New York school district pauses humanoid robot teacher pilot amid backlash
Consensus Summary
A New York school district in Salamanca, upstate New York, paused a pilot program to introduce a humanoid robot named Sally in high school classrooms amid widespread backlash from teachers, unions, and community members. The robot, costing around $60,000, was intended to assist with technology and robotics education but faced criticism over its ties to a company that manufactures sex dolls, concerns about student data privacy, and cultural insensitivity toward the district’s large Native American population. The program was set to begin in fall 2026, but the district announced on 24 July that it would be delayed while privacy agreements were finalized. Teachers and unions argued that robots could not replace human educators and raised ethical concerns about exposing students to untested technology, particularly in a historically marginalized community. Realbotix, the company behind the robot, denied any connection between Sally and its sex doll subsidiary and emphasized the robot’s educational purpose, though critics remained skeptical.
✓ Verified by 2+ sources
Key details reported by multiple sources:
- Salamanca City Central School District in upstate New York paused a pilot program to deploy a humanoid robot named 'Sally' from Realbotix in high school classrooms
- The robot was intended for students studying technology and robotics, with a cost of approximately $60,000 (ABC: $US60,000; Guardian: $57,590 or $58,000)
- The pilot program was announced to begin in fall 2026
- Realbotix acquired Simulacra, a Las Vegas-based company known for manufacturing sex dolls, for $16.7m in April 2024
- The Salamanca Teachers’ Association and New York State United Teachers union criticized the program, calling it inappropriate and raising concerns about student data privacy and the company’s background
- The robot, Sally, has working arms and hands but no legs, and was designed to interact with students using natural conversation and facial expressions
- The school district serves a large Native American population, with nearly 40% of Salamanca High School’s student body being Native American
- The pilot program was paused on 24 July after public and educator backlash, with the district citing the need for enhanced student data privacy agreements
Points of Difference
Details reported by only one source:
- The robot was initially described as a $60,000 program in Article 1, but later clarified as $57,590 or $58,000 in Articles 2 and 3.
- Realbotix’s CEO, Andrew Kiguel, stated the program was designed to assist teachers, not replace them, and emphasized safety and district approval.
- The Salamanca Teachers’ Association president, Lacey Pihlblad, expressed concerns about the security of Realbotix’s software and data collection methods.
- The Seneca Nation declined to comment to the Guardian, but local residents criticized the program as culturally tone-deaf and a repeat of historical experiments on Native American children.
- The robot was described as a closed-loop system available virtually 24/7 for students with access, offering personalized learning options.
- The district is the first in the US to deploy a humanoid robot and AI teaching assistant, according to Realbotix.
- The superintendent mentioned students would otherwise need to travel 1-2 hours to see high-level technology.
- The robot’s cost was explicitly stated as $US60,000 ($86,000 AUD), with a comparison to a San Diego charter school’s $US500,000 purchase of similar robots.
- The robot was described as a 'newly manufactured, purpose-built educational unit' with no ties to the sex doll company’s hardware.
- Realbotix LLC and Intima LLC (the sex doll subsidiary) were stated to have separate management, personnel, and operations.
- The robot was programmed to avoid inappropriate topics like sex, violence, and gambling, and would not collect personal student data or record audio/video.
- The district emphasized Sally would not replace teachers but complement them, with student authentication handled through existing systems.
Where the reporting differs
Details that conflict, or appear in only some outlets:
- The Guardian reports the robot cost was approximately $57,590 or $58,000, while ABC states it was $US60,000 ($86,000 AUD).
- Article 1 (Guardian) mentions a $60,000 program cost, but Articles 2 and 3 clarify the robot itself cost $57,590 or $58,000, creating ambiguity about the total program budget.
- The Guardian states the robot was paused on 24 July, while ABC does not specify a date for the pause but references the 24 July social media announcement.
- Guardian Article 1 claims the robot was paused due to public outcry, while Articles 2 and 3 attribute the pause to privacy concerns and community engagement, not just outcry.
Source Articles
If you think kids will respect a robot teacher, you have never met a kid | Dave Schilling
A New York school district has paused plans to bring an android into the classroom. Is this our educational future? What’s more harrowing than sending your child to school? Maybe getting stuck on a city bus that can’t drop below 55 miles per hour or it will explode, but that’s about it. Once your kid hits school age, you have to decide (if you’re lucky) between public and private education, vet the teachers, and neurotically worry about whether they’re learning enough and are socializing effecti
New York school district halts plan to use humanoid robot amid backlash
Salamanca City Central says it is pausing project with Realbotix as it addresses concerns including data privacy A New York school district has walked back plans to introduce a humanoid robot at its high school after the proposal sparked backlash from educators and community members. The Salamanca City Central school district announced on 24 July in a social media post that its pilot project with Toronto-based tech company Realbotix had been put on hold “while we work through enhanced student da
‘Really inappropriate’: teachers decry plan for humanoid robot in New York high school
Robot from company that acquired sex doll maker to be introduced in school with large Native American population A humanoid robot is being introduced as part of a pilot program, along with an AI teaching assistant, at Salamanca high school in Salamanca, New York, located on the Allegany territory of the Seneca nation. Teachers have criticized the program, deeming it “inappropriate” and claiming it dehumanizes the profession with the introduction of human-like robots. Some local Native American r
US school pauses humanoid robot plan after link with sexbot company raised
A school in rural upstate New York has puts its plans for a humanoid robot on hold, after concerns were raised about the maker's links to a company that produces sexbots.