Luke Sayers nude photo scandal and defamation case involving his estranged wife Cate
Consensus Summary
The core story revolves around the January 2025 scandal where a nude photo of Luke Sayers was posted on his X account, leading to an AFL investigation. Luke initially blamed his estranged wife, Cate, in a statutory declaration, alleging she posted the photo and was mentally unwell. However, leaked text messages from January 22–23, 2025, show Luke denying these claims and insisting he was hacked, contradicting his earlier affidavit. Cate Sayers is suing for defamation, arguing Luke’s statements breached her confidentiality and damaged her reputation. The case hinges on whether the matter should be heard in public at the Supreme Court of Victoria or privately in federal court. Both sources agree the texts reveal Luke’s desperation to salvage his marriage while Cate remains firm in her denial of wrongdoing, framing the dispute as a battle over truth and reputation.
✓ Verified by 2+ sources
Key details reported by multiple sources:
- A photo of Luke Sayers’ penis was posted on his X account for 13 minutes in January 2025, triggering an AFL investigation.
- Luke Sayers provided a statutory declaration to Carlton Football Club and the AFL in January 2025, alleging Cate Sayers posted the photo and was mentally unwell, failing to take medication.
- Text messages between Luke and Cate Sayers from January 22–23, 2025, were released by the court, showing Luke denied blaming her and claimed he was hacked.
- Cate Sayers denies posting the photo and denies having mental illnesses or failing to take medication, alleging Luke’s claims breached her confidentiality and damaged her reputation.
- Luke Sayers applied to move Cate Sayers’ defamation lawsuit from the Supreme Court of Victoria to a federal court for a private hearing.
- Cate Sayers wants the case to remain in the Supreme Court for public scrutiny, hoping to be 'vindicated'.
- The text messages show Luke Sayers telling Cate that 'no one we know' thought she posted the photo, contradicting his earlier affidavit.
- Cate Sayers was in Europe during the January 2025 scandal when the text exchanges occurred.
Points of Difference
Details reported by only one source:
- Luke Sayers sent the statutory declaration to the AFL’s general counsel, Stephen Meade, and barrister Christopher Townshend, KC, but denies wider publication.
- Justice Andrew Watson will decide where the matter should be heard at a later date.
- The text messages include Luke Sayers saying, 'I was hacked. I’ve said it repeatedly. It’s like bs I pushed Dan Andrews down the stairs … its all crap.'
- Cate Sayers alleges Luke’s actions caused serious harm to her reputation from a breach of confidence and invasion of privacy.
- Luke Sayers left Carlton Football Club after the scandal and claims he 'f---ed up 5 years ago and made the wrong call'.
- The article uses the text messages to draw a parallel with self-preservation in relationships, comparing Luke Sayers to a husband fleeing danger in Vietnam.
- The author, Kate Halfpenny, critiques Luke Sayers for allegedly 'exposing his wife to venom' to save his own reputation.
- The piece includes a personal anecdote about marriage and self-preservation, framing the story as a 'cautionary tale'.
Contradictions
Conflicting information between sources:
- The SMH and THEAGE both report the text messages were released by the court, but THEAGE specifies the release was on Wednesday (May 28, 2026), while SMH does not mention a date.
- THEAGE states Luke Sayers admitted sending the document to the AFL’s general counsel and a barrister, while SMH does not mention this detail.
Source Articles
Sayers text messages may contradict other account of nude photo scandal
Private messages between former Carlton boss Luke Sayers and his ex-wife Cate have raised fresh questions as the pair’s court battle continues.
Women were wondering if Luke Sayers was a massive grub. Then the text messages to his wife dropped
The strained text messages between the former Carlton president and his now estranged wife, Cate, have gripped the nation this week.
Women were wondering if Luke Sayers was a massive grub. Then the text messages to his wife dropped
The strained text messages between the former Carlton president and his now estranged wife, Cate, have gripped the nation this week.