Trial of three men accused of killing Australian brothers and American friend in Mexico
Consensus Summary
Three men accused of killing Australian brothers Jake and Callum Robinson and their American friend Carter Rhoad in April 2024 are on trial in Ensenada, Mexico. The victims, aged 31, 32, and 33 respectively, were shot dead during a surfing trip in Baja California, with their bodies later found in a well near Punta San José. The trial, which began with a last-minute judge replacement presiding remotely, is a judge-only proceeding expected to last four weeks, though initial reports suggested a shorter timeline. The defendants—Jesús Gerardo, Irineo Francisco, and Ángel Jesús—face charges of aggravated homicide, aggravated robbery, violent robbery, and grand theft auto, with prosecutors seeking sentences totaling over 200 years for each man.
The case stems from a botched robbery where the victims were allegedly ambushed while camping in a remote coastal area. Their burnt-out car, missing its tyres, was found near the well where their bodies were discovered. Investigators believe the attack was instigated by Ari Gisell, the former girlfriend of Jesús Gerardo, who was sentenced to 20 years in prison in 2025 for her role in the murders. The FBI cooperated with Mexican authorities in locating the bodies, though the extent of their involvement has not been publicly confirmed. The trial has been marked by procedural challenges, including witness intimidation and the need for a judge replacement due to an 'accident' over the weekend.
The parents of Jake and Callum Robinson, Martin and Debra, traveled from Perth to attend the trial, emphasizing their desire for truth and justice rather than revenge. Martin Robinson testified that his life has been 'hell' since the murders, describing the emotional toll of losing both sons in horrific circumstances. Debra Robinson also spoke about the importance of being present for their sons, who were deeply loved and had bright futures ahead. Witnesses, including a colleague of Callum’s and the mother of Carter Rhoad, have provided testimony about the victims’ final days and the circumstances surrounding their deaths, painting a picture of a tragedy that has left families devastated.
Coverage of the trial diverges slightly in emphasis and detail. While ABC, Guardian, and 7NEWS all agree on the core facts, discrepancies arise in the ages of the victims—ABC reports Jake as 31 and Callum as 32, while Guardian and 7NEWS list them as 30 and 33. Additionally, the expected duration of the trial varies, with some sources initially mentioning 20 days before extending to four weeks. The Guardian also notes the trial may conclude by the end of September, a detail not echoed by other outlets. Despite these differences, all sources highlight the emotional testimony from the victims’ families and the procedural hurdles faced by the court.
The trial remains unresolved, with dozens of witnesses expected to testify over the coming weeks. The defendants have not entered pleas and rejected plea deals that would have resulted in sentences between 47 and 52 years. The prosecution’s case hinges on evidence linking the accused to the crime scene, including testimony from intimidated witnesses and forensic findings. Once the trial concludes, the judge will have 24 hours to make a judgment and a week to deliver the verdict, though the final outcome remains uncertain. The case has drawn international attention, underscoring the broader issue of violence against tourists in Mexico’s Pacific coastal regions.
✓ Verified by 2+ sources
Key details reported by multiple sources:
- Three men—Jesús Gerardo (also known as 'El Kekas'), Irineo Francisco, and Ángel Jesús—are on trial for the aggravated homicide, aggravated burglary, violent robbery, and grand theft auto of Jake and Callum Robinson (Australian brothers) and Carter Rhoad (American friend) in April 2024.
- The victims were killed in Baja California, Mexico, while on a surfing trip, and their bodies were found in a well near Punta San José, about 80 kilometres south of Ensenada.
- The trial began in April 2024 and is being held in Ensenada, Mexico, with a judge-only proceeding expected to last four weeks (or 20 days, as initially reported).
- The former girlfriend of Jesús Gerardo, Ari Gisell, was sentenced to 20 years in jail in 2025 for her role in the murders.
- The prosecution is seeking 210-year jail sentences for each of the three accused, with an additional 168-year sentence for Jesús Gerardo for forced disappearance.
- The defendants rejected plea deals that would have resulted in sentences between 47 and 52 years.
