Australian universities' misuse of confidentiality clauses in student complaints, especially sexual harassment cases
Consensus Summary
Australian universities have come under scrutiny for improperly applying confidentiality clauses in student complaints, particularly those involving gender-based violence. The National Student Ombudsman (NSO) report revealed that 21 of 44 universities use such clauses, with UTS, James Cook University, and the University of Newcastle singled out for breaching trauma-informed practices. The NSO found that UTS 'effectively silenced' a student named Hailey after investigating her for an alleged confidentiality breach following an 'insufficient evidence' ruling on her sexual harassment complaint. Both sources agree that UTS and other universities failed to provide clear, consistent guidance on confidentiality, leaving students like Hailey feeling isolated and punished for reporting abuse. The NSO recommended that confidentiality clauses should only apply during the complaint process, not the broader experience, and universities like UTS and Newcastle have accepted these changes. While both articles highlight systemic failures, ABC provides more personal details about Haileyâs experience and UTSâs specific missteps, including an initial plan to publicly disclose the unsubstantiated complaint. NEWSCOMAU emphasizes broader policy inconsistencies and student advocacy concerns, while ABC underscores the emotional toll on complainants and the universityâs delayed or incomplete apologies.
â Verified by 2+ sources
Key details reported by multiple sources:
- The National Student Ombudsman (NSO) report found that 21 out of 44 Australian universities use confidentiality clauses in student complaints, including those about gender-based violence
- UTS, James Cook University (JCU), and the University of Newcastle were singled out for confidentiality practices that breached trauma-informed practice
- UTS was ordered to apologise to a student (Hailey*) for 'effectively silencing' her after investigating her for an alleged confidentiality breach following an 'insufficient evidence' finding on her sexual harassment complaint
- The NSO report stated that UTS 'did not possess any information indicating Hailey had talked about the details of the university's investigation or her sexual harassment complaint'
- The NSO was established in February 2025 as an independent service to address systemic failures in university complaint handling, receiving over 2200 complaints in its first six months
- UTS Deputy Vice-Chancellor Kylie Readman acknowledged the university's past failures and committed to 'doing better' and embedding trauma-informed approaches
- The University of Newcastle and JCU accepted some of the NSO's recommendations for policy updates
- The NSO recommended that confidentiality clauses should only apply to the complaint process, not the student's experience or reporting of sexual harm
Points of Difference
Details reported by only one source:
- The report noted that UTS told the NSO it placed no restriction on students discussing complaints with 'family and friends,' but the NSO found the university's advice was 'inconsistent, contradictory, and lacked a timeline'
- A student advocate group quoted in the report said, 'Once an investigation is concluded, students should be able to speak about their experience. Currently, confidentiality clauses feel attached to a punitive threat,'
- The NSO report highlighted that 'excessive confidentiality can cause a complainant to feel silenced or disempowered about the experience they had that led them to complain'
- The report mentioned that the student advocate group questioned whether confidentiality clauses exist 'to protect the university or students'
- The NSO noted that the timeline of the incident suggested that 'the university (UTS) effectively silenced' the student who made the complaint
- ABC News first revealed Hailey's concerns regarding her treatment by UTS last year, with the NSO investigation report released publicly in the same article
- Hailey said she was 'blindsided' by the investigation and offered 'no support whatsoever,' and felt she couldn't talk to friends about her experience
- UTS was ordered to apologise to Hailey for an initial plan to tell all students in the law society her complaint had not been substantiated
- The NSO found that UTS's demands for confidentiality were 'unreasonable and needlessly oppressive,' leading to students feeling isolated during recovery
- UTS stated it had 'stopped using confidentiality requirements' and would undertake 'meaningful consultation with students' on the issue
- The NSO made seven findings against UTS, five against the University of Newcastle, and four against JCU
- The NSO noted 'serious concerns' that the University of Newcastle applied confidentiality requirements even after investigations concluded and until students were no longer enrolled
- UTS said it had apologised to Hailey 'in writing and verbally' and continued to offer support, though Hailey said she was still waiting for the apology
Contradictions
Conflicting information between sources:
- NEWSCOMAU states that UTS told the NSO it placed no restriction on students discussing complaints with 'family and friends,' but ABC does not explicitly contradict thisâonly notes the NSO found the university's advice was inconsistent
- NEWSCOMAU reports that UTS 'told the student after the âinsufficient evidenceâ finding that âthere isâ (quote incomplete),' while ABC does not provide the exact wording but focuses on the university's broader handling of the case
- NEWSCOMAU does not mention the specific name 'Hailey*' or her direct quotes about feeling 'blindsided,' which are prominently featured in ABC's article
- ABC states that Hailey 'was still waiting for an apology' over the confidentiality investigation, while UTS claims it had already apologised 'in writing and verbally'
- NEWSCOMAU does not specify that UTS initially planned to tell all students in the law society about the unsubstantiated complaint, a detail highlighted by ABC
Source Articles
âSilencedâ: Aussie unis gag students
Australian universities have improperly used confidentiality clauses while claiming âzero toleranceâ for gender-based violence....
UTS 'effectively silenced' student who complained of sexual harassment
The National Student Ombudsman takes aim at the University of Technology Sydney in one of its first major investigations, accusing the university of isolating a young complainant....