Stephen Colbert to co-write a new Lord of the Rings film titled Shadow of the Past
Consensus Summary
Stephen Colbert is co-writing a new Lord of the Rings film titled Shadow of the Past, marking his transition from talk show hosting after The Late Show’s cancellation in May 2024. The project, developed with his son Peter McGee and Philippa Boyens, will explore the early chapters of The Fellowship of the Ring that were omitted from Peter Jackson’s original trilogy, focusing on Sam, Merry, and Pippin retracing their journey while Sam’s daughter Elanor uncovers a hidden secret about the War of the Ring’s near-failure. The film is the second in a planned LOTR expansion, following The Hunt for Gollum (directed by Andy Serkis and set for December 2027), and will be produced by Jackson and longtime collaborators. While Guardian sources speculate Tom Bombadil will play a pivotal role—drawing from chapters 3–8—others caution the film risks feeling disjointed or overly commercial by revisiting 'disposable' Tolkien material. Colbert’s deep fandom and Jackson’s involvement underscore the project’s ambition to blend book faithfulness with cinematic continuity, though debates persist over whether such deep cuts can sustain narrative weight or merely serve as nostalgia-driven expansions.
✓ Verified by 2+ sources
Key details reported by multiple sources:
- Stephen Colbert is co-writing a new Lord of the Rings film titled 'Lord of the Rings: Shadow of the Past'
- The film will be developed by Colbert, his son Peter McGee, and Philippa Boyens (original trilogy screenwriter)
- Peter Jackson is involved in the project as producer alongside Fran Walsh and will appear in an announcement video with Colbert
- The film is set 14 years after the events of The Lord of the Rings trilogy and follows Sam, Merry, and Pippin retracing their original journey
- Sam’s daughter Elanor discovers a 'long-buried secret' explaining why the War of the Ring was nearly lost before it began
- The film is the second upcoming LOTR movie after 'The Lord of the Rings: The Hunt for Gollum,' directed by Andy Serkis and set for December 17, 2027
- Colbert’s The Late Show on CBS will air its last episode on May 21, 2024
- The original LOTR trilogy grossed over $2.9 billion worldwide and The Return of the King won the Academy Award for Best Picture
- Colbert is an avid Tolkien fan and previously had a cameo in The Hobbit: The Desolation of Smaug (2013)
Points of Difference
Details reported by only one source:
- The film will take inspiration from chapters 3 to 8 of The Fellowship of the Ring, which were omitted from Jackson’s films
- Tom Bombadil is speculated to be central to the film’s mystery, as chapters 3–8 include his character
- The film’s focus is likely on chapter 8 ('Fogs on the Barrow-downs'), where Bombadil rescued hobbits
- Criticism that Hollywood is monetizing 'disposable' Tolkien material from appendices and extended editions
- Mention of Jackson’s 2001 film The Fellowship of the Ring trimming older, stranger Middle-earth elements for urgency
- Reference to Amazon’s Rings of Power including Bombadil, which was divisive among fans
- Colbert reread chapters 3–8 of The Fellowship of the Ring and sought to adapt them into a standalone story
- Colbert called Jackson to pitch the idea after years of contemplation, and Jackson approved the outline
- Jackson jokingly referenced Colbert’s free time post-The Late Show cancellation as fortunate for the project
- Colbert’s involvement is framed as a transition from talk show hosting to filmmaking after 11 years on The Late Show
- No specific details about the film’s plot or setting beyond the title and Colbert’s involvement
- No mention of Tom Bombadil or chapters 3–8 as key elements
- No discussion of the film’s inspiration or connection to the original books beyond Colbert’s Tolkien fandom
- No reference to the film’s release date or production status beyond being in development
Contradictions
Conflicting information between sources:
- Guardian Article 1 suggests the film will be a loose adaptation of chapters 3–8 with Tom Bombadil at its center, while Guardian Article 3 frames it as a standalone story inspired by those chapters but not a direct adaptation
- Guardian Article 1 implies the film may feel like a 'very expensive shrug' due to Bombadil’s lack of plot relevance, whereas Guardian Article 3 does not critique the project’s feasibility
- Guardian Article 1 mentions the film’s title as 'Shadow of the Past' but does not emphasize its connection to Sam’s daughter Elanor’s discovery, which is prominently highlighted in Guardian Article 3 and ABC
- Guardian Article 1 states the film will 'riff on' chapters 3–8 without trying to adapt them, while Guardian Article 3 explicitly states Colbert was inspired by those chapters to create the story
- Guardian Article 1 criticizes the film’s potential to 'hollow out' Middle-earth’s texture, a tone absent from ABC’s neutral reporting
Source Articles
Will Stephen Colbert’s Lord of the Rings film be Tom Bombadil’s time to shine?
The US talkshow host’s script will focus on chapters three to eight of Tolkien’s first volume – a section Hollywood originally thought disposable but is now circling back to monetise As I write this, ...
Talk show host Stephen Colbert to co-write new Lord of the Rings movie
Talk show host Stephen Colbert, famous devotee to JRR Tolkien's Middle Earth, is co-writing a Lord of the Rings movie with his son....
Stephen Colbert to write new Lord of the Rings film after end of the Late Show
Comedian and avid Tolkien fan to write the Lord of the Rings: Shadow of the Past, a new Peter Jackson-produced film based on unadapted chapters of The Fellowship of the Ring Stephen Colbert has lined ...