- The victims were aged 31 (Jake), 32 (Callum), and 33 (Carter Rhoad).
- The trial was delayed due to a last-minute judge replacement, who presided remotely on the first day.
- Two witnesses were intimidated by people connected to the accused, leading to their removal from the courtroom and placement in witness protection.
- The parents of Jake and Callum Robinson, Martin and Debra, traveled from Perth to attend the trial, seeking answers and justice.
How the outlets covered it
4 outlets reported this story. ABC News published first; 7News followed 42 h later.
| Outlet | Published | After first | Headline |
|---|---|---|---|
| ABC News | 6 Sept, 3:21 pm | First | 'Not about revenge': Parents of Perth brothers killed in Mexico to attend trial |
| The Guardian | 8 Sept, 3:29 am | +36 h | Alleged killers of Australian surfers and American friend go on trial in Mexico |
| 7News | 8 Sept, 9:02 am | +42 h | Callum and Jake Robinson: Mexico murder trial erupts as witnesses ‘intimidated’ on day one |
| SBS News | Time not given | n/a | 'We want to find out why': Parents of slain Aussie surfers look for answers in murder trial |
Times are when each outlet published, from its own feed, in Sydney time. Outlets whose feeds don’t give a publish time are listed last. See how this works.
Points of Difference
Details reported by only one source:
- The first clue in the investigation was acquired on May 1, 2024, about four days after the men went missing.
- A forensics specialist testified that blood-stained clothes, a .45-calibre bullet, blood smears, and a tooth were found at the crime scene, all severely burned.
- The trial was initially expected to last about a month, but a judge replacement extended it to four weeks.
- The judge will have 24 hours to make a judgment and another week to hand down the verdict after the trial concludes.
- A prosecutor argued that Ari Gisell was the instigator of the attack due to her interest in the tyres of the victims' car and their phones.
- The burnt-out car was believed to have belonged to the missing men, and its tyres were missing.
- The trial is expected to run until the end of September.
- The victims were aged 30 (Jake) and 33 (Callum), with Carter Rhoad also aged 30.
- The ex-girlfriend of one of the accused was sentenced to 20 years in prison last year after admitting she instigated the robbery.
- The crime sparked outrage and sadness in Australia and the United States, with the victims having bright futures in medicine, lacrosse, and marriage.
- The trial initially was expected to run for 20 days but was extended to four weeks due to the judge replacement.
- The defendants were removed from the courtroom when two witnesses were allegedly intimidated by people connected to the accused.
- The trial is expected to hear from more than 30 witnesses over an estimated six weeks, though the ABC and Guardian report a four-week timeline.
- A protected witness testified that they accompanied one of the defendants to the crime scene and fled after hearing gunshots, later being threatened into silence.
- The trial got off to a rocky start with witnesses reportedly receiving death threats and being placed in witness protection.
Where the reporting differs
Details that conflict, or appear in only some outlets:
- The Guardian and 7NEWS report the victims were aged 30 and 33, while ABC reports Jake was 31, Callum 32, and Carter Rhoad 33.
- ABC and 7NEWS state the trial is expected to last four weeks, while 7NEWS initially mentions a 20-day timeline before the extension.
- The Guardian reports the trial is expected to run until the end of September, while other sources do not specify this exact end date.
- ABC and 7NEWS mention the judge will have 24 hours to make a judgment and a week to hand down the verdict, but the Guardian does not reference this timeline.
Source Articles
Court hears how Mexican police found bodies of Australian brothers
Mexican authorities tell a court in Ensenada of the grim clues that led to the remains of Australian brothers Jake and Callum Robinson and their American friend Carter Rhoad being found.
Parents of Australian brothers killed at Mexican surfing hotspot attend murder trial – video
The parents of two Perth surfers killed alongside their American friend attended the start of the trial of three men accused of their murder in Mexico. Debra and Martin Robinson travelled to the port city of Ensenada in Baja California state for the proceedings after the deaths of their sons, Callum and Jake Robinson, and American Jack Carter Rhoad Alleged killers of Australian surfers and American friend go on trial in Mexico Continue reading...
