Victorian government's review of the Suburban Rail Loop project and potential cancellation
Consensus Summary
Victorian Premier Ben Carroll is reviewing the controversial Suburban Rail Loop (SRL) project, considering potential cancellation or redirection of funds after both sides of politics have expressed doubts about its viability. The SRL, first promised by Daniel Andrews in 2018, has seen $14.5 billion in contracts signed, with $11.8 billion committed by the state and $6 billion from the federal government, including $3.8 billion from May’s federal budget. The project’s first stage, SRL East, is a 26km tunnel between Cheltenham and Box Hill, with an official cost of $34.5 billion calculated in 2021. Two tunnel-boring machines are operational in Burwood, expected to begin tunnelling in four to six weeks, while $2.5 billion in early works and $5.3 billion in tunnelling contracts are already underway. Opposition Leader Jess Wilson has pledged to pause and review the project if elected in November, while Carroll has not ruled out redirecting funds to other projects, including Melbourne Airport Rail. The Age suggests the SRL’s total cost could reach $40 billion or $50 billion, while the Guardian cites a Parliamentary Budget Office report estimating cancellation could save $21 billion over a decade, though $1.8 billion in termination fees would apply. Both sources agree the project faces criticism over its origins, business case, and cost, with Carroll privately calling it a 'lemon' and prioritizing more pressing infrastructure needs in Melbourne’s outer regions.
✓ Verified by 2+ sources
Key details reported by multiple sources:
- The Suburban Rail Loop (SRL) project has contracts worth $14.5 billion signed by the government.
- The SRL East stage (Cheltenham to Box Hill) has an official price tag of $34.5 billion, calculated in 2021.
- The SRL was first promised by Daniel Andrews ahead of the 2018 election.
- The state government has committed about $11.8 billion for the first stage of the SRL (SRL East).
- The federal government allocated $6 billion to the SRL, including $3.8 billion in May’s federal budget.
- Two tunnel-boring machines are in the ground in Burwood, expected to begin tunnelling to Glen Waverley in four to six weeks.
- Opposition Leader Jess Wilson has said if the Coalition is elected in November, she will pause and review the project.
- The SRL East stage is a 26km stretch of tunnels between Cheltenham and Box Hill.
- The SRL has $2.5 billion of early works already completed and paid for.
- Two consortiums have been chosen to do $5.3 billion of tunnelling for the SRL.
Points of Difference
Details reported by only one source:
- The SRL has an identity crisis as it is unclear whether it is a transport project with apartments or a housing project with a rail line.
- The auditor-general will hand down a detailed report into the project’s financing and revenue assumptions next month.
- The SRL East cost was calculated in 2021, but a truer cost may emerge in the auditor-general’s report.
- Premier Ben Carroll said on Wednesday that he values public money and would not break contracts, though they could be renegotiated.
- Carroll privately told colleagues he thinks the SRL is a 'lemon' and will direct the SRL Authority to prepare a full briefing on contractual commitments.
- The SRL’s Burwood launch site should be kept untouched as an exhibit to remind future generations of poor financial decisions.
- The SRL’s total cost could reach $40 billion or $50 billion if fully completed.
- The SRL’s early works cost $2.5 billion, and tunnelling contracts worth $5.3 billion are already underway.
- Ben Carroll flagged 'sensible changes' to Jacinta Allan’s bill legislating the right to work from home two days a week, expected to pass the lower house by the end of today.
- The bill will be debated in the upper house during the next parliamentary sitting week beginning 11 August.
- The SRL is a 90km public transport project, with tunnel-boring machines expected to start tunnelling in four to six weeks.
- The federal government’s share of infrastructure funding for Victoria dropped to 8% under the former federal Coalition government.
- The independent Parliamentary Budget Office found cancelling the SRL now would improve the state’s budget position by $21 billion over the decade, with $1.8 billion in contract termination fees.
- Carroll spoke to Anthony Albanese on Wednesday, but did not discuss diverting federal funds into other projects.
- Albanese said he would work constructively with the Victorian government to ensure Victorians’ interests are looked after.
Where the reporting differs
Details that conflict, or appear in only some outlets:
- The Guardian states the SRL is a 90km project, while The Age does not specify the total length but focuses on the 26km SRL East stage.
- The Guardian mentions the SRL was first promised by Andrews ahead of the 2018 election, while The Age does not specify the exact election but notes it was part of Andrews’ legacy.
- The Guardian says the SRL’s total cost could be improved by $21 billion if cancelled, while The Age does not mention this specific budgetary figure.
Source Articles
There is no need for a Daniel Andrews statue. Ben Carroll has a more fitting tribute in mind
The question of what to do with the Suburban Rail Loop is a riddle wrapped in a mystery and ensnared in $14.5 billion worth of government contracts.
Ben Carroll will not rule out redirecting Suburban Rail Loop funds to other projects
New Victorian premier also considering ‘sensible changes’ to laws that would enshrine right to work from home two days a week Follow our Australia news live blog for latest updates Get our breaking news email , free app or daily news podcast Victoria’s new premier has not ruled out redirecting billions of dollars earmarked for the controversial Suburban Rail Loop to other projects, saying he’s seeking to pursue the “greatest value for Victorians”. Ben Carroll also used his second day in the top