Deadly LaGuardia Airport plane crash involving Air Canada jet and fire truck
Consensus Summary
An Air Canada Express regional jet operated by Jazz Aviation collided with a Port Authority fire truck at LaGuardia Airport on October 2024, killing both pilots and injuring dozens. The fire truck, responding to a United Airlines odor incident, was cleared to cross the runway just before the jet landed, despite the controllerâs last-second stop command. Investigators found the truck lacked a transponder, preventing the airportâs surveillance system from detecting it, and the NTSB is examining whether controller workloadâincluding managing a late-night emergency and handling double the usual trafficâplayed a role. The crash closed Runway 4 until at least Friday, and a flight attendant miraculously survived after being ejected from the plane. While the NTSB chair stressed multiple failures contributed to the accident, critics like former DOT officials blamed controller errors for the avoidable collision. Pilot safety reports filed months earlier had warned of similar operational risks at LaGuardia, highlighting systemic issues like controller shortages and aging equipment.
â Verified by 2+ sources
Key details reported by multiple sources:
- An Air Canada Express regional jet (Flight 8646) operated by Jazz Aviation collided with a Port Authority fire truck at LaGuardia Airport on Sunday night, October 2024, around 11:45 pm local time.
- The crash killed both pilotsâAntoine Forest (40) and Mackenzie Gunther (23)âand injured 39 passengers and crew, with six still hospitalized as of Monday.
- The fire truck was responding to a reported odor incident on a United Airlines flight when it crossed the runway where the Air Canada jet was cleared to land.
- Audio recordings show an air traffic controller initially cleared the fire truck to cross the runway, then urgently ordered it to stop with the command 'Stop, truck one, stop!' just before the collision.
- The fire truck lacked a transponder, preventing the airportâs ASDE-X surface surveillance system from detecting its location and triggering an alert.
- The NTSB is investigating whether the controllerâs workloadâincluding managing a late-night emergency and handling double the usual number of arrivals/departuresâcontributed to the crash.
- The runway (Runway 4) was closed until at least Friday, October 2024, for investigation and debris removal.
- A flight attendant, Solange Tremblay, was found alive outside the plane, still strapped into her seat, after being ejected during the collision.
- The NTSB chair Jennifer Homendy stated the crash was likely caused by multiple failures rather than a single error, emphasizing the aviation systemâs layered safety measures.
Points of Difference
Details reported by only one source:
- The Port Authority of New York and New Jersey declined to comment on the lack of a transponder in the fire truck due to the ongoing investigation.
- The NTSB timeline shows the fire truck requested runway crossing 25 seconds before the crash, was cleared five seconds later, and was ordered to stop nine seconds before impact.
- The controller was heard saying 'I messed up' in an exchange with a Frontier Airlines pilot after the crash, admitting to being distracted by an earlier emergency.
- The NTSB is analyzing 25 hours of cockpit voice recordings and 80 hours of flight data from the Air Canada jet.
- A survivor recalled seeing 'blood everywhere' after the crash and described the impact as an 'incredibly loud bang' with passengers helping each other.
- The NTSBâs Doug Brazy mentioned the final three minutes of cockpit recordings showed the co-pilot transferring control to the captain six seconds before the crash.
- The Port Authorityâs Kathryn Garcia stated the two firefighters in the truck were expected to recover from non-life-threatening injuries.
- Pilot safety reports filed months before the crash warned of LaGuardiaâs high operational pace and controller errors, including a pilot describing a near-miss where a departing plane was cleared while another was landing just 300 feet above.
- The Guardian highlighted systemic issues like controller shortages, aging equipment, and government shutdowns exacerbating airport safety risks.
- An NTSB investigator was delayed three hours in security lines in Houston while traveling to LaGuardia for the investigation.
- Former DOT inspector general Mary Schiavo stated the crash was 'entirely avoidable' and criticized the controller for 'going brain dead,' suggesting a lack of coordination between local and ground control.
- Retired FAA controller Harvey Sconick called the controllerâs actions 'unexplainable' and questioned whether the controller was handling both air and ground traffic alone.
- The Guardian published audio clips capturing the controllerâs clearance and last-second stop command to the fire truck.
Contradictions
Conflicting information between sources:
- The Guardian reports pilot safety concerns were filed months before the crash, but ABC and NEWSCOMAU do not mention these reports until the Guardianâs article.
- The Guardian states the NTSB investigator was delayed three hours in Houston security lines, while ABC and NEWSCOMAU do not mention this delay.
- NEWSCOMAU (Article 2) reports 76 people on board the Air Canada flight, while ABC (Article 3) and Jazz Aviation state 72 passengers and four crew members.
- NEWSCOMAU (Article 5) claims the controller âwent brain deadâ and âmade a very critical mistake,â while NTSB chair Jennifer Homendy emphasized multiple failures rather than a single error.
- The Guardian mentions the NTSB investigator was delayed due to government shutdown-related TSA staffing issues, but ABC and NEWSCOMAU do not connect this to the investigation timeline.
Source Articles
Control tower audio captures moments before LaGuardia plane crash â audio
The audio from a control tower at New York's LaGuardia airport captured the moments before a plane collided with a fire truck while landing. An air traffic controller could be heard on a radio transmi...
LaGuardia air traffic controller slammed as âbrain deadâ for avoidable Air Canada crash
The fatal plane crash at New Yorkâs LaGuardia Airport on Sunday night was entirely avoidable and likely caused by a miscommunication, experts say....
LaGuardia pilots raised safety alarms months before deadly runway crash
Nasa reports show repeated warnings of close calls before crash that killed two pilots and injured 41 others Sign up for the Breaking News US email to get newsletter alerts in your inbox Pilot safety ...
Air traffic controller appears to say 'I messed up' moments after fatal crash at LaGuardia
Audio recordings from the LaGuardia air traffic control tower reveal a controller appearing to admit he "messed up" just moments after the crash of an Air Canada Express regional jet that killed a pil...
Controller appears to say 'I messed up' after deadly runway crash
Audio recordings from New York's LaGuardia airport reveal an air traffic controller appearing to admit he "messed up" just moments after an Air Canada Express regional jet crashed into a fire truck, k...
âBlood everywhereâ: New details in deadly plane crash
New details into a deadly collision between a plane and a fire truck have been revealed, with officials urging against âpointing fingers at controllersâ....
Seconds before LaGuardia crash, controller cleared fire truck to cross runway
US investigators are working to determine which of the airport's safety precautions failed and allowed the fire truck onto the runway, resulting in a collision that killed two pilots....