NFL player Cam Skattebo’s controversial denial of CTE and asthma legitimacy sparks backlash
Consensus Summary
New York Giants running back Cam Skattebo faced widespread backlash after dismissing chronic traumatic encephalopathy (CTE) and asthma as 'fake' during a podcast interview. Skattebo, a 2025 rookie drafted in the fourth round, called CTE an 'excuse' and joked about asthma, prompting an apology where he framed his remarks as a 'tasteless joke' not meant seriously. Both articles confirm his comments sparked criticism due to the scientific consensus on CTE’s link to repeated head trauma and asthma’s prevalence, with studies showing high rates of CTE in former NFL players. Skattebo’s mother defended his comments as sarcastic, sharing her own asthma struggles, while the Giants remained silent on the matter. The two Guardian articles align on core facts like Skattebo’s draft year, rookie stats, and his apology but differ on study timelines, specific player examples, and emphasis on fan reception or the mother’s response.
✓ Verified by 2+ sources
Key details reported by multiple sources:
- Cam Skattebo, 24, is a running back for the New York Giants drafted in the 2025 NFL draft (4th round out of Arizona State)
- Skattebo made comments on the Bring the Juice podcast dismissing chronic traumatic encephalopathy (CTE) as an 'excuse' and asthma as 'fake', saying 'just breathe air'
- CTE is a degenerative brain condition linked to repeated head trauma, with symptoms including mood swings, depression, suicidal thoughts, and memory loss
- A 2017 study found CTE in 110 of 111 former football players examined, and the NFL acknowledged a link between football and CTE in 2016
- Skattebo scored seven touchdowns and ran for 410 yards in his rookie season (2025) before an ankle injury ended it
- Skattebo apologized on X (formerly Twitter) for his comments, calling them a 'tasteless joke' and saying he was not trying to downplay seriousness
Points of Difference
Details reported by only one source:
- Skattebo’s mother, Becky Skattebo, replied to her son’s apology post, stating she is asthmatic and shared a personal anecdote about Cam needing her inhaler, calling his comments sarcastic
- The article mentions a 2017 study (not 2023) finding CTE in 110 of 111 former football players
- The article includes the Giants fan popularity context: Skattebo was a 'popular figure' in his rookie season due to his 'physical running style'
- The article references a 2023 Boston University study finding CTE in roughly 92% of former NFL players whose brains were examined
- It lists specific former NFL players with diagnosed CTE (Junior Seau and Aaron Hernandez) as examples
- The article notes the Giants have not publicly commented on Skattebo’s remarks
Contradictions
Conflicting information between sources:
- Article 1 states a 2017 study found CTE in 110 of 111 former football players, while Article 2 cites a 2023 Boston University study with 92% prevalence in examined players
- Article 1 mentions Skattebo’s mother’s response about her asthma and Cam’s childhood anecdote, but Article 2 does not include this detail
- Article 1 describes Skattebo as a 'popular figure' with Giants fans in his rookie season, while Article 2 does not emphasize fan reception
- Article 1 includes the Giants’ lack of public comment indirectly (via Skattebo’s mother’s post), but Article 2 explicitly states the Giants have 'not publicly commented'
- Article 1 does not mention Junior Seau or Aaron Hernandez as examples of CTE cases, while Article 2 does
Source Articles
‘It’s an excuse’: New York Giants’ Cam Skattebo says CTE and asthma are ‘fake’
Skattebo calls CTE and asthma ‘fake’ on podcast Comments draw backlash citing medical consensus Giants have not publicly responded to remarks New York Giants running back Cam Skattebo is facing backla...
Giants’ Cam Skattebo says his denial of CTE and asthma were part of a ‘tasteless joke’
Running back retracts comments he gave on podcast Player’s mother says she is asthmatic New York Giants running back Cam Skattebo has apologized for saying that chronic traumatic encephalopathy (CTE) ...