Victorian Liberal MP Moira Deeming loses preselection for upper house seat
Consensus Summary
Moira Deeming, a controversial Victorian Liberal MP, lost her preselection for the upper house seat in the Western Metropolitan Region after a contentious vote on Sunday. Dinesh Gourisetty secured the top spot with 39 votes, defeating Deeming (26 votes) and Trung Luu (3 votes), ending her political career in the Liberal Party unless she defects to another party. Deeming’s fallout with the party began in 2023 after she threatened defamation action against then-leader John Pesutto over his comments about her alleged Nazi sympathies, a controversy that escalated when she won a defamation case against him in December 2024. Despite backing from high-profile conservatives like Tony Abbott and Peta Credlin, Deeming’s polarizing stance on issues like transgender rights and her attendance at a neo-Nazi-gatecrashed rally damaged her standing within the party. The preselection process was marked by allegations of irregularities, with Deeming complaining about early voting and ID checks, though the party rejected her calls to invalidate the ballots. One Nation has expressed openness to discussions with Deeming, while Libertarians have not ruled out the possibility. The Western Metropolitan Region is a critical battleground for the November election, and the Liberal Party’s decision to replace Deeming signals a shift toward more moderate candidates like Gourisetty, who has strong support in the western suburbs. The outcome reflects broader tensions within the party between conservative and moderate factions, with Deeming’s loss seen by some as an opportunity to reset the party’s direction.
✓ Verified by 2+ sources
Key details reported by multiple sources:
- Moira Deeming was dumped from the Victorian Liberal Party’s upper house ticket for the November 2024 election after losing a preselection vote in the Western Metropolitan Region.
- Dinesh Gourisetty won the top spot in the Western Metropolitan Region preselection with 39 votes, defeating Moira Deeming (26 votes) and Trung Luu (3 votes).
- Deeming was expelled from the Liberal Party room in 2023 after threatening defamation action against then-leader John Pesutto over comments about her alleged Nazi sympathies.
- Deeming won a defamation case against Pesutto in December 2024, leading to his loss of the Liberal leadership in late 2024.
- Deeming was backed by former PM Tony Abbott and media commentator Peta Credlin during her preselection challenge.
- The preselection vote took place at Liberal Party headquarters on Collins Street, Melbourne, on Sunday, with results announced around 3pm.
- Deeming did not contest for the second spot on the ballot and left party headquarters immediately after her loss.
- One Nation state president Warren Pickering said his party was open to discussions with Deeming if she considers defecting.
- The Western Metropolitan Region is a key battleground for the November 2024 election, with Labor’s popularity waning after three terms.
Points of Difference
Details reported by only one source:
- Deeming offered to delay bankruptcy proceedings against Pesutto in 2023 if the party bypassed its rules and guaranteed her preselection.
- Deeming attended an anti-trans-rights rally in 2023 that was gatecrashed by neo-Nazis, which became a major controversy.
- Deeming was suspended from the parliamentary Liberal Party before being expelled after threatening defamation action against Pesutto.
- Deeming was elected to the upper house in 2022 and had the backing of conservative figures including Tony Abbott and Peta Credlin.
- Deeming did not speak with media before or after the vote.
- The Victorian Liberal party has stripped voting rights from four delegates in the days leading up to the preselection, citing constitutional justifications.
- Gourisetty had donated to Pesutto’s legal fund during his defamation case.
- Deeming was described as a 'Nazi sympathiser' by former Liberal leader John Pesutto in her first months in parliament, a saga that has dogged the party for three years.
- One party member hoped Deeming’s loss was a 'line in the sand' and an opportunity to reset the party.
- Liberals expect to easily re-elect two MPs in the region at the November election, particularly given Labor’s waning popularity.
- The legitimacy of branch meetings in which delegates were elected had faced challenges.
- Deeming’s supporters hoped she would defect to One Nation and criticized Pesutto for not being present at the vote.
- Liberals stripped voting rights from four delegates using justifications under the party’s constitution, such as working for MPs.
- Deeming’s vote tally was reported as 26 votes, with Gourisetty receiving 39 and Luu receiving 3.
- Deeming’s initial preselection in 2022 created controversy due to her views on abortion and transgender rights.
- Deeming was appointed as the 'leader’s representative to the western suburbs' after her defamation win, a role not continued under current leader Jess Wilson.
- Deeming complained to the party’s executive about irregularities in the delegate selection process, including early voting and lack of ID checks.
- Deeming called for the ballots to be declared invalid and re-run, but the executive rejected her request.
- The preselection vote included delegates from western suburbs branches, a random pool of metropolitan Melbourne members, and the executive.
- Phones of attendees were confiscated during the vote, with the final result expected at about 3pm.
- Bev McArthur survived a challenge by Trent Sullivan on Saturday to hold the No.1 ticket spot in the Western Victoria region.
Contradictions
Conflicting information between sources:
- ABC reports Deeming was expelled after threatening defamation action, while THEAGE states she was suspended before expulsion and describes Pesutto's comments as accusing her of being a 'Nazi sympathiser'—a distinction not made in ABC.
- THEAGE reports Deeming received 26 votes, while GUARDIAN does not specify her vote count but describes the vote as a 'serious challenge' without exact numbers.
- ABC states Deeming did not contest for the second spot, but GUARDIAN implies she may have considered it by mentioning she did not nominate for it.
- THEAGE claims Deeming’s supporters hoped she would defect to One Nation, while ABC states she did not indicate she would defect and speculation remains open.
- GUARDIAN mentions Deeming complained about irregularities in delegate selection and called for ballots to be invalidated, but ABC and THEAGE do not explicitly mention this complaint.
Source Articles
Moira Deeming dumped: MP loses Liberal preselection battle
Deeming quickly left the party’s headquarters without comment on Sunday after losing the hard-fought ballot, fuelling speculation she could defect to One Nation or the Libertarians....
D-day for Moira Deeming as she faces preselection challenge for Victorian Liberal seat
Party members to determine MP’s political future after Dinesh Gourisetty also nominated for upper house seat Get our breaking news email , free app or daily news podcast Moira Deeming’s political futu...
Liberals dump Moira Deeming from ticket for next state election
Controversial Victorian MP Moira Deeming has lost her preselection battle for the state election, with Liberal Party members replacing her with business leader Dinesh Gourisetty....