Family of Jake and Callum Robinson in court in Mexico as Perth brothers’ accused killers go on trial
The mother and father of two brothers allegedly murdered while on a surf trip have made the long journey overseas to come face to face with their accused killers.
'Not about revenge': Parents of Perth brothers killed in Mexico to attend trial
The parents of Australian brothers Jake and Callum Robinson are travelling to Mexico for the trial of the men accused of murdering their sons, saying it's not about revenge, but hearing the truth and representing all those who loved them.
Jake and Callum Robinson’s dad tells court life is ‘hell’ without Perth brothers after their alleged murders in Mexico
The siblings’ death during a surfing and camping jaunt has ‘left a huge hole’ in the lives of their family.
FBI involved in locating bodies of Jake and Callum Robinson in Mexico, court hears
The bodies of two Australian men and their American friend who were shot dead while on a surfing trip in Mexico in 2024 were found through the United States FBI, a murder trial hears.
Callum and Jake Robinson: Mexico murder trial erupts as witnesses ‘intimidated’ on day one
The Mexico trial of the three men accused of killing Perth brothers Callum and Jake Robinson has had an ugly start, with witnesses reportedly intimidated in the courtroom.
Alleged killers of Australian surfers and American friend go on trial in Mexico
Three men on trial for killing Jake and Callum Robinson and Jack Carter Rhoad in Baja California in 2024 The alleged killers of two Australian surfers and an American at a Mexican surfing hotspot in 2024 have gone on trial in the border resort where the three were murdered. The Australian brothers Jake and Callum Robinson, aged 30 and 33, respectively, and their 30-year-old American friend Jack Carter Rhoad were shot dead after being robbed in Mexico’s violence-hit Baja California . Continue rea
Judge replaced as alleged killers of Australian brothers face trial in Mexico
The parents of Callum and Jake Robinson come face to face with their sons' alleged killers at their murder trial in Mexico, as the judge is unexpectedly replaced due to a weekend "accident".
'We want to find out why': Parents of slain Aussie surfers look for answers in murder trial
The bodies of the Robinson brothers were found alongside their American friend Jack Carter Rhoad in a well in Mexico.
Callum and Jake Robinson: Perth dad delivers sad testimony in Mexico trial for men accused of killing sons
The father of the Perth brothers murdered while on a Mexican surf trip in 2024 has delivered a heart-wrenching hour-long testimony on the second day of the trial of three men accused of killing his sons.
‘It’s hell’: father of slain Australian surfers tells Mexico homicide trial about identifying sons’ bodies
Three men are on trial over the death of brothers Jake and Callum Robinson and their friend, US citizen Jack Carter Rhoad, in Ensenada The father of two Australian surfers killed in Mexico two years ago testified in court on Tuesday that his life had been turned into hell, as the high-profile trial continued into its second day. Three men are charged in the killing of Australian brothers Jake and Callum Robinson, aged 30 and 33, respectively, and their 30-year-old American friend Jack Carter Rho
More Crime stories
Bondi Beach terror attack and hero Ahmed Al Ahmed's aftermath one year later
David Walliams accused of grooming and sexual misconduct against teenage girls
Beau Lamarre-Condon's double murder trial for killing Jesse Baird and Luke Davies in 2024
Russell Brand convicted and sentenced for rape and sexual assault involving multiple women
Fatal stabbing of Melbourne food delivery driver Jianming Feng sparks safety debate
Robert Crawford on trial for alleged murder of wife Frances Crawford in 2024
Latest cross-verified stories
Usman Khawaja's book reignites Sandpapergate scandal, implicating entire 2018 Australian cricket team
Australia wins 4th straight Women’s Rugby League World Cup, defeating New Zealand 34-10
AFLW semi-final incident: Swans nurse Lexi Hamilton aids injured Geelong ruck Piper Dunlop
Oil tanker collides with cruise ship in New Orleans, Mississippi River, causing rescue operation
Australian PM Albanese's hot-mic gaffe at COP31 climate summit in Antalya, Türkiye
SpaceX Starship achieves first orbital upper-stage catch in historic test flight
Browse all stories from September 2026 in the archive.