Federal Court orders Fortescue to pay $150m to Yindjibarndi traditional owners for cultural loss
Consensus Summary
The Federal Court ruled that Fortescue Metals Group must pay $150.1 million to the Yindjibarndi Ngurra Aboriginal Corporation (YNAC) for cultural losses caused by the Solomon Hub iron ore mine, the largest native title compensation in Australian history. The mine, operational since 2013, has generated $80 billion in revenue for Fortescue but was built without the Yindjibarndi’s consent, despite their exclusive native title rights being recognized in 2017. Justice Stephen Burley’s decision followed a 2022 claim by YNAC, which sought $1.8 billion for cultural damage, economic loss, and site destruction. Both sources confirm 240 heritage sites were impacted, with 140 completely destroyed, and that Fortescue initially resisted compensation, arguing for a cap of $8–8.1 million. The ruling highlights the deep cultural and spiritual harm suffered by the Yindjibarndi, with elders describing trauma and the destruction of their connection to country. While the payout is historic, Yindjibarndi leaders expressed disappointment, calling it insufficient compared to Fortescue’s profits. The ABC notes the WA government will not contribute to the compensation, unlike in similar cases where state governments were held liable.
✓ Verified by 2+ sources
Key details reported by multiple sources:
- Federal Court Justice Stephen Burley ordered Fortescue to pay $150,100,000 in compensation to the Yindjibarndi Ngurra Aboriginal Corporation (YNAC) for cultural loss, with an additional $100,000 for economic loss.
- The compensation is the largest native title payout in Australian history, following a decades-long legal battle.
- The Solomon Hub iron ore mine, operated by Fortescue, has generated an estimated $80 billion in revenue since operations began in 2013.
- The Yindjibarndi people were awarded exclusive native title rights to their land, including the Solomon Hub mine area, in 2017.
- The compensation claim was lodged in 2022 after Fortescue’s failed appeal of the Yindjibarndi’s native title claim.
- Justice Burley found that 240 heritage sites were relocated or destroyed, with 140 cultural sites completely destroyed by mining activities.
- The Yindjibarndi Ngurra Aboriginal Corporation (YNAC) sought $1.8 billion in total compensation, including $1 billion for cultural damage, $678 million for economic loss, $34.85 million for site destruction, and $112.13 million for social disharmony.
- Fortescue argued the compensation should be capped at $8.1 million, while the WA government suggested $5–10 million.
- Justice Burley traveled to the Pilbara in 2023 for an on-country court hearing to hear from Yindjibarndi elders and community members.
- The courtroom in Perth was packed with Yindjibarndi elders, community members, and children, with over 1,000 people watching the livestream.
Points of Difference
Details reported by only one source:
- Elders described the $150.1 million payout as 'peanuts' compared to Fortescue’s billions in revenue from the Solomon Hub mines.
- The full judgment was suppressed to protect commercially sensitive information, with only a summary read out in court.
- The WA government will not be asked to contribute to the compensation bill, unlike in the McArthur River mine case where the NT government was liable.
- Yindjibarndi elders Judith Coppin and Wendy Hubert expressed disappointment, noting many elders had died before the verdict was delivered.
- A composite image of Andrew Forrest and Michael Woodley was included in the ABC article.
- Justice Burley’s 350-page judgment recounted elders’ testimony that their 'Nurra, soul and spirit [were] destroyed' by mining activities.
- Fortescue funded a 'breakaway group' (Wirlu-Murra Yindjibarndi Aboriginal Corporation) in 2010, paying $500 each to attend a meeting that approved a land use agreement.
- Lawyers for YNAC argued that Fortescue’s actions caused profound cultural and spiritual harm, including rupturing community and family ties.
- Fortescue’s closing submissions claimed that social disharmony losses were not compensable under native title laws.
- The court heard that the land had become 'barren' from mining activities, as described by elders.
Contradictions
Conflicting information between sources:
- The Guardian states Fortescue sought to cap compensation at $8 million, while the ABC says Fortescue argued for a cap of $8.1 million.
- The Guardian specifies the economic loss awarded was $100,000, while the ABC states it was $150,000.
Source Articles
Fortescue ordered to pay Yindjibarndi traditional owners $150m in record native title payout
Federal court found miner’s Solomon Hub iron ore mine caused cultural and social harm, including the destruction of 140 heritage sites Follow our Australia news live blog for latest updates Get our breaking news email , free app or daily news podcast Mining company Fortescue has been ordered to pay $150m in compensation to traditional owners over cultural losses caused by the multi-billion dollar Solomon Hub iron ore mine – the largest compensation payout in native title history. The mine, which
Record payout after billionaire built mine without traditional owners' permission
Andrew Forrest's Fortescue has been ordered to pay $150 million to WA traditional owners after mining their land without permission.