Testing and reviewing the best chef’s knives for home cooks
Consensus Summary
The Guardian’s two articles explore the selection and care of chef’s knives through a rigorous testing process led by Ben Lippett, a professional chef and food writer. Both articles agree that the Wüsthof Classic Chef Knife (20cm) is the best overall choice, while the Victorinox Fibrox Chef’s Knife (20cm) stands out as the best budget option at £43. Lippett tested 14 knives over two weeks, focusing on tasks like dicing shallots, slicing tomatoes, and chopping herbs to evaluate performance, edge retention, and comfort. Key consensus includes advice from knife specialist Helen Symonds to avoid using knives on stones, bones, or frozen food, and to hand-clean and store knives properly to maintain their quality. Article 1 delves deeper into specific models like the Sabatier Cook’s Knife and Opinel N°118, while also discussing blade geometry, handle fit, and the importance of a minimalist knife collection for home cooks. It emphasizes the need to test knives in person for comfort and balance, recommending a ‘beater knife’ for tougher tasks. Article 2, however, focuses more on the logistical challenges of sourcing knives and the collaborative process with the Guardian Food Quarterly, without repeating all the specific details from Article 1. Contradictions arise in pricing specifics, model mentions, and care instructions, particularly around Damascus forged knives and wooden handle maintenance. Overall, the articles collectively provide a comprehensive guide for home cooks seeking durable, high-performing knives, stressing both the importance of proper selection and meticulous care.
✓ Verified by 2+ sources
Key details reported by multiple sources:
- Ben Lippett tested 14 knives over a fortnight for The Guardian, focusing on tasks like dicing shallots, slicing tomatoes, and chopping herbs.
- The Wüsthof Classic Chef Knife (20cm) was named the best overall chef’s knife by Ben Lippett in both articles.
- Victorinox Fibrox Chef’s Knife (20cm) was selected as the best budget knife, priced at £43.
- Helen Symonds, a knife specialist, advised against using knives on stones, bones, frozen food, or hard surfaces like steel or glass.
- Ben Lippett recommended avoiding dishwashers for knives, emphasizing hand cleaning and proper storage on magnetic racks or in boxes.
Points of Difference
Details reported by only one source:
- The Wüsthof Classic Chef Knife was priced at £137.11 at the time of testing (mentioned in Article 2 but attributed to Article 1’s context).
- The Victorinox Fibrox Chef’s Knife was described as ‘razor sharp and well balanced’ by Ben Lippett, referencing his early cooking career experience.
- The Allday Goods Maldon Santoku Knife (16cm) and Blenheim Forge Santoku Knife (17.5cm) were specifically named as best Japanese-style and best investment knives, respectively.
- The Sabatier Cook’s Knife (25cm) was highlighted as the best workhorse western-style knife, with a focus on blade length for larger hands.
- The Opinel N°118 Chef Multipurpose Knife was recommended as the best knife for beginners, emphasizing its versatility and affordability.
- The article detailed specific blade lengths for different hand sizes, recommending 20cm+ for larger hands and smaller sizes for petite users.
- The Asahi chopping boards were mentioned as the preferred choice for protecting knife edges due to their structural longevity.
- The article included a detailed breakdown of knife geometry, comparing western-style curved blades to Japanese straight-edge blades.
- The article emphasized the importance of blade edge quality, describing how to test for smoothness by running a thumb along the edge.
- The article warned against Damascus forged knives for everyday use due to brittleness, staining, and poor edge retention unless cared for meticulously.
- The article recommended a ‘beater knife’ for tougher tasks like pumpkin carving or lobster prep to preserve premium knives.
- The article provided specific care instructions for wooden handles, including oiling with food-safe oil.
- The article discouraged pull-through sharpeners and metal steels, preferring whetstones for even sharpening and manual dexterity.
- The article included a quote from Ben Lippett describing his ‘no-nonsense’ approach to home cooking and his audience of millions on social media (@dinnerbyben).
- The article mentioned Ben Lippett’s background as a London-based chef, recipe developer, and bestselling cookbook author.
- The article detailed the testing process, including controlled tests like slicing chives and filleting fish alongside everyday meals like pastas and braises.
- The article recommended a minimalist knife collection for home cooks, suggesting a chef’s knife, paring knife, and serrated bread knife as essentials.
- The article included a section on knife repair, stating that chipped or bent blades and loose handles can often be successfully repaired if addressed promptly.
- The article mentioned logistical challenges in sourcing knives for testing, including ID verification for deliveries and issues with unboxing sharp knives in an office setting.
- The article referenced Lily Smith, the researcher, who had to physically visit high-street stores to obtain some knives that weren’t available online.
- The article included a brief mention of the Guardian Food Quarterly’s collaboration in the testing process but did not provide further details on its role.
- The article did not repeat the specific names of all knives tested in Article 1, focusing more on the process and Ben Lippett’s methodology.
- The article included a sidebar with unrelated topics such as skincare products, air fryers, and travel tips for parents, which were not present in Article 1.
Contradictions
Conflicting information between sources:
- Article 1 states the Wüsthof Classic Chef Knife costs £137.11, while Article 2 does not provide a price but implies it is a high-end knife without specifying the exact cost.
- Article 1 explicitly mentions the Sabatier Cook’s Knife (25cm) as the best workhorse western-style knife, but Article 2 does not reference this specific model or category.
- Article 1 details the Opinel N°118 as the best knife for beginners, while Article 2 does not mention this model or category at all.
- Article 1 provides extensive care instructions for wooden handles, including oiling, while Article 2 does not address this detail.
- Article 1 includes a quote from Helen Symonds about the brittleness of Damascus forged knives, but Article 2 does not reference this specific advice or critique.
Source Articles
Blades of glory (or not): what makes a chef’s knife truly great?
Our kitchen expert spent weeks chopping to find the blades that cut it. Plus, how to travel with kids, and the best tools for a home and garden spring reset • Don’t get the Filter delivered to your in...
‘Buy this, and you’ll be set for life’: the best (and worst) chef’s knives – tested
From budget to Japanese-style models, here are chef Ben Lippett’s sharpest picks for comfort, cut and cost after weeks of chopping. Plus, what to know before you buy • The kitchen gadgets top chefs ca...