Victorian government expands device ban in schools to include smartwatches and headphones
Consensus Summary
The Victorian government is expanding its device ban in schools to include smartwatches and headphones, effective January 2027, making it the first state to implement such sweeping rules. The ban, which already applies to public schools since 2020, will now cover all 233 independent and Catholic schools in Victoria. Education Minister Ben Carroll has cited improvements in student focus, reduced distractions, and fewer critical incidents as reasons for the policy’s success, with 60% of children aged 7-12 using smartwatches. The new legislation will enforce consistent rules across all schools, with exceptions for health-related device use. While the move is supported by some school leaders and parents, concerns remain about shifting responsibility to schools and the need for student consultation. Schools like Caroline Chisholm Catholic College have already seen positive outcomes, such as increased fairness perceptions and social connections among students, following stricter enforcement of similar policies.
✓ Verified by 2+ sources
Key details reported by multiple sources:
- Victorian public, Catholic, and independent schools will ban internet-enabled smartwatches and wireless headphones from January 2027 as part of an expanded device ban.
- Mobile phones have been banned in Victorian public schools since 2020, with the policy credited with improving student focus, reducing distractions, and lowering critical incidents involving devices.
- Education Minister Ben Carroll stated the phone ban was a 'game changer' and that 60% of children aged 7-12 use smartwatches, according to ABC and THEAGE sources.
- The new policy will apply to all 233 independent schools in Victoria, enforced through the Victorian Registration and Qualifications Authority (VRQA).
- Exceptions will be made for students requiring devices for health conditions, as noted in THEAGE and NEWSCOMAU.
- The government will introduce draft legislation into parliament on Wednesday (date implied in THEAGE and NEWSCOMAU).
Points of Difference
Details reported by only one source:
- Parents Victoria chief executive Gail McHardy expressed mixed parental views on the ban, noting some parents believe it shifts too much responsibility onto schools rather than families.
- ABC quotes Education Minister Ben Carroll saying 'Mobile phones and digital devices have been an incredible distraction' and that the ban will create 'disruption-free classrooms'.
- ABC mentions a 2024 student-led consultation process at Caroline Chisholm Catholic College, which initially introduced a strict phone policy in 2019 but later tightened it in 2024.
- THEAGE reports that private and Catholic schools will be required to follow the policy through compliance with the Victorian Registration and Qualifications Authority (VRQA).
- THEAGE includes a quote from Caroline Chisholm Catholic College deputy principal Tristen O’Brien stating that phones became a distraction and contributed to behavior and social issues post-pandemic.
- THEAGE details specific enforcement measures at Caroline Chisholm Catholic College, including students collecting banned devices from reception, parents collecting them on repeat offenses, and potential meetings with school coordinators for continued violations.
- THEAGE notes a 20% increase in students believing rules were enforced fairly, a 10% increase in students keeping good friends, and a 5% increase in students feeling connected to staff at Caroline Chisholm Catholic College since introducing the ban.
- NEWSCOMAU explicitly states Victoria is the first state to introduce these sweeping new rules, a claim not mentioned in ABC or THEAGE.
- NEWSCOMAU includes Premier Jacinta Allan’s announcement of the changes, which is not referenced in the other sources.
- NEWSCOMAU quotes Education Minister Ben Carroll saying 'Learning, behaviour, socialisation and focus are all improving' in a more direct and concise manner than ABC or THEAGE.
Contradictions
Conflicting information between sources:
- ABC reports that Catholic and independent schools requested to be included under the new policy, while THEAGE states the government intends to bring all students under the same rules without mentioning prior requests.
- ABC mentions that Parents Victoria supports the ban but advocates for student-led consultation, while THEAGE does not reference this specific point about student involvement.
- ABC and THEAGE do not mention the claim in NEWSCOMAU that Victoria is the first state to introduce these rules, which NEWSCOMAU attributes to Premier Jacinta Allan.
Source Articles
Phone ban in classrooms extended to include smartwatches, headphones
Victorian students in public and private schools will be banned from wearing smartwatches with internet connectivity and using headphones in classrooms from next year after the government announced an...
Smartwatches, headphones restricted in classrooms in new device crackdown
Victoria’s nation-leading ban on phones on classrooms will be extended to all private schools, and will now include internet-enabled smartwatches and wireless headphones....
Major change coming to Victorian schools
The sweeping new changes will be applied to all Victorian schools in an effort to reduce distraction rates in the classroom....