream with rage’ after epic AFL final, as fans criticised for throwing bottles

Sam Mitchell says ‘this feeling is the pits’ after loss to Brisbane AFL Fans Association says bottle throwing an ‘ugly look for our game’ Brisbane and Hawthorn fought out one of the all-time great AFL finals , but when the siren sounded the biggest noise in the MCG was the booing. Hawks players James Sicily, Tom Barrass and Jack Ginnivan had angry words with the umpires, who then had bottles thrown at them from Hawks fans as they left the stadium on Saturday night. Continue reading...

ABC

AFL bans loom for bottle-throwing Hawks fans

Hawthorn supporters who threw bottles at umpires after a controversial finals exit face lengthy bans if identified by the AFL and Victoria Police.

7NEWS

Ugly scenes as angry Hawthorn fans hurl bottles at umpires after preliminary final loss to Brisbane

The officials were quickly escorted off the field after the controversial finish.

ABC

MCC threatens lifetime bans over AFL final bottle throwing incident

The Melbourne Cricket Club says it wants footy fans who threw bottles at umpires during the preliminary final to be banned for life.

THEAGE

Five assaulted, bottles thrown at umpires as ugly scenes erupt at tense prelim final

The spectators who threw items at umpires face bans of at least five years, while another football fan claimed she and her son were pelted with nachos at the MCG.

More Sport stories

Latest cross-verified stories

Browse all stories from September 2026 in the archive.