← Back to Stories

Analysis of *Spider-Man: Brand New Day* film and its narrative reset after *No Way Home*

By The Media Fact Checker teamUpdated 15 hours ago2 articles from 2 sources

Consensus Summary

Both articles analyze *Spider-Man: Brand New Day*, a *[DATE UNVERIFIED]* film that resets the narrative after *Spider-Man: No Way Home*, erasing Peter Parker’s identity from his loved ones, including MJ (Zendaya) and Ned Leeds. The film features Tom Holland as Spider-Man, who must navigate a telepathic villain possessing bodies, including Scorpion, while grappling with new physical and mental health issues. Cameos include Black Widow (Florence Pugh), Dr. Bruce Banner (Mark Ruffalo), and Frank Castle/The Punisher (Jon Bernthal), with the story set in New York City. Critics note the film’s runtime of *2 and a half hours* and its visual and narrative ties to the *2000s* Spider-Man films, though both sources agree it lacks the innovation of *Spider-Verse* animations. The Guardian highlights Zendaya’s performance as a standout, while ABC criticizes the film for being overstuffed and visually uninspired, comparing it unfavorably to Marvel’s TV show *Wonder Man*. Despite its flaws, the film is described as a mid-tier Marvel entry, appealing primarily to fans of the character.

✓ Verified by 2+ sources

Key details reported by multiple sources:

  • The film is titled *Spider-Man: Brand New Day*
  • The story references *Spider-Man: No Way Home* as the preceding film
  • The film features Tom Holland as Peter Parker/Spider-Man
  • Zendaya plays MJ, Peter Parker’s love interest, who does not remember him
  • The film includes a telepathic villain possessing bodies, including Scorpion (Michael Mando)
  • The film references the *2000s* Spider-Man films (Sam Raimi trilogy) for visual or narrative inspiration
  • The film’s runtime is described as *2½ hours* or *2 and a half hours*
  • The film features a cameo by Black Widow (Florence Pugh)
  • The film includes a scene with Dr. Bruce Banner (Mark Ruffalo) as the Hulk
  • The film features Jon Bernthal as Frank Castle/The Punisher
  • The film’s setting is New York City

Points of Difference

Details reported by only one source:

The Guardian
  • The film’s narrative reset erases Peter Parker’s identity from MJ and Ned Leeds (Jacob Batalon)
  • Spider-Man’s physical and mental health issues include headaches described as ‘David Cronenberg zone’
  • Black Widow’s cameo involves Spider-Man joining her in a plunge pool while wearing his mask and underpants
  • The film’s climax involves a ‘fractious frenmity-bromance’ with Frank Castle/The Punisher
  • The film’s visual style is criticized for lacking novelty compared to *Spider-Verse* animations
  • The film’s destruction scenes are described as ‘apocalyptic but weirdly temporary’
  • The film’s director is Destin Daniel Cretton, who gets the best out of Zendaya’s performance
ABC News
  • The film’s opening montage recreates classic *Spider-Man* comic covers
  • The film’s villain’s identity was kept secret but is revealed in theaters (known to comic fans)
  • The film features Sadie Sink in an undisclosed role, with her character’s identity kept under lock and key
  • The film’s Spider-Man develops ‘organic webbing’ as a throwback to the *2000s* Raimi trilogy
  • The film’s visual style is criticized for excessive green-screen use and lack of sparkle in web-slinging
  • The film’s narrative is compared unfavorably to *Wonder Man* (a Marvel TV show) and *Into the Spider-Verse*
  • The film’s runtime is explicitly stated as *almost 2 and a half hours*
  • The film’s Department of Damage Control is mentioned as a bureaucratically evil entity
  • The film’s plot is described as ‘overstuffed and under-done’ with a ‘grab-bag of characters’
  • The film’s finale passes the Bechdel test

Contradictions

Conflicting information between sources:

  • The Guardian describes the film’s runtime qualitatively as ‘2½ hours,’ while ABC explicitly states it as *almost 2 and a half hours*, implying a slight difference in emphasis
  • The Guardian mentions Spider-Man’s headaches as a ‘David Cronenberg zone’ development, while ABC does not reference this detail
  • The Guardian describes the film’s destruction as ‘apocalyptic but weirdly temporary,’ while ABC does not use this phrasing

Source Articles

GUARDIAN

Spider-Man: Brand New Day review – Zendaya saves Tom Holland’s semi-Cronenberg-style superhero

Now 30, Holland is back as the vexed webslinger in a sometimes shocking, occasionally sluggish new instalment opposite his Odyssey castmate Just a few weeks ago, Tom Holland was telling us that his role as Telemachus in Christopher Nolan’s Odyssey was his “last chance to play a boy”. Well, Holland is back as the supposedly scrappy, gawky, arachnid young superhero Spider-Man. Not Spider-Boy admittedly, and these days Holland is actually a chunkier and more stacked Spidey than previously, flexing

Yesterday
ABC

Spider-Man: Brand New Day is the return of the mid-tier Marvel movie

Tom Holland's return as a now-anonymous Peter Parker isn't the igniting spark Marvel needs to revive its cinematic universe.

16 hours ago