Stephen Colbert to co-write a new Lord of the Rings film titled Shadow of the Past
Consensus Summary
Stephen Colbert is co-writing a new Lord of the Rings film titled Shadow of the Past, set 14 years after the original trilogy’s events. The project follows Sam, Merry, and Pippin as they retrace their early journey, with Sam’s daughter Elanor uncovering a secret tied to the near-loss of the War of the Ring. Inspired by chapters 3–8 of The Fellowship of the Ring—omitted from Peter Jackson’s films—Colbert collaborates with Philippa Boyens and his son Peter McGee, while Jackson serves as producer. The film is the second in Warner Bros.’ upcoming LOTR expansion, following The Hunt for Gollum (2027), and marks Colbert’s transition after hosting The Late Show until May 2024. While ABC and Guardian (Article 3) focus on the project’s development and Colbert’s Tolkien devotion, Guardian (Article 1) critiques the film’s potential to exploit Tolkien’s lesser-known material, questioning whether it can meaningfully engage with the source chapters. Contradictions arise over the film’s narrative approach, with some sources emphasizing Bombadil’s role while others treat him as tangential, and differing perspectives on whether the adaptation will be faithful to the books or merely inspirational.
✓ Verified by 2+ sources
Key details reported by multiple sources:
- Stephen Colbert is co-writing a new Lord of the Rings film titled *The Lord of the Rings: Shadow of the Past* with Philippa Boyens and Peter McGee (his son)
- The film is set 14 years after the events of *The Lord of the Rings* trilogy and follows Sam, Merry, and Pippin retracing their early journey
- Sam’s daughter, Elanor, discovers a secret explaining why the War of the Ring was nearly lost before it began
- The film is the second upcoming LOTR movie after *The Lord of the Rings: The Hunt for Gollum*, directed by Andy Serkis and set for release on December 17, 2027
- Peter Jackson directed the original LOTR trilogy and is involved in producing this new film
- Colbert’s *The Late Show* on CBS will air its final episode on May 21, 2024
- The film is being developed by Warner Bros Discovery and New Line Cinema
- Colbert is a lifelong J.R.R. Tolkien fan and referenced chapters 3–8 of *The Fellowship of the Ring* as inspiration for the plot
Points of Difference
Details reported by only one source:
- The film will take inspiration from chapters 3–8 of *The Fellowship of the Ring*, which were omitted from Jackson’s films, including Tom Bombadil’s role as a potential central figure
- The Guardian criticizes the film’s potential to monetize 'disposable' Tolkien material, calling it a 'hollowed-out' attempt to exploit the franchise’s depth
- The article suggests the film may focus on *Fogs on the Barrow-downs* (chapter 8) as its main narrative
- Colbert’s script is described as following Sam, Merry, and Pippin with Sam’s daughter Elanor uncovering a 'long-buried secret' tied to Bombadil
- The Guardian mentions the divisive appearance of Tom Bombadil in *The Rings of Power* and questions whether he can plausibly be the source of a plot-critical revelation
- The ABC article highlights Colbert’s 11-year tenure as host of *The Late Show* ending in May 2024, framing it as a 'new chapter' for him
- The piece includes a quote from Colbert saying, 'I’m pretty happy about it' in a video with Peter Jackson
- The ABC notes Colbert’s cameo in *The Hobbit: The Desolation of Smaug* (2013) alongside his family
- The article emphasizes Colbert’s 'noted devotee' status for Tolkien’s work and his collaboration with Jackson’s team
- No critical analysis of the film’s narrative choices or Tolkien’s material is included
- The Guardian (Article 3) clarifies the film’s setting as 14 years after Frodo’s passing, explicitly stating it follows Sam, Merry, and Pippin retracing their early journey
- Colbert’s quote in the Guardian (Article 3) directly references chapters 3–8 of *The Fellowship of the Ring* as his inspiration, saying, 'I thought, wait, maybe that could be its own story'
- The article includes Colbert’s joke about finding time to adapt the film after *The Late Show* cancellation, with Jackson replying, 'Isn’t that fortunate?'
- The Guardian (Article 3) notes the film’s production involvement by Philippa Boyens and Fran Walsh, longtime producers of the original trilogy
- The article mentions the combined box office gross of the six LOTR and Hobbit movies as $5.9 billion
Contradictions
Conflicting information between sources:
- Guardian (Article 1) suggests the film may focus on Tom Bombadil as a central figure due to his enigmatic nature, while Guardian (Article 3) does not explicitly state Bombadil’s role beyond inspiration from chapters 3–8
- Guardian (Article 1) implies the film may retrospectively adapt chapters 3–8 'as inspiration' rather than a direct adaptation, while Guardian (Article 3) describes it as a story 'faithful to the books'
- Guardian (Article 1) criticizes the film’s potential to 'hollow out' Middle-earth’s depth, a perspective absent from ABC’s neutral reporting
- Guardian (Article 1) mentions the film’s title as *Shadow of the Past* but does not provide a direct quote from Colbert or Jackson confirming its exact narrative focus, unlike Guardian (Article 3) and ABC
- Guardian (Article 1) references the divisive reception of Tom Bombadil in *The Rings of Power*, while ABC and Guardian (Article 3) do not discuss this aspect
Source Articles
Talk show host Stephen Colbert to co-write new Lord of the Rings movie
Talk show host Stephen Colbert, famous devotee to JRR Tolkien's Middle Earth, is co-writing a Lord of the Rings movie with his son....
Will Stephen Colbert’s Lord of the Rings film be Tom Bombadil’s time to shine?
The US talkshow host’s script will focus on chapters three to eight of Tolkien’s first volume – a section Hollywood originally thought disposable but is now circling back to monetise As I write this, ...
Stephen Colbert to write new Lord of the Rings film after end of the Late Show
Comedian and avid Tolkien fan to write the Lord of the Rings: Shadow of the Past, a new Peter Jackson-produced film based on unadapted chapters of The Fellowship of the Ring Stephen Colbert has lined ...