US DHS partial shutdown funding negotiations and political deadlock
Consensus Summary
Congress is deadlocked over funding the Department of Homeland Security after Democrats blocked appropriations in mid-February unless Republicans agreed to reforms on ICE agents’ conduct. The Senate passed a DHS funding bill on 28 February excluding ICE and parts of CBP, but House Republicans initially rejected it, passing their own 60-day bill that Democrats vowed to filibuster. On 28 February, leaders Mike Johnson and John Thune agreed to advance the Senate bill, but the House failed to act by 1 March, prolonging the longest partial shutdown in US history. The shutdown caused airport delays as TSA agents went unpaid, though Trump’s 1 March executive order eased those lines. Republicans plan to use budget reconciliation to fund ICE and CBP separately, avoiding Democratic opposition, with Lindsey Graham’s committee leading the effort. Divisions within the GOP and Democratic demands for warrant requirements and bans on agent masks have stalled progress, with both chambers on recess until 1 March. The outcome remains uncertain, with Republicans facing tough negotiations ahead of midterm elections.
✓ Verified by 2+ sources
Key details reported by multiple sources:
- The Department of Homeland Security (DHS) has been without full funding since mid-February 2024, marking the longest partial shutdown in US history.
- The Senate passed a DHS funding bill on 28 February 2024 that excludes funding for Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) and parts of Customs and Border Protection (CBP).
- House Republicans initially rejected the Senate bill and passed their own 60-day DHS funding measure, which Senate Democrats vowed to block via filibuster.
- Transportation Security Administration (TSA) employees faced weeks without pay during the shutdown, causing security lines at airports to stretch for hours in early March 2024.
- Donald Trump signed an executive order on 1 March 2024 to ensure TSA employees received back pay, easing airport delays.
- Mike Johnson (House Speaker) and John Thune (Senate Majority Leader) agreed on 28 February 2024 to advance the Senate’s DHS funding bill, excluding ICE/CBP, but the House did not act on it by 1 March 2024.
- Republicans plan to use budget reconciliation to fund ICE and CBP separately, avoiding Democratic filibusters, with Lindsey Graham’s Senate budget committee leading the effort.
- The partial shutdown began after Democrats blocked DHS funding unless Republicans agreed to reforms on ICE agents’ conduct, including warrant requirements and bans on wearing masks during arrests.
- Both chambers are on recess through 1 March 2024, with ceremonial sessions scheduled for Thursday, 1 March, to potentially pass the DHS funding bill.
Points of Difference
Details reported by only one source:
- The Senate’s DHS funding bill was approved unanimously on 21 February 2024, not 28 February 2024.
- The Senate budget committee chair Lindsey Graham’s plan to fund ICE via reconciliation is described as ‘already initiated’ with a focus on ‘border security and immigration enforcement for the balance of the Trump administration.’
- Democratic Senate Minority Leader Chuck Schumer accused Republicans of prolonging the shutdown due to divisions within the GOP, specifically citing House Speaker Mike Johnson’s rejection of the Senate bill at the urging of the House Freedom Caucus.
- House Minority Leader Hakeem Jeffries stated Democrats would support the Senate bill and called ICE funding a ‘violent mass deportation machine.’
- The One Big Beautiful Bill Act (OBBBA) was referenced as the funding measure that allowed ICE to continue operations despite the partial shutdown.
- The forthcoming reconciliation bill may include funding for the US-Iran conflict and elements of the Save America Act, which imposes voter ID requirements.
- Trump wants the reconciliation bill on his desk by 1 June 2024.
- The Senate passed the DHS funding bill on 28 February 2024, not 21 February 2024.
- House Republicans formally rejected their own 60-day DHS bill on 1 March 2024 during a ceremonial session, sending the Senate’s version back to the House.
- The House did not take up the Senate’s DHS funding bill during its pro forma session on 1 March 2024, lasting just under three minutes.
- Keith Self, a member of the House Freedom Caucus, criticized the plan to separate ICE/CBP funding from DHS, warning it would ‘hand our border and ICE agents straight to the radicals.’
- The partial shutdown caused TSA agents to quit or call out after weeks without pay, with security lines at airports stretching for hours in early March 2024.
Contradictions
Conflicting information between sources:
- Article 1 states the Senate’s DHS funding bill was approved unanimously on 21 February 2024, while Article 2 says it was passed on 28 February 2024.
- Article 1 claims the Senate’s DHS funding bill was ‘already initiated’ via reconciliation, while Article 2 does not mention this specific phrasing or timeline for the reconciliation process.
- Article 1 attributes the delay to divisions within the GOP, specifically citing the House Freedom Caucus’s influence on Johnson, but Article 2 does not explicitly mention this internal GOP split as a cause for delay.
- Article 1 notes Democrats would support the Senate bill but calls ICE funding a ‘violent mass deportation campaign,’ while Article 2 does not include this specific phrasing.
- Article 1 references the ‘One Big Beautiful Bill Act (OBBBA)’ as the funding measure allowing ICE operations during the shutdown, but Article 2 does not mention this act by name.
Source Articles
Partial shutdown drags on as US House takes no action on compromise deal
Senate-passed funding plan for DHS languishes despite agreement between Republican congressional leaders Sign up for the Breaking News US email to get newsletter alerts in your inbox The US House of R...
Republican leaders agree to advance funding deal to end DHS shutdown
Measure that would fund homeland security but exclude money for ICE could conclude lengthy funding lapse An end to the partial shutdown of the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) may be in sight, af...