US jury rules Meta and YouTube liable for designing addictive platforms harming young users
Consensus Summary
A California jury ruled Meta and YouTube liable for negligently designing addictive platforms that harmed a young user, awarding $3 million in compensatory damages split 70-30 between the companies. The plaintiff, KGM, testified her addiction to YouTube (starting at age six) and Instagram (age nine) led to severe mental health issues by age 13, including depression, self-harm, and diagnosed disorders. Jurors found both companies knew or should have known of the risks but failed to warn users adequately, rejecting defenses that blamed KGMâs troubled home life or disputed her platform usage. The case mirrors tobacco industry lawsuits, with features like infinite scroll and autoplay cited as engineered addiction tools. Snap and TikTok settled beforehand, while Meta and YouTube plan appeals. The verdict follows a New Mexico ruling where Meta paid $375 million for enabling child exploitation on its platforms, signaling growing legal scrutiny. Over 20 similar 'bellwether' trials are pending, potentially reshaping accountability for tech giantsâ role in youth mental health crises. Australian law firms are already exploring similar cases, and regulators are tightening digital safety laws, including a proposed 'duty of care' for platforms.
â Verified by 2+ sources
Key details reported by multiple sources:
- A Los Angeles jury found Meta and YouTube liable for negligence in designing addictive products that harmed a young user (KGM), awarding $3 million in compensatory damages (split 70-30 between Meta and Google/YouTube) on June 12, 2024.
- The plaintiff, known as KGM (or Kaley GM in ABC), began using YouTube at age six and Instagram at age nine, alleging her addiction led to depression, self-harm, body dysmorphic disorder, and social phobia by age 13.
- Jurors found both companies knew or should have known their platforms posed dangers to minors and failed to warn users adequately, with Meta assigned 70% of liability and YouTube 30%.
- The trial lasted six weeks, featuring testimony from KGM, Meta/YouTube executives, whistleblowers, and expert witnesses on addiction and social media harm.
- Snap and TikTok settled with KGM before the trial began, while Meta and YouTube plan to appeal the ruling.
- A separate New Mexico jury ordered Meta to pay $375 million in civil penalties the day before the California verdict for misleading consumers about platform safety and enabling child sexual exploitation.
- The California case is the first of over 20 'bellwether' trials scheduled to set legal precedent for thousands of pending lawsuits against Meta, TikTok, YouTube, and Snap.
- The plaintiffâs lawyers compared the case to the 1990s tobacco lawsuits, arguing features like infinite scroll and autoplay were designed to engineer addiction.
Points of Difference
Details reported by only one source:
- The jury awarded punitive damages to be decided in a later phase of the trial (not yet finalized).
- Metaâs spokesperson stated KGMâs mental health issues were caused by 'significant emotional and physical abuse' at home, not social media use.
- The consolidated lawsuit includes over 1,600 plaintiffs, including 350 families and 250 school districts.
- Australian law firms (Shine Lawyers, Slater and Gordon) are investigating potential cases based on the US ruling.
- The plaintiff was awarded $4.3 million total (including punitive damages), with Meta liable for 70% ($3.02m) and Google for 30% ($1.29m).
- Jurors recommended an additional $3 million in punitive damages for malice, oppression, or fraud.
- YouTube disputed the plaintiffâs usage records, claiming she averaged less than a minute per day on the platform.
- Laura Marquez-Garrett (Social Media Victims Law Center) called the case 'a vehicle, not an outcome,' emphasizing its historic nature.
- The verdict could influence over 40 state attorneys-general lawsuits against Meta for contributing to a youth mental health crisis.
- Jasmine Enberg (Scalable) stated '$3 million is a slap on the wrist' for Meta/YouTube, noting redesigning platforms could threaten their business models.
- YouTubeâs Luis Li apologized to the plaintiff but argued punitive damages should not be part of a 'social crusade'.
Contradictions
Conflicting information between sources:
- The Guardian reports the compensatory damages award as $3 million, while ABC states the total award (including punitive damages) is $4.3 million.
- Metaâs spokesperson in the Guardian denies social media caused KGMâs harm, citing her 'difficult home life,' but ABC reports Meta argued this during trial without explicitly denying social mediaâs role in the verdict.
- ABC claims jurors recommended $3 million in punitive damages, but the Guardian states punitive damages will be decided in a later phase (no final amount yet).
- The Guardian mentions a separate New Mexico case where Meta was ordered to pay $375 million, while ABC and NewsCorp Australia both reference this but do not specify the exact timing difference (Guardian says 'just one day before').
- ABC reports YouTube disputed the plaintiffâs usage records (averaging <1 minute/day), but the Guardian does not mention this specific rebuttal.
Source Articles
Meta and YouTube designed addictive products that harmed young people, jury finds
Six-week trial including whistleblowers and top executives at Meta and YouTube was first of its kind to go to trial Sign up for the Breaking News US email to get newsletter alerts in your inbox Meta a...
Unpacking the social media addiction ruling against Meta and YouTube
A US jury has found Instagram and YouTube were designed to be addictive to young users, in a landmark trial experts say could influence thousands of similar lawsuits....
Meta and Google found liable in landmark social media addiction lawsuit
The verdict could mark a âturning point in the global backlash against their platforms' perceived mental health harms to youth....
Law firms investigate possible Australian cases after US jury finds Meta and YouTube designed addictive products
Courts in Australia may be willing to hold social media companies accountable for real-world harm, lawyers say Follow our Australia news live blog for latest updates Get our breaking news email , free...
âAccountability has arrivedâ: US jury finds Meta, YouTube guilty in landmark social media addiction trial
Meta and YouTube have just lost a landmark court case about the addictive design of their platforms, a signal that âaccountability has arrivedâ....
'Accountability has arrived': Meta and Google found liable in landmark social media addiction lawsuit
The case was brought on by a 20-year-old woman who accused the tech companies of causing harm by deliberately designing addictive platforms which worsened her mental health....