Tropical Cyclone Narelle’s unusual path and red sky phenomenon in Western Australia
Consensus Summary
Tropical Cyclone Narelle made headlines in March 2013 for its rare triple-coast landfall and the striking red sky phenomenon in Western Australia’s Shark Bay. The eerie blood-red hue was caused by iron-rich dust from the Pilbara region, stirred into the atmosphere by the cyclone’s winds, with experts confirming the role of rust-colored soils and cloud cover. While the storm avoided Shark Bay’s worst impacts, it devastated Exmouth, damaging infrastructure and agricultural lands, with widespread cleanup efforts and government relief payments following. The event drew global attention, with images of the apocalyptic sky shared across major outlets, though details like timing, duration, and specific damage varied slightly between sources. Two Guardian articles focused on the meteorological cause and the storm’s unusual path, while ABC provided firsthand accounts, broader impact assessments, and additional context on the phenomenon’s visual intensity and aftermath.
✓ Verified by 2+ sources
Key details reported by multiple sources:
- Tropical Cyclone Narelle made landfall in Western Australia on 27 March 2013, becoming the first storm in over 20 years to hit three of Australia’s states/territories
- The red sky in Shark Bay was caused by iron-rich dust picked up by Cyclone Narelle from the Pilbara region’s rust-red soils, as confirmed by Jessica Lingard (Bureau of Meteorology) and Angus Hines (Bureau of Meteorology)
- Shark Bay’s red sky occurred on 27 March, with footage captured at Shark Bay Caravan Park in Denham, WA, showing the phenomenon before Cyclone Narelle’s landfall
- The Pilbara region, less than 400km northeast of Denham, is the center of Australia’s iron-ore industry and contributed to the dust storm
- Cyclone Narelle caused significant damage in Exmouth, including destroyed roofs, damaged marina, and an ‘obliterated’ airport, with 30 pastoral properties extensively damaged
- WA Premier Roger Cook announced one-off payments of $2,000 for major home damage and up to $4,000 for destroyed homes following Cyclone Narelle
Points of Difference
Details reported by only one source:
- Cyclone Narelle crossed the WA coast on Friday afternoon (27 March) and became the first storm in over 20 years to make landfall in three states/territories
- The Guardian’s first article explicitly mentions the storm’s ‘very unusual’ path to hit Australia on three coastlines
- No mention of the cyclone’s impact on Carnarvon’s banana crops or the evacuation center’s damage
- Kerrie Shepherd from Shark Bay Caravan Park described the sky turning ‘orange’ midday before turning ‘red’ by 3:30pm, lasting until the wind picked up
- ABC highlights the ‘apocalyptic scenes’ making worldwide news, including references to The New York Times, CNN, and The Sun
- Details the cloud cover’s role in intensifying the red hue by diffusing light evenly, a factor not emphasized in Guardian articles
- Includes specific damage details like the ‘cyclone-proof’ evacuation center’s roof being peeled back and 80% crop destruction in Carnarvon
- Mentions the event lasted several hours, beginning midday and clearing within half an hour after rain
Contradictions
Conflicting information between sources:
- The Guardian does not mention the specific time (3:30pm) when the sky turned red in Denham, while ABC cites Kerrie Shepherd’s exact observation of this timing
- ABC reports the red sky began midday and lasted several hours, while Guardian articles do not specify a duration beyond ‘before arrival of Cyclone Narelle’
- The Guardian’s first article does not mention the worldwide news coverage of the ‘apocalyptic scenes,’ which ABC explicitly highlights
- ABC details the banana grower’s 80% crop loss in Carnarvon, a fact not referenced in either Guardian article
- Guardian’s first article does not mention the evacuation center’s damage or the $2,000–$4,000 relief payments announced by WA Premier Roger Cook, both covered by ABC
Source Articles
Apocalyptic scenes from Australia ahead of cyclone make worldwide news
Cyclone Narelle turned the sky over parts of Western Australia's north into an ominous red, sparking headlines across the globe....
Sky turns blood-red in Western Australia’s Shark Bay before arrival of Cyclone Narelle – video
Footage from 27 March shows a red sky in Western Australia’s Shark Bay ahead of the arrival of a Tropical Cyclone Narelle, partially thanks to copious amounts of iron-rich dirt picked up by the storm ...
How Tropical Cyclone Narelle turned the sky red in Western Australia
Dry ground, iron-rich earth and strong winds combined to create an eerie dust storm that was filmed in Denham Get our breaking news email , free app or daily news podcast The skies of Shark Bay in Wes...