← Back to Stories

Australia’s surrogacy law reforms proposed by ALRC to address exploitation and accessibility

By Updated 19 November 20263 articles from 2 independent sources

Consensus Summary

Australia’s surrogacy laws are under scrutiny following the Australian Law Reform Commission’s (ALRC) landmark review, which proposes sweeping changes to address exploitation, accessibility, and legal inconsistencies. The ALRC’s report, released in late 2026, recommends maintaining the ban on commercial surrogacy while expanding financial compensation for surrogates and establishing a nationally consistent legal framework. The review was initiated in 2024 by the Attorney-General to protect the rights of children born through surrogacy and provide clarity for intended parents and surrogates alike. The ALRC found that current laws drive many Australians to seek surrogacy overseas, where risks of harm and exploitation are higher, with more than 300 children born annually through international arrangements—accounting for 80% of all Australian surrogacy births.

The push for reform stems from decades of fragmented state and territory laws, which create barriers for domestic surrogacy while failing to adequately safeguard the rights of all parties involved. For example, some states require police checks or mandate that surrogates have previously given birth, while others impose strict advertising restrictions. These inconsistencies not only complicate the process for intended parents but also leave surrogates financially vulnerable, as current altruistic models only allow reimbursement for certain expenses without broader compensation. The ALRC’s report highlights that domestic surrogacy births have tripled from 27 in 2014 to 84 in 2023, while overseas surrogacy has surged from 246 in 2015 to 375 in 2024, reflecting growing demand despite legal hurdles.

Key figures in the debate include ALRC Justice Mordy Bromberg, who emphasized that good surrogacy laws should balance enabling family formation with protecting against exploitation. Bromberg noted that current laws fail to achieve either goal, often leaving surrogates worse off financially and forcing intended parents to navigate complex legal processes. Roxanne Brewer, a Gold Coast mother who served as a surrogate for strangers in 2019, supports expanded compensation, arguing it could encourage more women to consider surrogacy. Meanwhile, religious groups like the Australian Christian Lobby and the Australian Catholic Bishops Conference oppose reforms, citing concerns that surrogacy severs a child’s biological and emotional bonds with their gestational mother. The Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia, however, backed the ALRC’s proposal to recognize intended parents as legal parents from birth, arguing it aligns with the parties’ intentions and reduces post-birth legal complications.

While both ABC and the Guardian agree on the core recommendations—such as greater surrogate compensation, a national framework, and stricter oversight of overseas arrangements—they differ in emphasis. The ABC focuses on the personal stories of intended parents like Emilie Miller, who became a quadriplegic at age 12 and relied on surrogacy to have her son Max, highlighting the emotional and legal challenges of the current system. The Guardian, however, underscores the broader systemic issues, including the rise in overseas surrogacy and the need for international legal safeguards. The ABC also details specific state-level restrictions, such as South Australia’s police check requirement, while the Guardian emphasizes the ALRC’s call for licensed support organizations to facilitate domestic surrogacy arrangements. Both outlets note that the federal government will consider the recommendations in consultation with states and territories, though no immediate legislative changes are planned.

The ALRC’s report has sparked debate over whether Australia’s surrogacy laws can be reformed without compromising ethical standards. Critics argue that expanding compensation risks commodifying children, while supporters contend that better-regulated domestic options would reduce exploitation and provide clearer legal protections. The proposed National Surrogacy Register, which would allow children born through surrogacy to access their gestational mother’s details at age 16, is another contentious recommendation. As the federal government weighs the ALRC’s findings, the outcome could reshape surrogacy in Australia, balancing the needs of intended parents, surrogates, and the children at the heart of these arrangements. The process underscores the tension between accessibility and protection in family law reform.

✓ Verified by 2+ sources

Key details reported by multiple sources:

  • The Attorney-General asked the Australian Law Reform Commission (ALRC) to examine Australia’s surrogacy laws in 2024, focusing on protecting the rights of children born through surrogacy.
  • The ALRC recommended maintaining Australia’s ban on commercial surrogacy and only allowing altruistic surrogacy, where surrogates are not paid a fee or allowed to profit.
  • More than 300 Australian children are born through overseas surrogacy arrangements each year, accounting for an estimated four in five (80%) of Australian surrogacy births, according to the ALRC.
  • The ALRC proposed that intended parents be recognized as legal parents from birth if a domestic surrogacy arrangement was approved before conception, supported by the Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia in its submission earlier this year.
  • The ALRC’s report found that about 80% of Australians’ surrogacy arrangements happen outside the country due to domestic legal barriers.
  • Roxanne Brewer was a surrogate in 2020, having decided to become one for strangers in 2019.
  • The ALRC recommended a nationally consistent surrogacy framework overseen by a regulator to streamline the current patchwork of state and territory laws.
  • The ALRC recommended surrogates be entitled to greater financial compensation for the impacts of pregnancy and childbirth, including a monthly payment capped by a national regulator.
  • The ALRC’s report found that domestic gestational births increased from 27 in 2014 to 84 in 2023, while overseas surrogacy births rose from 246 in 2015 to 375 in 2024.

