Ben Roberts-Smith arrested over alleged Afghan war crimes and charged with murder
Consensus Summary
Ben Roberts-Smith, Australia’s most decorated living soldier and Victoria Cross recipient, was arrested at Sydney Airport on Tuesday, 23 April 2024, in connection with alleged war crimes committed in Afghanistan between 2009 and 2012. He is expected to face five counts of murder as a war crime, with a maximum penalty of life imprisonment for each charge. The allegations include personal executions and orders to execute unarmed Afghan civilians and prisoners, including an elderly man with a prosthetic leg in 2009 and detainees in 2011 and 2012. A five-year investigation by the Office of the Special Investigator (OSI) and Australian Federal Police (AFP) secured witness testimonies from SAS soldiers and Afghan survivors, including the wife of Ali Jan, who alleged Roberts-Smith ordered his execution after kicking him off a cliff. The case is based on eyewitness accounts rather than circumstantial evidence, with some witnesses stating they cooperated with investigators to uphold accountability. Roberts-Smith previously lost a defamation case in 2023, where a Federal Court judge ruled to the civil standard that he was involved in four murders, though the High Court later refused his appeal. Despite his fall from grace, political figures like Pauline Hanson have pledged unwavering support, while opposition leaders have avoided direct criticism of the arrest. The charges mark a historic moment in Australia, as Roberts-Smith’s prosecution could strip him of his medals and set a precedent for accountability among military personnel. The Australian War Memorial is reviewing its displays of Roberts-Smith’s achievements, and the case has reignited debates about military justice and the role of senior officers in overseeing deployments.
✓ Verified by 2+ sources
Key details reported by multiple sources:
- Ben Roberts-Smith was arrested at Sydney Airport on Tuesday, 23 April 2024, by the Australian Federal Police (AFP) and the Office of the Special Investigator (OSI) in relation to alleged war crimes in Afghanistan between 2009 and 2012
- He is expected to be charged with five counts of war crime—murder, with a maximum penalty of life imprisonment for each count
- The alleged incidents include murders of unarmed Afghan civilians and prisoners, including an elderly man with a prosthetic leg in 2009 and detainees in 2011 and 2012
- Roberts-Smith was awarded the Victoria Cross in 2010 for actions in Afghanistan and previously denied any wrongdoing, though a 2023 Federal Court ruling found allegations of his involvement in four murders to be true to the civil standard of 'balance of probabilities'
- The investigation involved witness testimonies from SAS soldiers and Afghan survivors, including the wife of Ali Jan, who alleged Roberts-Smith ordered his execution after kicking him off a cliff in 2011
- Pauline Hanson publicly stated she would 'not abandon' Roberts-Smith, while Greens senator David Shoebridge welcomed the arrest as a 'moment of accountability'
- The Office of the Special Investigator (OSI) and AFP conducted a five-year investigation, involving phone taps, raids, and securing witness cooperation
- Roberts-Smith was previously involved in a defamation case against *The Age* and *Sydney Morning Herald*, which he lost in 2023, with the High Court refusing his appeal in September 2023
- The charges stem from allegations Roberts-Smith personally executed or ordered executions of detainees, including during a 'blooding' ritual in 2012
- Prime Minister Anthony Albanese declined to comment, stating he would not 'prejudice a matter that is before the courts'
Points of Difference
Details reported by only one source:
- Pauline Hanson's party (One Nation) is surging in the polls, and she framed her support for Roberts-Smith as a rejection of 'politicians abandoning' him
- Former PM Tony Abbott criticized the arrest process, stating 'why wasn’t this picked up prior to his gallantry awards?' and questioned why senior officers allegedly failed to address alleged brutality earlier
- The Greens' David Shoebridge criticized the 'gaping hole' in accountability for senior officers overseeing Afghanistan deployments and called for a dedicated war crimes investigation unit within the AFP
- The investigation secured cooperation from SAS eyewitnesses who alleged Roberts-Smith executed or directed executions of at least half a dozen detainees, including a 2012 'blooding' incident when he was Australia's most decorated Commonwealth soldier in Afghanistan
- The case against Roberts-Smith is described as 'not circumstantial' but based on 'witness accounts of decorated SAS soldiers and Afghan War veterans'
- An anonymous SAS eyewitness stated they assisted OSI because 'no Australian soldier was above the law' and that the war crime involved a defenceless detainee 'after the dust has settled'
- The article details the 2016 Brereton Inquiry, which found credible evidence of 39 alleged executions by SAS soldiers, prompting the creation of the OSI
- The AFP and OSI conducted phone taps, planted listening devices, and raids as part of the investigation
- The AFP confirmed Roberts-Smith was arrested at the domestic terminal of Sydney Airport and expected to face a NSW court later on Tuesday
- The charges include allegations Roberts-Smith 'intentionally caused the death' of a person in April 2009 and 'aided, abetted, counselled or procured' another death on the same day in Kakarak, Uruzgan Province
