Democratic victory in Florida state house special election near Trump’s Mar-a-Lago
Consensus Summary
Democrats secured a surprise victory in Florida’s 87th state house district special election, flipping a seat previously held by a Republican who won by 19 points in 2024. Emily Gregory, a first-time candidate with no prior political experience, defeated Jon Maples, who had Trump’s endorsement. The district encompasses Mar-a-Lago, Trump’s Florida estate, and Democrats framed the win as evidence of growing voter frustration with Trump and the Republican Party ahead of the midterms. Both sources confirm Trump voted by mail despite his public criticism of the practice, with voter records verifying his ballot. Since Trump’s return to office, Democrats have flipped 29 state legislative seats, per Democratic leaders. The Brookings Institution’s 2025 data on mail voting fraud rates was cited by both outlets to contextualize Trump’s contradictory voting behavior. While the core facts align—such as the election outcome, Trump’s endorsement, and the district’s history—the Guardian and ABC provide distinct details, including Gregory’s background (public health expert vs. fitness company owner) and Trump’s motivations for voting by mail, with no outright contradictions beyond interpretive framing.
✓ Verified by 2+ sources
Key details reported by multiple sources:
- Emily Gregory (Democrat) defeated Jon Maples (Republican) in Florida’s 87th state house district special election, with Gregory leading by 2.4 percentage points (797 votes).
- The seat was previously held by Republican Mike Caruso, who won by 19 percentage points in the 2024 election before resigning to become Palm Beach County clerk.
- Donald Trump endorsed Maples and urged voters to support him, despite Trump’s longstanding criticism of mail-in voting as fraudulent.
- Trump voted by mail in the special election despite publicly opposing mail-in ballots, with Palm Beach County voter records confirming his mail ballot.
- The district includes Mar-a-Lago, Trump’s Florida residence and estate, and Democrats framed the win as a rejection of Trump and Republicans ahead of midterms.
- Since Trump’s return to office, Democrats have flipped 29 state legislative seats nationwide, per statements from Democratic leaders.
- Brookings Institution reported mail voting fraud occurred in 0.000043% of total mail ballots cast (about four cases per 10 million votes) in 2025.
Points of Difference
Details reported by only one source:
- Emily Gregory is a public health expert and small business owner, and 314 Action (a pro-science political committee) endorsed her, calling it a ‘STEM wave’ victory.
- Heather Williams (Democratic Legislative Campaign Committee president) stated ‘Mar-a-Lago just flipped red to blue’ and noted Republicans are ‘vulnerable everywhere’.
- Gregory’s campaign emphasized her focus on ‘lowering costs, restoring healthcare, and bringing down the temperature in Tallahassee’ based on evidence, not ideology.
- Maples faced allegations he did not live in the district, which he denied, and the Guardian highlighted this as scrutiny during the race.
- Emily Gregory owns a fitness company specializing in pregnant and postpartum women and had never run for elected office before.
- Democratic National Committee chair Ken Martin said Trump’s neighbors ‘are furious and ready for change’ after the loss.
- ABC noted Trump distanced himself from the loss, saying ‘I’m not involved in that,’ despite his endorsement of Maples.
- The article included a quote from Gregory calling her victory a ‘fairly out-of-body experience’ after winning.
- ABC referenced Trump’s switch from New York to Florida as his personal residence during his first term and Mar-a-Lago’s role as a gathering place for allies.
Contradictions
Conflicting information between sources:
- The Guardian mentions Trump voted via mail-in ballot ‘despite criticizing the practice as “mail-in cheating” during an event in Tennessee this week,’ while ABC states Trump’s opposition was to ‘universal mail-in voting’ and not individual accommodations, with the White House clarifying his stance.
- The Guardian reports Trump ‘urged voters to back Maples, a financial adviser who describes himself as an “America-First patriot”’ with no contradiction in ABC, but ABC does not elaborate on Maples’ self-description.
- The Guardian cites a 2024 Republican win margin of 19 percentage points in the district, while ABC states the previous Republican (Caruso) won by 19 points in 2024—both align but ABC omits the year 2024 explicitly.
- ABC highlights Trump’s ‘personal residence switch to Florida during his first term’ as a key detail, while the Guardian does not emphasize this timeline or context.
- The Guardian attributes the quote ‘a Trump +11 district in his own backyard shouldn’t be in play for Democrats’ to Heather Williams, while ABC does not reference this exact phrasing or source.
Source Articles
Democrats flip seat in Florida district home to Mar-a-Lago resort
Democrats celebrate the victory as the latest sign voters are turning against Donald Trump and Republicans ahead of November's midterm elections....
Democrats flip seat in Florida state house in district that includes Trump’s Mar-a-Lago
Emily Gregory defeats Republican Jon Maples in district that is home to US president’s Palm Beach estate Democrats managed to flip a seat in the Florida state house in the district that is home to Don...