← Back to Stories

NSW Legislative Council suspends Sharpe and Graham over document refusals, sparking parliamentary crisis

5 hours ago2 articles from 2 sources

Consensus Summary

The NSW Legislative Council suspended Labor leader Penny Sharpe for 14 days in late May 2026 after she refused to release documents tied to a 2015 sexual harassment allegation against former Labor figure Jamie Clements, a friend of Premier Chris Minns. The opposition and crossbench, led by independent Mark Latham, accused the government of obstructing transparency, while Minns argued the documents were protected by police investigations. Sharpe’s suspension was her fourth this year, and her deputy, John Graham, was also suspended over the government’s refusal to release the Sackar report on hate speech laws. The upper house has blocked over 20 government bills using ‘poison pill’ amendments, with Minns labeling the opposition a ‘cabal.’ The standoff follows a December 2025 court ruling that stripped the upper house of its power to compel witness appearances, and it comes amid speculation Minns may step down after the 2027 election. The crisis highlights deep divisions over parliamentary scrutiny powers and document disclosure, with both sides accusing the other of political obstruction.

✓ Verified by 2+ sources

Key details reported by multiple sources:

  • Penny Sharpe, NSW Labor’s leader in the Legislative Council, was suspended for 14 days (May 2026) after refusing to release documents related to a 2015 sexual harassment allegation against former Labor general secretary Jamie Clements.
  • Mark Latham (independent MP) led the motion to suspend Sharpe, citing the government’s refusal to release documents tied to a 2015 AVO application against Clements, whom Minns is friends with.
  • The NSW government claims the Clements documents cannot be released due to advice from the NSW Crown Solicitor linking them to ‘court proceedings and a police investigation’ (2015 AVO case).
  • John Graham, NSW Labor’s deputy leader in the upper house, was suspended on May 2026 over the government’s refusal to release the Sackar report on hate speech laws, calling it a ‘confidential cabinet document’.
  • The Legislative Council has blocked over 20 government bills this year (vs. 86 in 2025 and 96 in 2024) using ‘poison pill’ amendments, including hate speech laws and e-bike regulations.
  • Premier Chris Minns accused the Legislative Council of forming a ‘cabal’ with Greens, Latham, and the Coalition to obstruct government business, calling their demands ‘conspiracy theories’.
  • The upper house lost its power to compel witnesses to attend committee meetings after a December 2025 court ruling (James Cullen case), with a High Court appeal set for September 2026.
  • Mark Latham was ordered to pay $100,000 in compensation to independent MP Alex Greenwich for vilification and sexual harassment (court ruling cited in May 2026).
  • The destruction of an Aboriginal rock shelter during construction of the Central-West Orana Renewable Energy Zone (ACEREZ) was reported in May 2026, with ACEREZ issuing an apology.

Points of Difference

Details reported by only one source:

Sydney Morning Herald
  • Sharpe returned to parliament on Tuesday (May 27, 2026) before being suspended again hours later, marking her fourth suspension this year (totaling 24 days).
  • The redacted Crown Solicitor’s advice stated there was a ‘quite strong relationship’ between Minns’ 2015 police statement and the AVO proceedings against Clements.
  • Sharpe accused the opposition of ‘interfering with government business,’ noting only 11 bills passed in 2026 vs. 86 in 2025 and 96 in 2024.
  • The Aboriginal rock shelter destruction was confirmed by ACEREZ CEO Steve Masters, who called the loss ‘permanent’ and apologized to Traditional Owners.
The Guardian
  • The Guardian framed the suspensions as part of a ‘serpentine drama’ where ‘two more ministers appeared in Sharpe’s place’ after her expulsion, hinting at a potential ‘who’s next?’ scenario.
  • Greens MLC Sue Higginson cited the ‘woman [alleged victim] who is out there in the community’ wanting documents released to pursue the matter fully.
  • The Sackar review’s non-release was linked to a five-page document from senior public servants stating no documents were lawfully required, per the government.
  • Premier Minns was described as ‘exhausted’ after the Bondi terror attack (December 2025) and facing speculation about stepping down post-2027 election, despite denying it in March.
  • Minns criticized federal Labor’s lack of income tax changes and reiterated ‘biological differences’ should reflect in law, signaling a rightward shift.

Contradictions

Conflicting information between sources:

  • The SMH states Sharpe’s suspension was for a ‘fortnight’ (14 days), while the Guardian also confirms 14 days but does not explicitly use the term ‘fortnight’—no numerical discrepancy.
  • The SMH reports Sharpe’s suspension was her *fourth* this year (totaling 24 days), but the Guardian does not specify the cumulative suspension days, only that it was her *second* suspension in May 2026.
  • The Guardian implies Minns ‘backtracked’ on comments about not being premier in 2032, while the SMH does not mention this backtracking explicitly.
  • The SMH includes a direct quote from Minns calling the upper house a ‘cabal,’ while the Guardian paraphrases this as Minns ‘bristled’ at the moves but does not quote him verbatim.
  • The Guardian suggests Minns’ desire to step down was discussed by MPs *before* the Bondi attack, while the SMH does not provide a timeline for when such discussions began.

Source Articles

SMH

Parliament rebellion erupts as Sharpe cops unprecedented fortnight suspension

Labor’s leader in the upper house returned to parliament after a one-week suspension. But within hours of the house resuming, she was out again.

Yesterday
GUARDIAN

Expulsions, allegations and ‘poison pills’: behind the drama holding up NSW parliament

Labor’s leader in the upper house, Penny Sharpe, and deputy leader, John Graham, have been suspended after the government’s refusal to release documents Get our breaking news email , free app or daily news podcast The New South Wales upper house this week suspended the government’s leader in the Legislative Council, Penny Sharpe, for 14 days. But, like beheading a hydra, two more ministers appeared in her place to answer questions for NSW Labor. Continue reading...

5 hours ago