Victorian Labor Party leadership crisis over Jacinta Allan amid election speculation
Consensus Summary
Victorian Premier Jacinta Allan faces growing leadership speculation within her Labor Party as she battles negative approval ratings of -37% and internal factional pressure ahead of the November 2024 election. Two key contenders, Deputy Premier Ben Carroll (right faction) and Transport Minister Gabrielle Williams (left faction), have both dismissed challenges, but anonymous sources confirm backroom discussions are underway. Allanâs unpopularity stems from her handling of corruption scandals like the âBig Buildâ and the cancelled Commonwealth Games, as well as her perceived disconnect with voters. While most MPs publicly back her, factional powerbrokersâparticularly from the Socialist Leftâs south-east groupingâare reportedly pushing for a change, though they deny involvement. The ALPâs 2013 rules require a 60% caucus vote and member approval, but Victorian state rules remain untested. Despite united public denials, the risk of a self-fulfilling prophecy looms, with some arguing a challenge could destabilize the party further. Polling suggests Labor may lose up to 20 seats, though party officials downplay these projections. The election looms in less than nine months, leaving little time for a potential leadership transition without risking costly by-elections or prolonged instability.
â Verified by 2+ sources
Key details reported by multiple sources:
- Jacinta Allan is Victorian Premier and faces leadership speculation ahead of the November 2024 state election
- Deputy Premier Ben Carroll (right faction) and Transport Infrastructure Minister Gabrielle Williams (left faction) are the most likely leadership contenders
- Allanâs net approval rating is -37% according to DemosAU (Herald Sun) and Resolve polling (Age), making her the only state leader in negative territory
- Allan dismissed leadership speculation as âanonymous gossipâ and âscallywagâ comments, stating she has âgreat support from my strong and united teamâ
- The ALPâs 2013 national party rules require a vote of party members and caucus, with >60% support needed to replace a sitting premier (though Victorian state rules are untested)
- Victoriaâs last Labor leadership spill occurred in 1999, with no formal challenge since
- Allan became Victorian Premier in September 2023 after succeeding Daniel Andrews
- The Victorian Labor caucus has 69 seats, with the Socialist Left faction holding ~39 seats
Points of Difference
Details reported by only one source:
- Allanâs unpopularity is linked to her handling of the âBig Buildâ corruption allegations and the cancelled Commonwealth Games
- A factional chief stated âanyone other than Allan would lead the party to a better resultâ in recent polls
- A senior right faction figure warned a leadership change would signal âno confidence in your own premierâ and âsaving the furnitureâ
- Internal polling suggests Labor may face a loss of up to 20 seats, though party HQ distanced itself from this claim
- The âtransaction costâ of changing leadership is seen as greater than the benefit by some senior figures
- MPs from the Socialist Leftâs south-east grouping are reportedly unhappy with Allanâs appointment by Andrews and blame her for âalways being on borrowed timeâ
- No one has âcounted numbersâ to gauge support for a full leadership challenge, though preliminary conversations have occurred
- Jess Wilson (Liberal leader) is described as a ârelatively unknown quantityâ to voters, contrasting with Allanâs unpopularity
- A move on Allan is not expected this week, but Labor sources are divided on whether a challenge is inevitable or unlikely
- Ministers presented a âunited frontâ at Parliament, dismissing speculation as âidle gossipâ
- Allanâs baggage includes her role in the cancelled Commonwealth Games and the âBig Buildâ corruption scandal, where she allegedly failed to act once corruption was public
- The Socialist Leftâs south-east grouping (including former Andrews ally) is blamed for pushing the leadership challenge, though they deny involvement
- One MP warned public leaks could âcreate a sense of inevitability that doesnât yet existâ and that a challenge would require coordination between factions
- A senior right faction figure said ânothing will happenâ without the left pulling the trigger, as some left MPs remain reluctant
- Suggestions to avoid a spill until after the May budget or closer to the election to prevent costly by-elections
- The Herald Sun reported âmore than a dozen senior sourcesâ from both left and right factions confirmed leadership discussions were under way
- Allan focused on cost-of-living issues and criticized Liberals for âcozying upâ to One Nation, which 69% of Coalition voters would prefer over Labor (Redbridge survey)
Contradictions
Conflicting information between sources:
- The Guardian reports the Socialist Leftâs south-east grouping is pushing for a leadership change, but they emphatically deny involvement
- The Age states Allanâs unpopularity is tied to her handling of corruption and the Commonwealth Games, while ABC does not mention these specific issues
- The Guardian suggests a leadership challenge would require coordination between factions, but the Age implies the right faction alone may not have the numbers
- The Age cites internal polling suggesting a 20-seat loss, but party HQ distanced itself from this claim, calling it âmanufactured gossipâ
- The Guardian notes Allanâs approval rating is âher lowest since taking over from Andrews in late 2023,â while ABC does not specify this timeline
Source Articles
âScallywagsâ: Premier bats away spill gossip
The Victorian Premier has batted away leadership spill rumours as âanonymous gossipâ peddled by âscallywagâ colleagues....
A âfew scallywagsâ gossiping or a premier under threat? Inside Laborâs push to ditch Jacinta Allan
More than a dozen Victorian Labor sources, including ministers and factional powerbrokers, confirm move for leadership change Follow our Australia news live blog for latest updates Get our breaking ne...
Jacinta Allan dismisses leadership rumblings as 'scallywag' gossip
The Victorian premier denounces speculation about her leadership as "scallywag" gossip amid growing concern that she could cost Labor government in November's state election....
Allan rejects leadership speculation as âscallywag gossipâ as MPs publicly back leader
Premier Jacinta Allan and a conga line of Labor MPs have dismissed speculative reports of a possible leadership challenge before the state election....