- The other three charges relate to murders of civilians in Darwan and Syahchow in September and October 2012
- Pauline Hanson posted on X (formerly Twitter) that Roberts-Smith's arrest occurred 'in front of his twin 15-year-old girls'
- The article notes that the 2023 defamation ruling was made to the civil 'balance of probabilities' standard, not the criminal 'beyond reasonable doubt' standard, suggesting the AFP may have new evidence
- The article includes a detailed description of the 2009 Whiskey 108 raid, where Roberts-Smith allegedly ordered the execution of an elderly man and killed a disabled man with a prosthetic leg, whose leg was later used as a drinking vessel by SAS troops
- The article mentions the Australian War Memorial is reviewing its display of Roberts-Smith's achievements
- The Australian War Memorial is reviewing its display of Ben Roberts-Smith's exhibits following his arrest
- The article includes a brief mention of unrelated stories (Trump's Iran deadline, Rohan Dennis' domestic violence case, etc.) as part of an 'Afternoon Update' format
- AFP Commissioner Krissy Barrett stated the arrest involved 'circumstances that constitute war crimes' and that Roberts-Smith was allegedly involved in the deaths of Afghan nationals between 2009 and 2012
- The article includes a detailed recounting of the 2018 defamation trial, where Roberts-Smith sued newspapers for portraying him as a war criminal, and the court found the allegations true to the civil standard
- The article describes the 2012 incident where Roberts-Smith allegedly kicked Ali Jan off a cliff and ordered his execution, with Ali Jan's body later being dragged to a field
Contradictions
Conflicting information between sources:
- The Guardian (Article 1) states Pauline Hanson's party is 'surging in the polls,' but this specific claim is not corroborated by other sources
- The ABC and SMH mention Roberts-Smith was arrested at the domestic terminal, but the Guardian (Article 7) does not specify the terminal type
- The SMH and The Age describe the 2009 Whiskey 108 incident in detail, but the ABC and NewsCorp Australia do not include this specific allegation
- The Guardian (Article 1) and NewsCorp Australia mention Pauline Hanson's post on X about Roberts-Smith's arrest occurring 'in front of his twin 15-year-old girls,' but this detail is not repeated in other sources
- The Guardian (Article 1) and ABC mention Roberts-Smith's appeal to the High Court was dismissed in September 2023, but the SMH states the High Court refused his application in September 2023 without specifying the month of the Federal Court ruling
Source Articles
Hanson ‘will not abandon’ Roberts-Smith
Pauline Hanson says she will not abandon Ben Roberts-Smith following revelations the decorated soldier is expected to be charged with war crimes....
Former Australian soldier Ben Roberts-Smith arrested over alleged war crimes in Afghanistan
Roberts-Smith previously failed in his attempt to sue three newspapers which published allegations he murdered unarmed civilians and bullied comrades Follow our Australia news live blog for latest upd...
Details of Ben Roberts-Smith arrest revealed by AFP commissioner - video
Australian federal police commissioner, Krissy Barrett, says a former soldier was arrested at Sydney’s domestic airport on Tuesday morning, and will face court in New South Wales later on Tuesday. She...
Afternoon Update: Ben Roberts-Smith arrested over alleged war crimes; Trump’s Iran deadline nears; and the appeal of barefoot hiking
Want to get this in your inbox every weekday? Sign up for the Afternoon Update here , and start your day with our Morning Mail newsletter . Welcome, readers, to Afternoon Update. Australia’s most deco...
Pauline Hanson says she won’t ‘abandon’ Ben Roberts-Smith as Greens argue ‘no one should be above the law’
Queensland senator ‘steadfast’ in her support of former Australian soldier as police charge him with five counts of war crime – murder Follow our Australia news live blog for latest updates Get our br...
Ben Roberts-Smith arrested by Australian federal police at Sydney airport – video
Australia’s most decorated living soldier, Ben Roberts-Smith, has been arrested at Sydney airport in relation to alleged war crimes. The Australian federal police and the Office of the Special Investi...
The arrest of Australia's most decorated war hero Ben Roberts-Smith – podcast
Australia’s most decorated living soldier, Ben Roberts-Smith, has been arrested at Sydney airport in relation to alleged war crimes. He was subsequently charged, and was due to appear in bail court on...
Ben Roberts-Smith arrested over multiple war crimes
Australia’s most famous soldier has been taken into custody over the alleged murders of unarmed Afghan civilians and prisoners....
Former soldier Ben Roberts-Smith arrested over alleged Afghanistan war crimes
SBS understands the former soldier was arrested on Tuesday and is expected to face five war crime murder charges over Afghanistan deaths....
Live moment: Ben Roberts-Smith expected to be charged with war crimes
One of Australia's most decorated soldiers, Ben Roberts-Smith, has been arrested and is expected to be charged with five counts of the war crime of murder....
Ben Roberts-Smith arrested over multiple war crimes
Australia’s most famous soldier has been taken into custody over the alleged murders of unarmed Afghan civilians and prisoners....