Federal government’s stalled national gun buyback scheme after Bondi terror attack
Consensus Summary
The core issue is the federal government’s stalled national gun buyback scheme, introduced after the December 2023 Bondi Beach terror attack, which aimed to remove firearms nationwide by July 2024. Prime Minister Anthony Albanese’s March 31 deadline passed with only four jurisdictions—NSW, WA, Tasmania, and the ACT—fully committing, while South Australia, Queensland, and the Northern Territory outright rejected the plan. Key disputes center on funding (50:50 split vs. full Commonwealth coverage) and jurisdictional autonomy, with critics like NT Chief Minister Lia Finocchiaro and Queensland Premier David Crisafulli arguing the buyback lacks detail or addresses root causes like extremism. Western Australia’s completed buyback (83,000 guns surrendered for $64.3M) contrasts with Victoria’s hesitation, where 244,000 firearms remain unaccounted for due to delayed reviews. Opposition parties and gun lobby groups accuse the federal government of overreach, while advocates warn inconsistent state participation undermines public safety. The scheme’s future hinges on unresolved funding and political will, with no unified timeline despite the government’s insistence on national consistency.
✓ Verified by 2+ sources
Key details reported by multiple sources:
- Anthony Albanese set a March 31 deadline for states and territories to agree on a national gun buyback plan, which has now passed with less than half signing up (NEWSCOMAU, ABC, GUARDIAN).
- South Australia, Northern Territory, and Queensland have explicitly rejected the federal government’s 50:50 funding proposal for the buyback (NEWSCOMAU, ABC, GUARDIAN).
- Western Australia completed its own gun buyback in January 2024, surrendering over 83,000 firearms at a cost of $64.3 million (ABC, GUARDIAN).
- Victoria holds approximately 244,000 firearms—about a quarter of Australia’s total—yet remains noncommittal on the buyback (ABC, GUARDIAN).
- The federal government proposed a 50:50 cost-sharing model for the buyback, but critics like Northern Territory Chief Minister Lia Finocchiaro argue the Commonwealth should cover the full cost (NEWSCOMAU, ABC).
- The Bondi Beach terror attack in December 2023 prompted the national gun reforms, with the federal government citing the need for ‘national consistency’ in gun laws (NEWSCOMAU, ABC, GUARDIAN).
- New South Wales is the only jurisdiction to fully legislate stricter gun controls, including capping firearms per licensee to four (with exceptions for farmers) (ABC, GUARDIAN).
- The federal government’s target for the buyback to be legislated in all jurisdictions was July 1, 2024 (NEWSCOMAU, ABC, GUARDIAN).
- The Howard government’s 1996 Port Arthur buyback destroyed 650,000 firearms for $371 million (adjusted to ~$770 million today) (GUARDIAN).
- Queensland Premier David Crisafulli stated the buyback ‘doesn’t focus on keeping guns out of the hands of terrorists and criminals’ (ABC).
- The National Firearms Agreement was initially agreed upon by national cabinet after the Bondi attack but has since seen states backtrack (ABC, GUARDIAN)
Points of Difference
Details reported by only one source:
- Attorney-General Michelle Rowland explicitly stated ‘the key word here is “national”’ and that reforms are ‘overwhelmingly supported by the Australian people’ (quote).
- South Australia’s position is described as ‘noncommittal’ with no plans to tighten laws, while Victoria is framed as ‘waiting for a rapid review’ without releasing findings (NEWSCOMAU-specific framing).
- Farmers and recreational shooters are quoted pushing back against the buyback, arguing it ‘lacks detail’ and ‘punishes lawful gun owners’ (NEWSCOMAU).
- Shadow Home Affairs Minister Jonno Duniam called the buyback a ‘rushed, chaotic idea’ and claimed it was a ‘distraction from failures on antisemitism and extremism’ (quote).
- Tasmania’s Premier Jeremy Rockliff initially opposed the buyback but later announced a state-led scheme including guns reclassified as illegal (ABC-specific timeline).
- The ABC notes Victoria’s Premier Jacinta Allan ‘has been noncommittal’ and is awaiting a ‘rapid review’ led by former top police officer Ken Lay (ABC-specific detail).
- The ABC reports the federal government’s own March deadline ‘has come and gone’ with ‘more than half the jurisdictions still opposed’ (ABC-specific phrasing).
- Queensland’s opposition to the buyback is linked to ‘underlying issues of antisemitism and hate’ per Premier David Crisafulli (ABC-specific reasoning).
- The Guardian cites a South Australian spokesperson claiming the state ‘has not received any firearms proposal’ from the federal government (GUARDIAN-specific claim).
- The Guardian describes the federal government’s approach as ‘badly backfired’ based on Duniam’s comments (GUARDIAN-specific framing).
- The Guardian notes the Shooting Industry Foundation of Australia’s CEO James Walsh argued the buyback has created ‘uncertainty for thousands of law-abiding Australians’ (GUARDIAN-specific quote).
- The Guardian emphasizes the federal government’s accusation that states are ‘standing in the way’ of ‘getting those guns off our streets’ (GUARDIAN-specific phrasing).
Contradictions
Conflicting information between sources:
- NEWSCOMAU states South Australia ‘has said it would not tighten any laws,’ while the Guardian reports South Australia claims it ‘has not received any firearms proposal’ from the federal government.
- ABC reports Tasmania’s Premier Rockliff ‘had a change of heart’ and announced a buyback in February, but NEWSCOMAU does not mention this shift.
- The Guardian describes the federal government’s cost-sharing model as ‘no final cost of the plan has been released,’ while NEWSCOMAU and ABC imply the 50:50 split is the confirmed arrangement without ambiguity.
- ABC quotes Queensland Premier Crisafulli saying the buyback ‘doesn’t focus on keeping guns out of the hands of terrorists and criminals,’ but NEWSCOMAU does not attribute this specific reasoning to Queensland’s opposition.
- NEWSCOMAU frames Victoria as ‘noncommittal’ without a timeline, while the Guardian notes Victoria ‘plans to release the rapid review report and response in coming weeks’ (ABC also confirms this).
Source Articles
Vow on problematic Bondi promise
The government’s top lawyer is vowing to keep pushing a national gun buyback despite resistance from states and territories....
Federal government claims some states standing in the way of ‘getting those guns off our streets’
PM’s deadline to establish the biggest gun buyback in 30 years passes with half of the nation’s governments refusing to join Get our breaking news email , free app or daily news podcast The federal go...
Less than half of states signed up as national gun reform deadline passes
The federal government's March deadline for national gun reform has come and gone, with more than half the states and territories still opposed to parts of the plan. Only four have committed to a gun ...