← Back to Stories

Top-rated Italian restaurants in Melbourne and Sydney from the Good Food Guide

4 hours ago2 articles from 2 sources

Consensus Summary

The two articles highlight top-rated Italian restaurants from the Good Food Guide, with THEAGE focusing on Melbourne’s 10 best hatted spots and SMH covering 12 in Sydney. Both lists emphasize quality, service, and signature dishes, though Melbourne’s entries lean toward traditional, old-school hospitality with a focus on classics like pasta and wine pairings. Sydney’s selections showcase a mix of creative, seasonal twists on Italian cuisine, with standout dishes ranging from roast chicken agnolotti to wood-fired pizzette. While Melbourne’s list includes hidden basement gems and outer-suburban winery restaurants, Sydney’s features harborside institutions and playful, modern interpretations of Italian flavors. The Good Food Guide’s hat system serves as a consistent marker of quality across both cities, though the tone and culinary approaches differ, reflecting local dining cultures.

✓ Verified by 2+ sources

Key details reported by multiple sources:

  • The Good Food Guide awards restaurants with 'hats' as a mark of quality, and these lists are based on anonymous, independently paid reviews.
  • Bar Olo in Melbourne (165 Nicholson Street, Carlton) is praised for its well-executed Italian classics, including saltimbocca, tiramisu, and a signature pappardelle ripiene with field mushrooms.
  • Cecconi’s in Melbourne (basement, 61 Flinders Lane) has been operating for 20+ years in its current Flinders Lane location (and 10+ years before that at another site).
  • Tipo 00 in Melbourne (361 Little Bourke Street) is a perennial favorite, known for its ox tongue starter and pumpkin ravioli with taleggio and sage.
  • The Good Food Guide lists restaurants like Bar Olo, Cecconi’s, and Tipo 00 as top-rated Italian spots in Melbourne, with mentions of their signature dishes and service styles.
  • Sydney’s 10 William Street (Paddington) is noted for its convivial atmosphere, well-priced wines, and signature dishes like scallop crudo, mozzarella-stuffed suppli, and tiramisu.
  • Vin-Cenzo’s in Sydney (174 Liverpool Street, Darlinghurst) is praised for its roast chicken and mortadella agnolotti in brodo, a standout dish.
  • Otto Ristorante in Sydney (6 Cowper Wharf Road, Woolloomooloo) is a harborside institution with a wide-ranging wine list and Italian classics like gnocco fritto and scallop tartare.
  • The Good Food Guide’s Sydney list includes restaurants like Pilu at Freshwater (Moore Road) and Fontana (133A Redfern Street), known for Sardinian roots and creative Italian-ish dishes.

Points of Difference

Details reported by only one source:

The Age
  • Caterina’s Cucina e Bar in Melbourne (221 Queen Street) is a weekdays-only basement power-lunch hub with a 600-wine list and daily specials like goldband snapper crudo.
  • Centonove in Kew (109 Cotham Road) offers a prix-fixe menu with two ($89) or three ($109) courses, featuring dishes like fried zucchini flowers with caviar-specked bisque.
  • Di Stasio Citta in Melbourne (45 Spring Street) is described as a stark concrete gallery with a focus on stuzzichini and a well-dressed, high-end clientele.
  • Lagotto in Melbourne (1 York Street, Fitzroy North) attracts a young professional crowd and is known for its parmesan foam and black-garlic ketchup dishes.
  • La Vetta in Mickleham (2335 Mickleham Road) is a winery restaurant balancing accessibility and specialness, with global ingredients like Moreton Bay bug and curry leaves.
  • Lucia in South Melbourne (11 Eastern Road) features a striking bar and elegant dining room, with dishes like crisp-skinned duck with quince and caramelized fennel.
  • Trattoria Emilia in Melbourne (360 Little Collins Street) is praised for its industrial-chic ambiance and masterful pasta, including signature tortelloni.
  • The Good Food Guide’s Melbourne list includes honorable mentions like Bar Olo’s sibling Scopri, and storied Bourke Street dining room now under Edition Group stewardship.
Sydney Morning Herald
  • Cricca in Windsor (1/135 George Street) reframes suburban dining with next-generation chef Alessio Nogarotto and seasonal Hawkesbury produce, including wood-fired oysters and flatbread.
  • Neptune’s Grotto in Sydney (44 Bridge Street) is described as a romantic, Goodfellas-esque enclave with dishes like olives all’ascolana and pork sausage gramigna pasta.
  • Pilu at Freshwater (Moore Road) highlights Sardinian roots with hand-made culurgiones and roast suckling pig, emphasizing multi-generational family dining.
  • Fontana in Redfern (133A Redfern Street) is noted for its restraint and gusto, with dishes like schie fritte (fried prawns) and gnochetti con salsiccia.
  • a’Mare in Barangaroo (1 Barangaroo Avenue) offers harbour views, swish trolley service, and dishes like seafood risotto and wagyu ragu gnocchi.
  • Attenzione! in Redfern (180 Redfern Street) features oversized pici pasta and playful, post-structuralist Italian cuisine, including whipped brown butter and cornflakes on bread.
  • Cibaria in Manly (55 N Steyne) is a multi-part venue with a bar, cafe-gelateria, and restaurant, known for wood-fired pizzette and raw scallops with finger lime.
  • Gran Torino in Double Bay (24 Bay Street) is a revival of Neil Perry’s Cantonese diner, focusing on impeccable produce and dishes like vitello tonnato and kingfish with salsa verde.
  • Osteria Mucca on Australia Street is described as a luxury spot with alternative cuts like coppa di testa and house ricotta, reflecting its butcher heritage.

Contradictions

Conflicting information between sources:

  • The Good Food Guide’s Melbourne list in THEAGE focuses on restaurants like Bar Olo and Tipo 00, while SMH’s Sydney list does not mention Melbourne at all, creating a geographical divide in coverage.
  • THEAGE emphasizes 'old-school' hospitality and service in Melbourne’s Italian restaurants, while SMH’s Sydney list highlights more modern, creative, and sometimes playful approaches to Italian cuisine.
  • THEAGE’s list includes outer-fringe suburbs like Mickleham (La Vetta), whereas SMH’s Sydney list focuses on central and coastal areas like Paddington, Darlinghurst, and Freshwater.

Source Articles

THEAGE

The Good Food guide to Melbourne’s top 10 hatted Italian restaurants

Whether it’s an inner-city power lunch powerhouse or a swish find on the city’s fringe, here are Melbourne’s molto buono Italian stallions.

3 June 2026
SMH

12 of Sydney’s best hatted Italian restaurants from the Good Food Guide

The Emerald City’s top spots for pasta, pizza and all things pomodoro from the Good Food Guide 2026.

3 June 2026