How the outlets covered it

2 outlets reported this story. ABC News published first; The Guardian followed 6.1 h later.

Who reported which facts

FactABCGuardian
The Attorney-General asked the Australian Law Reform Commission (ALRC) to examine Australia’s surrogacy laws in 2024, focusing on protecting the rights of children born through surrogacy.✓·
The ALRC recommended maintaining Australia’s ban on commercial surrogacy and only allowing altruistic surrogacy, where surrogates are not paid a fee or allowed to profit.✓·
More than 300 Australian children are born through overseas surrogacy arrangements each year, accounting for an estimated four in five (80%) of Australian surrogacy births, according to the ALRC.✓·
The ALRC proposed that intended parents be recognized as legal parents from birth if a domestic surrogacy arrangement was approved before conception, supported by the Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia in its submission earlier this year.✓·
The ALRC’s report found that about 80% of Australians’ surrogacy arrangements happen outside the country due to domestic legal barriers.✓·
Roxanne Brewer was a surrogate in 2020, having decided to become one for strangers in 2019.✓·
The ALRC recommended a nationally consistent surrogacy framework overseen by a regulator to streamline the current patchwork of state and territory laws.✓·
The ALRC recommended surrogates be entitled to greater financial compensation for the impacts of pregnancy and childbirth, including a monthly payment capped by a national regulator.✓✓

Times are when each outlet published, from its own feed, in Sydney time. Outlets whose feeds don’t give a publish time are listed last. Ticks show which outlets the analysis found reporting each fact. See how this works.

Points of Difference

Details reported by only one source:

ABC News
  • Emilie Miller and her husband David had their son Max through surrogacy, with Max being seven months old as of the reporting date.
  • The ALRC’s report included 47 recommendations, with a focus on enabling responsible surrogacy while safeguarding against exploitation.
  • The Australian Christian Lobby and the Australian Catholic Bishops Conference opposed the ALRC’s recommendations, arguing that surrogacy violates children’s rights to biological and emotional bonds.
  • The Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia supported the proposal that intended parents be recognized as legal parents from birth, stating it better reflects parties’ intentions.
  • The ALRC recommended replacing certain criminal offences related to prohibited surrogacy arrangements with civil penalties for easier enforcement.
The Guardian
  • The ALRC’s investigation aimed to harmonize laws with international legal obligations while protecting human rights, particularly the rights of the child.
  • The report recommended licensed surrogacy support organizations to help intended parents connect with surrogates.
  • The ALRC proposed that intended parents entering overseas surrogacy arrangements must register, receive guidance, and obtain legal advice in both Australia and the overseas country.
  • The report noted that inconsistent surrogacy laws and criminal sanctions are driving parents overseas and arrangements underground, increasing risks of harm.

Where the reporting differs

Details that conflict, or appear in only some outlets:

  • The ABC states that Roxanne Brewer became a surrogate in 2019, while the Guardian does not provide a specific year for her involvement.
  • The ABC mentions that about 20% of surrogacy arrangements in Australia are between strangers, while the Guardian does not provide this specific statistic.

Source Articles

ABC

Compensation could encourage more Australian surrogates, supporters say

A cousin's gift gave Emilie Miller her son. Now, a national review wants to make surrogacy easier for everyone.

ABC

Australia's surrogacy laws could receive major shake-up under landmark review

Surrogates would be entitled to greater financial compensation for the impacts of pregnancy and childbirth under sweeping changes proposed by the country's law reform body.

GUARDIAN

Australia’s ‘problematic’ surrogacy laws could be transformed under proposed changes

Law reform body recommends ongoing ban on commercial surrogacy, but greater compensation for surrogates, and safeguards around who the child’s legal parents are Get our breaking news email , free app or daily news podcast Surrogates would be entitled to full compensation, with a nationally consistent framework ensuring domestic surrogacy is a viable option to parenthood, under proposed changes by Australia’s law reform body. The Australian Law Reform Commission has been investigating how to bett

More Health stories

Latest cross-verified stories

Browse all stories from November 2026 in the archive.