Italian PM Giorgia Meloni’s referendum defeat on judicial reform and its political fallout
Consensus Summary
Italian Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni suffered a significant setback in a referendum on judicial reform, where voters rejected her government’s proposed changes to separate judges and prosecutors and reform the Consiglio Superiore della Magistratura (CSM) by a narrow margin of 53.2% to 46.8% or 54% to 46%, depending on the source. The referendum, which was driven by younger voters and saw record turnout of around 58.5% to 59%, marks Meloni’s first major electoral defeat since taking office in October 2022. The reform, which included a lottery system for selecting judicial oversight members, was widely criticized as an attempt to politicize the judiciary and was framed as a referendum on Meloni’s leadership. Meloni conceded defeat but vowed to continue governing responsibly, though analysts warn her political standing has weakened, particularly due to her alignment with US President Donald Trump, which many Italians oppose. The defeat complicates her plans for broader constitutional reforms and electoral law changes ahead of next year’s elections, while energizing the opposition, which includes the Democratic Party and Five Star Movement. The outcome highlights divisions in Italian politics, with younger voters and left-leaning regions playing a key role in the referendum’s outcome.
✓ Verified by 2+ sources
Key details reported by multiple sources:
- Giorgia Meloni’s Brothers of Italy party leads in polls at around 30% (Guardian, ABC)
- The referendum on judicial reform was rejected by 53.2% to 46.8% (Guardian Article 1) and 54% to 46% (Guardian Article 2, ABC)
- Turnout for the referendum reached 58.5% (Guardian Article 2) and almost 59% (ABC)
- The referendum sought to separate the roles of judges and prosecutors and reform the Consiglio Superiore della Magistratura (CSM) (Guardian Article 1, ABC)
- Meloni conceded defeat and stated ‘the Italians have decided’ while pledging to continue with responsibility (Guardian Article 2, ABC)
- The referendum was held over two days, Sunday and Monday (Guardian Article 2, ABC)
- Meloni’s government includes a coalition with far-right and conservative parties (Guardian Article 1, ABC)
- The reform proposed a lottery system for selecting members of the new judicial oversight bodies (Guardian Article 1, ABC)
- Meloni’s alignment with US President Donald Trump is a key political issue, with many Italians opposing Trump’s policies (Guardian Article 1, Guardian Article 2, ABC)
- The referendum was driven by younger voters, with 61% of 18- to 34-year-olds voting no (Guardian Article 2)
- Meloni’s Justice Minister Carlo Nordio accused the judiciary of a ‘para-Mafia mechanism’ (ABC)
Points of Difference
Details reported by only one source:
- Meloni’s approval ratings for her party have remained stable since 2022, a remarkable feat in Italian politics
- Meloni’s alignment with Trump is rooted in ideological affinity (tradition, religion, cultural homogeneity) and strategic pragmatism
- The Trump factor may have mobilized more Italians to vote no, especially in left-leaning regions and cities with opposition to Trump
- Meloni’s reform was approved along party lines in parliament and would have divided the CSM into two separate councils with a third oversight body
- The reform proposed that two-thirds of the new councils’ members would be magistrates and one-third legal experts appointed by parliament
- Meloni’s proximity to Trump has led to tariff pressures and demands for high military spending, which may have contributed to the referendum outcome
- The breakdown of the vote showed higher turnout in central regions and major cities, traditionally left-leaning and opposed to Trump
- Meloni’s loss forces her to shelve plans for a bolder constitutional overhaul strengthening the executive and deprives her of a major legislative achievement for the 2024 election campaign
- Meloni’s ruling coalition may become more restive, but for now has no incentive to break up or challenge her leadership
- The opposition is energized by the referendum but remains divided, with the Democratic Party and Five Star Movement leading the no campaign
- Meloni turned to an irreverent podcast hosted by a rapper to sway young voters days before the referendum
- Roberto D’Alimonte (Luiss University professor) stated that Meloni’s standing is going to suffer and she will be a weaker prime minister
- The referendum defeat will make it harder for Meloni’s coalition to push forward with plans to pass an electoral law for the 2027 general elections
- The loss means Meloni will lose leverage to push through her pet project of allowing the electorate to vote directly for the prime minister
- D’Alimonte noted that Meloni’s association with Trump is problematic even for her own voters due to rising gas and electricity bills
- Giuseppe Conte (Five Star Movement leader) said ‘We did it – long live the constitution’ after the referendum defeat
- Daniele Albertazzi (University of Surrey professor) called the result a ‘bad, bad result’ for Meloni, stating it means she has lost the Italian electorate on a key manifesto issue
- Albertazzi said the defeat could help the centre-left if they get their act together, as it weakens Meloni’s image of being unbeatable
- The reform was cast by the government as necessary to ensure impartiality in the courts, but critics argued it was an attempt to exert more control over independent judges
- The reform’s complexity and inflammatory rhetoric made the vote a referendum on Meloni herself
- Lorenzo Castellani (Luiss University professor) stated Meloni is certainly weakened by the defeat
- Former prime minister Giuseppe Conte said the referendum result was an ‘eviction notice for this government after four years’
Contradictions
Conflicting information between sources:
- Guardian Article 1 states the referendum result was 53.2% no to 46.8% yes, while Guardian Article 2 and ABC report 54% no to 46% yes
- Guardian Article 1 mentions Meloni’s approval ratings have remained stable since 2022, but ABC does not provide any specific data on her approval ratings
- Guardian Article 2 states Meloni’s party leads in polls at about 30%, while Guardian Article 1 does not specify the exact polling number for her party
- Guardian Article 2 reports Meloni’s coalition has been unusually stable since October 2022, while ABC does not mention the duration of her coalition’s stability
- Guardian Article 1 states the referendum was a ‘no-holds-barred struggle between the executive and the judiciary,’ but ABC does not explicitly mention this framing
Source Articles
Blow to Italian PM Giorgia Meloni as she suffers referendum defeat
Italian Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni concedes defeat in a referendum on justice reform, but despite the major blow to her far-right leadership, she insists she is going nowhere....
Italian voters reject Giorgia Meloni’s plan to overhaul judiciary
Referendum result could tarnish PM’s reputation and make winning next year’s general election more challenging Italian voters have rejected an overhaul of the country’s judiciary pushed by the prime m...
Meloni’s referendum defeat shows the cost of the Trump factor | Riccardo Alcaro
The Italian PM has won plaudits for her tightrope-walking pragmatism. But have voters now had enough? Giorgia Meloni has a long history of defying expectations . She holds the record as Italy’s younge...