Federal Court upholds discrimination ruling against Giggle for Girls app for excluding transgender woman
Consensus Summary
The Federal Court of Australia upheld a landmark ruling on May 15, 2026, finding that transgender woman Roxanne Tickle was directly discriminated against by the Giggle for Girls app and its CEO Sall Grover. Tickle was excluded from the app in 2021 after an AI initially approved her access, but Grover manually restricted her account. The court doubled her damages from $10,000 to $20,000 and ordered Grover to pay up to $50,000 in court costs. The ruling marks the first time gender identity discrimination has been upheld under the Sex Discrimination Act since its 2013 amendments. The case hinged on whether the app's exclusion of Tickle, based on her gender-related appearance, constituted direct discrimination. Grover argued the app was a safe space for women, but the court rejected this defense, stating the discrimination was clear. Following the ruling, Opposition Leader Angus Taylor vowed to amend the Sex Discrimination Act to include a definition of biological sex, claiming it would protect single-sex spaces for women and girls. The decision has drawn praise from advocacy groups like Equality Australia, which called it a win for equality, while critics like One Nation Senator Pauline Hanson and JK Rowling have expressed opposition.
✓ Verified by 2+ sources
Key details reported by multiple sources:
- Roxanne Tickle, a transgender woman, was excluded from the Giggle for Girls app in 2021 after her account was restricted following a manual review, despite initial AI approval.
- The Full Court of the Federal Court upheld a ruling on May 15, 2026, finding Sall Grover (CEO of Giggle for Girls) directly discriminated against Tickle on the basis of her gender identity.
- Damages awarded to Tickle were doubled from $10,000 to $20,000, with additional court costs of up to $50,000 ordered against Grover and Giggle for Girls.
- The court ruled that Tickle was discriminated against twice: once when she was excluded from the app and again when her readmission was refused.
- The Giggle for Girls app was marketed as a platform exclusively for women to share experiences and provide a safe space.
- The original ruling in August 2024 found indirect discrimination against Tickle, but the appeal court found direct discrimination instead.
- Roxanne Tickle has lived as a woman since mid-2017, has a birth certificate reissued with a female sex marker, and has undergone gender-affirming surgery.
- The case is the first to claim discrimination on the basis of gender identity under the Sex Discrimination Act since its 2013 amendments.
- Opposition Leader Angus Taylor vowed to amend the Sex Discrimination Act to include a definition of biological sex, stating it would protect single-sex spaces for women and girls.
Points of Difference
Details reported by only one source:
- Justice Robert Bromwich initially ruled in 2024 that the exclusion was indirect discrimination due to the 'imposed condition of needing to appear to be a cisgendered female'.
- Sall Grover argued that sex referred to a person's sex at birth, conflicting with a 'long history' of court decisions that sex is changeable.
- Grover's lawyers attempted to invoke a carve-out of discrimination law for measures designed to achieve substantive equality between men and women, but this failed.
- Grover said on social media she was 'absolutely devastated' and claimed 'it is women who are being discriminated against'.
- Equality Australia described the ruling as a 'significant win for equality and fairness' and stated it reinforces protections for trans women.
- One Nation Senator Pauline Hanson posted on social media that she was 'disgusted' by the ruling and promised to 'back' Sall Grover in parliament.
- JK Rowling posted support for Grover on X, writing 'Good luck, Sall, may the best woman (haha) win x'.
- The Lesbian Action Group, which opposes transgender women's inclusion, supported Grover's case financially.
- The court explicitly stated that Grover's conduct, including repeatedly misgendering Tickle, was 'gratuitous, disrespectful and unnecessary' and aggravated Tickle's hurt.
- The lawsuit was first filed in December 2022, with a four-day appeal hearing held in August 2025.
- The court heard Grover described transgender women as 'male' and envisioned the app as a 'refuge away from men' to avoid 'male patterned online behaviour'.
- Grover confirmed during evidence that she regarded transgender women as 'male'.
- The app was taken offline in 2022.
Where the reporting differs
Details that conflict, or appear in only some outlets:
- ABC and SMH state the court ruled Grover's conduct, including misgendering Tickle, was 'gratuitous, disrespectful and unnecessary', but NEWSCOMAU does not mention this detail.
- ABC and NEWSCOMAU report Angus Taylor's vow to amend the Sex Discrimination Act, but only ABC and NEWSCOMAU mention Matt Canavan's support for similar changes, while SMH and Guardian do not address this.
- ABC and NEWSCOMAU state the damages were increased to $20,000 plus court costs, but SMH and Guardian specify the costs could be up to $50,000 without explicitly stating the total amount awarded beyond $20,000.
Source Articles
Ruling upheld after transgender woman excluded from female-only app
A landmark Federal Court ruling that the exclusion of a transgender woman from a female-only app constituted unlawful gender identity discrimination is upheld on appeal.
Taylor vows to amend Sex Discrimination Act following ‘Tickle v Giggle’ ruling
Opposition leader Angus Taylor has vowed to amend the Sex Discrimination Act after the Federal Court upheld a landmark ruling that the exclusion of a transgender woman from a female-only app was discriminatory.
Taylor vows to amend Sex Discrimination Act following 'Tickle v Giggle' ruling
Opposition Leader Angus Taylor has vowed to amend the Sex Discrimination Act after the Federal Court upheld a landmark ruling that the exclusion of a transgender woman from a female-only app was discriminatory.
Taylor vows change to country’s sex laws
The Liberal leader has pledged sweeping legal changes after a transgender woman won her discrimination case against a women-only app founder.
Trans woman wins landmark gender case
In a groundbreaking ruling, an app founder once backed by JK Rowling must now pay double for discriminating against a transgender user.
Giggle for Girls app discriminated against trans woman Roxanne Tickle, appeal judge rules when doubling damages
Federal court affirms an August 2024 finding that Tickle was discriminated against on the basis of her gender identity and awards her $20,000 Follow our Australia news live blog for latest updates Get our breaking news email , free app or daily news podcast The federal court has upheld a landmark decision that found a women-only social media app and its founder unlawfully discriminated against Roxanne Tickle after the transgender woman was denied access to the platform. In their judgment on Frid
Damages doubled after trans woman’s landmark discrimination win
Roxanne Tickle took the founder of women-only social media app Giggle for Girls to court after she was blocked from using the platform.