Analysis of the 2026 DC film *Supergirl* starring Milly Alcock
Consensus Summary
The 2026 DC film *Supergirl*, directed by Craig Gillespie and starring Milly Alcock as Kara Zor-El, received mixed reviews from ABC and The Guardian. Both sources agree on key elements: Jason Momoa as Lobo, Eve Ridley as Ruthye, and a plot involving the kidnapping of Supergirlās dog Krypto. The film explores Supergirlās origins on Krypton and her arrival on Earth, with David Krumholtz reprising his role as her father, Zor-El. However, the articles diverge sharply on tone and themes. The ABC criticizes the film for its bland script, disjointed editing, and missed opportunities to explore feminist or feminist themes, while The Guardian praises its clear storytelling and feminist moments, such as Ruthye teaching Lobo to escape prison. Both agree the film avoids the convoluted DC backstory seen in earlier films, but the ABC finds it dull and derivative, whereas The Guardian sees potential for the franchise. The filmās musical choices and pacing are also points of contention, with ABC lamenting a lack of creativity and Guardian focusing on its energetic approach.
ā Verified by 2+ sources
Key details reported by multiple sources:
- Milly Alcock stars as Supergirl (Kara Zor-El) in the film
- Jason Momoa plays the bounty hunter Lobo in the movie
- Eve Ridley portrays Ruthye Marye Knoll, a secondary protagonist
- David Krumholtz plays Supergirlās father, Zor-El
- The film features a plot involving Krypto, Supergirlās dog, being kidnapped
- The movie references Supergirlās origins on Krypton and her arrival on Earth
- Craig Gillespie directed *Supergirl* (2026)
- The film includes a scene where Supergirlās dog Krypto is disabled and sidelined
Points of Difference
Details reported by only one source:
- The filmās scriptwriter is Ana Nogueira, who originated the role of Eliza Schuyler in *Hamilton*
- The article criticizes the filmās editing as overly fast-paced, comparing it to TikTok-friendly pacing
- The filmās music choices are described as 'pop-punk and clunky,' lacking the impact of James Gunnās work
- The article mentions a 'Brat Summer' reference tied to Supergirlās intergalactic pub crawl
- The filmās plot is compared to *Mad Max: Fury Road* for its later story beats
- The article highlights a 'Riot Grrrl track' suggestion as a missed opportunity for the soundtrack
- The filmās protagonist is described as 'cynical' and 'apathetic,' with a 'drunken, disheveled' appearance
- The article explicitly states the filmās release year as 2026, with a publication date of 2026-06-26
- Matthias Schoenaerts plays Krem of the Yellow Hills, an intergalactic human trafficker
- The film includes a feminist moment where Ruthye schools Lobo on prison escape techniques
- Supergirlās flight style is described as 'rising vertically up and down, one knee slightly bent,' not the classic horizontal mode
- The article notes a cameo by David Corenswet as Superman in a 'caring big-brother mode'
- The filmās plot involves avenging the death of Ruthyeās father at Kremās hands
- The article mentions a copyright concern over the term 'Supergirl' vs. 'Superman,' referencing Friedrich Nietzscheās *Ćbermensch*
- The filmās release year is implied to be 2026, with a publication date of 2026-06-24
Contradictions
Conflicting information between sources:
- The ABC article claims the filmās scriptwriter Ana Nogueira is 'relatively new to feature film writing,' while the Guardian does not mention her writing experience
- The ABC article describes Supergirlās costume as 'not figure-hugging,' while the Guardian explicitly states she 'isnāt required (yet) to model any figure-hugging costume,' implying a future possibility
- The ABC article criticizes the filmās editing as 'dizzying' and 'butchered,' while the Guardian praises it for being 'sprightly and sparkling' without excessive backstory
- The ABC article emphasizes the filmās failure to explore Supergirlās feminist themes, while the Guardian highlights a 'clear feminist moment' involving Ruthye and Lobo
- The ABC article describes the filmās tone as 'dull' and 'disappointing,' while the Guardian calls it a 'sprightlier and sparkier' superhero yarn
Source Articles
Supergirl shoots for the moon, but runs out of fuel
Australian Milly Alcock shines as Supergirl in the hero's first solo outing since 1984. If only the rest of the movie sparkled around her.
Supergirl review ā sprightly and sparkling superhero yarn without the usual baffling DC backstory
Milly Alcockās Supergirl joins with Eve Ridleyās Ruthye to fight an evil intergalactic human trafficker The sexual politics of perceived female maturity has always been a problem in this particular set of superhero films. Quite why Kara Zor-El gets to be a āsupergirlā while Kal-El gets to be a āsupermanā, despite not being that much older, is not obvious. Even that notorious wokester Friedrich Nietzsche went with the non-gender term āĆbermenschā. The issue is in fact pre-emptively raised here in