TGA proposes reforms to Australian sunscreen regulations amid SPF testing controversies
Consensus Summary
The Therapeutic Goods Administration (TGA) is proposing major reforms to Australia’s sunscreen regulations after consumer group CHOICE revealed in June 2023 that 16 out of 20 popular SPF50+ sunscreens failed to meet their advertised protection levels. The TGA’s draft proposals aim to address inconsistencies in SPF testing, strengthen oversight of testing laboratories, and simplify labelling—potentially replacing numerical SPF ratings with word-based categories like ‘low’ or ‘high’ to clarify protection levels for consumers. Over 20 sunscreen products have already been recalled or paused since CHOICE’s testing, including Ultra Violette’s ‘Lean Screen 50+’ (tested at SPF4) and Coles’ SPF50+ Ultra Tube (tested at SPF43). The TGA cites Australia’s high skin cancer mortality rate (around 2,000 deaths annually) as a priority for ensuring consumer confidence. While CHOICE supports expanded testing and transparency, it opposes the proposed word-based ratings, arguing consumers are accustomed to numerical SPF values. The TGA has launched a public consultation, with Professor Tony Lawler defending the regulator’s proactive stance, including mandatory recalls and voluntary actions taken during the reform process. Industry stakeholders and consumer advocates are now weighing in on the balance between innovation, transparency, and maintaining global regulatory alignment.
✓ Verified by 2+ sources
Key details reported by multiple sources:
- The Therapeutic Goods Administration (TGA) has proposed sweeping reforms to Australian sunscreen regulations, including changes to SPF testing requirements, lab oversight, and simplified SPF labelling (ABC, NEWSCOMAU).
- Consumer group CHOICE tested 20 popular SPF50 and SPF50+ sunscreens in June 2023 and found 16 did not meet their SPF label claims (ABC, NEWSCOMAU).
- The TGA has opened a public consultation process on the proposed reforms, citing Australia’s high rates of skin cancer and melanoma (around 2,000 deaths annually) as justification (ABC, NEWSCOMAU).
- Seven sunscreens tested by CHOICE returned SPF results significantly lower than their SPF50+ claims, including Banana Boat Baby Zinc Sunscreen Lotion (tested at SPF28) and Coles SPF50+ Sunscreen Ultra Tube (tested at SPF43) (ABC, NEWSCOMAU).
- The TGA has recalled or paused supply of over 20 sunscreen products since CHOICE’s testing (ABC, NEWSCOMAU).
- Ultra Violette’s Australian Sunscreen ‘Lean Screen 50+’ tested at SPF4, with the company previously boasting about high testing costs on Instagram (NEWSCOMAU).
- The TGA’s proposed reforms include requiring public disclosure of SPF testing data, though this may expose trade secrets (ABC).
- Professor Tony Lawler, TGA head, defended the regulator’s handling of the scandal, stating investigations into underperforming sunscreens would continue (ABC).
Points of Difference
Details reported by only one source:
- The TGA flagged replacing SPF numbers with ‘low’, ‘medium’, ‘high’, and ‘very high’ ratings to address consumer misconceptions about the SPF scale (e.g., minimal difference between SPF30 and SPF50) (ABC).
- CHOICE Director Andy Kelly stated the group opposes replacing SPF numbers with word-based ratings, citing consumer familiarity with the current system (ABC).
- The TGA acknowledged legislative amendments and industry investment would be required to implement the new labelling system (ABC).
- Professor Lawler emphasized the TGA’s risk-based approach, balancing prompt action (e.g., recalls) with proportionate regulatory reform (ABC).
- The TGA’s consultation paper outlines seven areas for reform, including maintaining current standards as an option (ABC).
- The TGA has not ruled out further regulatory action on individual products, though it declined to comment on imminent recalls (ABC).
- The TGA’s report highlighted ‘misunderstandings about SPF values’ and ‘variability of test results’ as key reasons for reform (NEWSCOMAU).
- The regulator found some manufacturers lacked awareness of their legal obligations regarding SPF claims (NEWSCOMAU).
- The TGA plans to adopt new testing technologies faster and improve quality assurance through regular testing and ingredients standards (NEWSCOMAU).
- Ultra Violette’s Instagram post claimed its sunscreen testing cost up to $150,000, framing it as a commitment to integrity (NEWSCOMAU).
- The TGA’s spokesman stated the reforms aim to ‘strengthen confidence in sunscreen performance’ and ‘provide sponsors greater certainty of regulatory compliance’ (NEWSCOMAU).
Contradictions
Conflicting information between sources:
- ABC reports the TGA proposed replacing SPF numbers with word-based ratings (e.g., ‘low’, ‘medium’), while NEWSCOMAU does not explicitly mention this proposal as a primary focus beyond simplified labelling.
- NEWSCOMAU states the TGA found ‘some product owners and manufacturers lacked an understanding about their legal obligations,’ but ABC does not reference this specific finding.
- ABC notes the TGA’s consultation paper offers multiple options for reform, including maintaining current standards, while NEWSCOMAU frames the reforms as a ‘crackdown’ with fewer nuanced options.
- NEWSCOMAU highlights the TGA’s report on ‘complex exemption rules for cosmetic sunscreens,’ a detail not emphasized in ABC’s coverage.
- ABC quotes CHOICE’s Andy Kelly as concerned about replacing SPF numbers with word ratings, but NEWSCOMAU does not include this specific criticism.
Source Articles
Regulator’s crackdown on dud sunscreen claims
Australia’s medicines regulator has revealed new regulations for sunscreen after it was revealed some of the most iconic Aussie brands may not meet their labelled SPF claims...
TGA releases proposed reforms to Australian sunscreen regulation
The proposals include a number of changes to SPF testing requirements, oversight of the labs that do SPF testing, and the way SPF is labelled — reforms that would overhaul the sunscreen industry....
TGA not 'sitting on our hands', defends handling of sunscreen scandal
In his first interview since the sunscreen controversy erupted almost 10 months ago, the Therapeutic Goods Administration head says he hopes the proposed shake-up of regulations will restore consumer ...