Australian government investigates tech firms over under-16 social media ban compliance
Consensus Summary
Australia’s government is investigating five major social media platforms—Facebook, Instagram, Snapchat, TikTok, and YouTube—for allegedly failing to comply with a December 2023 ban on under-16 accounts. The eSafety Commission’s report reveals platforms allow repeated age-verification attempts and fail to block banned users from creating new accounts, despite fines of up to A$49.5 million for systemic violations. A parent survey found 31% of children still had accounts post-ban, down from nearly half pre-ban, while over 4.7 million accounts were deactivated in the first days. Communications Minister Anika Wells accused tech firms of ‘undermining’ the law, calling for strict enforcement. The ban, inspired by News Corp’s campaign, applies to 10 platforms but excludes services like WhatsApp and Discord. Critics highlight flaws in age-assurance tech, particularly near the 16-year-old cutoff, while supporters argue the law reduces overall underage usage. The government plans to expand the ban’s scope to include more platforms with interactive features like infinite scroll.
✓ Verified by 2+ sources
Key details reported by multiple sources:
- Facebook, Instagram, Snapchat, TikTok, and YouTube are under investigation by Australia’s eSafety Commission for potential non-compliance with the under-16 social media ban, announced on or before February 2024.
- The eSafety Commission’s compliance update (released February 2024) found platforms allow underage users to repeatedly attempt age assurance tests until they pass, and fail to block banned users from creating new accounts.
- The Australian government’s social media minimum age laws, effective since December 10 2023, ban under-16s from holding accounts on 10 platforms: Facebook, Instagram, Snapchat, Threads, TikTok, Twitch, X, YouTube, Kick, and Reddit.
- Fines for systemic non-compliance with the ban can reach up to A$49.5 million per company, as stated by Communications Minister Anika Wells.
- A survey of 900 Australian parents found 31% of children still had social media accounts after the ban, down from 49% before the laws (Guardian and eSafety data).
- Over 4.7 million accounts were deactivated or restricted in the first days after the ban took effect (ABC, Guardian, News Corp).
- Meta (Facebook/Instagram) reported closing 550,000 accounts, while Snapchat and TikTok combined closed 665,000 accounts since the ban (News Corp).
- The eSafety Commissioner will release an official compliance update on February 2024, detailing specific failures by the platforms.
Points of Difference
Details reported by only one source:
- Penny Wong (Foreign Affairs Minister) stated Australia has ‘concerns’ if the US war in Iran aims for regime change, calling for de-escalation due to economic impacts (mentioned in two separate Guardian excerpts).
- The Guardian cited a survey where 70% of under-16s who had accounts on Instagram/Snapchat/TikTok before the ban still retained access post-ban.
- The Guardian reported that facial age estimation technology has higher error rates for users near the 16-year-old cutoff, with some platforms knowing false positives occur for 14–15-year-olds.
- SBS noted platforms were making it ‘easy to find ways to circumvent age-assurance measures’ but did not provide specific numbers or platform names beyond the general investigation.
- ABC reported eSafety Commissioner Julie Inman-Grant acknowledged ‘teething issues’ with age-assurance technologies when the ban launched, citing teenage bragging about still accessing accounts.
- ABC detailed that the ban’s scope was expanded in January 2024 to include platforms with infinite scroll, feedback features (likes), and time-limited content (e.g., disappearing stories).
- ABC specified that Discord, Google Classroom, WhatsApp, and Roblox are excluded from the ban’s restrictions.
- News Corp attributed the ban’s origins to its ‘Let Them Be Kids’ campaign, making Australia the first country to implement such a law.
- News Corp explicitly listed the 10 platforms covered by the ban: Meta’s Facebook/Instagram/WhatsApp (though WhatsApp is excluded per ABC), Snapchat, Threads, TikTok, Twitch, X, YouTube, Kick, and Reddit.
Contradictions
Conflicting information between sources:
- The Guardian and News Corp both list WhatsApp as part of Meta’s brands under the ban, but ABC explicitly states WhatsApp is excluded from the ban’s scope.
- The Guardian reports 70% of under-16s retained TikTok/Instagram/Snapchat accounts post-ban, while SBS does not provide specific retention percentages and only mentions ‘circumvention’ generally.
- ABC states the ban’s expansion to include platforms with infinite scroll was announced in January 2024, but this detail is not mentioned in Guardian, SBS, or News Corp.
- News Corp claims Meta closed 550,000 accounts, while the Guardian does not provide Meta’s specific closure numbers and focuses on systemic failures rather than exact figures.
- The Guardian cites a survey where 31% of parents reported children still had social media accounts, but SBS does not reference this survey or percentage in its coverage.
Source Articles
Crackdown looms for social media giants
Social media platforms like Facebook and TikTok face millions in fines over revelations they are using “big tech playbook” tactics to undermine Australia’s under-16 social media ban....
Australian politics live: social media giants accused of ‘potential non-compliance’ with under-16s social media ban
Meta, TikTok, Snapchat and YouTube being investigated as eSafety releases update on compliance with social media ban. Follow today’s news live Get our breaking news email , free app or daily news podc...
Meta, Tiktok and Google under investigation for allegedly disobeying Australia’s social media ban
Nearly 70% of under-16s with accounts on Instagram, Snapchat or TikTok had maintained access, survey finds The Australian government has accused big tech firms like Meta, TikTok and Google of disobeyi...
Five social media companies investigated over response to teen ban
Facebook, Instagram, Snapchat, TikTok and YouTube are being investigated for potential noncompliance with the ban, almost four months after the laws came into force....
Australia investigating tech giants over teen social media ban breaches
A compliance report on the legislation found platforms were making it easy to find ways to circumvent age-assurance measures....