Victorian government expands device bans in all schools including smartwatches and headphones
Consensus Summary
The Victorian government is expanding its device ban in schools to include smartwatches and wireless headphones, effective from January 2027, applying to all public, Catholic, and private schools. The policy builds on the 2020 phone ban in public schools, which an independent review found improved student focus, socialization, and reduced device-related incidents. Smartwatches with notifications, internet access, or recording functions will be restricted, while exceptions will allow health-related device use. Education Minister Ben Carroll emphasized the need for disruption-free classrooms, citing evolving technology as a reason for the stricter rules. Independent Schools Victoria and the Catholic Education Authority welcomed the policy, noting it aligns with their existing efforts to balance technology use and student wellbeing. While parents and schools have generally supported the ban, some concerns remain about consistency, parental responsibility, and the broad scope of the restrictions. Schools like Caroline Chisholm Catholic College have already seen positive outcomes, such as improved student perceptions of fairness and increased social connections, though critics argue more student and family involvement in policy design is necessary.
✓ Verified by 2+ sources
Key details reported by multiple sources:
- Victorian public and private (including Catholic) schools will ban internet-enabled smartwatches and wireless headphones from term one 2027
- Mobile phones have been banned in Victorian public schools since 2020, with the policy expanded to all schools starting January 27 2027
- Smartwatches with notifications, internet connection, or recording functions will be restricted during school hours
- Education Minister Ben Carroll stated the phone ban led to increased student focus, improved socialization, and fewer device-related incidents
- Independent review found students were more focused in class and more social during breaks after the phone ban
- Exceptions for health-related device use will be allowed under the new legislation
- The Victorian Registration and Qualifications Authority will enforce compliance for private and Catholic schools
- Rachel Holthouse (Independent Schools Victoria CEO) welcomed the policy as supporting positive learning environments and student wellbeing
- Elizabeth Labone (Victorian Catholic Education Authority CEO) supported the announcement as enhancing student engagement and learning
Points of Difference
Details reported by only one source:
- Parents Victoria chief executive Gail McHardy advocated for student-led consultation in policy changes and noted mixed parental views on effectiveness
- Ben Carroll described smartwatches as a 'new disruptive machine' in classrooms and stated 60% of children aged 7-12 use smartwatches
- Parents Victoria expressed concerns about shifting responsibility onto schools instead of partnerships with families
- Caroline Chisholm Catholic College introduced a strict phone policy in 2019, later tightening it in 2024 to ban all devices including headphones and disable smartwatch internet
- School reported 20% increase in students believing rules enforced fairly, 10% increase in keeping good friends, and 5% increase in feeling connected to staff post-ban
- Year 12 student Macbeth Gonsalves noted reduced phone gaming in classrooms but saw more physical activity and social connections during breaks
- Principal Napoleon Rodezno cited inconsistency in school policies as a challenge and compared current device access to 'giving kids a licence without being able to drive the vehicle'
- The draft legislation will be introduced into parliament on Wednesday (implied as the announcement day)
- Premier Jacinta Allan announced the sweeping changes on Wednesday morning
- The article explicitly states Victoria is the first state to introduce these rules
Contradictions
Conflicting information between sources:
- ABC notes mixed parental views on the ban's effectiveness, while THEAGE and NEWSCOMAU do not mention parental opposition or mixed views
- THEAGE reports a 20% increase in students believing rules enforced fairly post-ban, but this specific statistic is not mentioned in ABC or NEWSCOMAU
- ABC states 60% of children aged 7-12 use smartwatches, but this percentage is not referenced in THEAGE or NEWSCOMAU
- THEAGE highlights a student-led consultation process at Caroline Chisholm Catholic College, but ABC does not mention this specific approach beyond general student involvement advocacy
- NEWSCOMAU claims Victoria is the first state to introduce these rules, but ABC and THEAGE do not explicitly state this as a unique claim
Source Articles
Smartwatches, headphones restricted in classrooms in new device crackdown
Victoria’s nation-leading ban on phones on classrooms will be extended to all private schools, and will now include internet-enabled smartwatches and wireless headphones....
Phone ban in classrooms extended to include smartwatches, headphones
Victorian students in public and private schools will be banned from wearing smartwatches with internet connectivity and using headphones in classrooms from next year after the government announced an...
Major change coming to Victorian schools
The sweeping new changes will be applied to all Victorian schools in an effort to reduce distraction rates in the classroom....