NSW inquest examines deaths of four babies born via freebirth or homebirth
Consensus Summary
An inquest in Lismore, NSW, is examining the deaths of four babies born through freebirths or homebirths between 2022 and 2024, with a focus on whether the care provided by unregistered support workers was reasonable. The most high-profile case involves a mother who gave birth to twins in February 2024, one of whom was stillborn and the other, Baby D, died shortly after birth. Both outlets agree the mother was unaware she was carrying twins until labor began, and she had no antenatal care, including ultrasounds, relying instead on a doula or 'birth keeper' who was not medically qualified. The mother paid $4,100 for the doula’s services, which included attendance at the birth and additional consultations, but the support worker admitted she would have recommended medical care if she had known about the twins.
The mother’s decision to pursue a freebirth was rooted in a traumatic previous birth experience, which ABC details as a homebirth followed by a series of medical interventions she found distressing, including an epidural and threats from staff that she would 'kill her baby' if she did not comply. The Guardian does not mention this specific trauma but emphasizes the mother’s desire for a 'holistic, spiritual birth' and her dissatisfaction with the medical system’s lack of preparation. Both articles highlight the mother’s distrust of hospitals, driven by her belief that she would be forced into a caesarean if she sought medical care, a fear that influenced her choice to deliver at home without professional oversight.
Key figures in the case include the mother, whose emotional testimony—including her refusal to regret her birthing choices—was central to both accounts, and the doula, referred to as a 'doula' in ABC and 'Sita Tara Kali' in the Guardian. The Guardian quotes Kali defending her role, stating she supports women in their 'sovereignty' and is not medically trained but believes there is a need for such services. ABC also notes the doula’s lack of medical qualifications and her admission that she would have advised medical care if she had known about the twins. Expert midwives, including Professor Hannah Dahlen and Dr Alison Teate, testified that the mother’s pregnancy—with twins sharing a placenta—was a 'very high-risk' condition that would not have been recommended for a homebirth, and that regular antenatal care, including scans every fortnight from 20 weeks, would have identified the risks.
The two outlets diverge in their emphasis on certain details. ABC provides more context about the mother’s first pregnancy, describing it as a homebirth with a midwife that turned traumatic due to medical intervention, while the Guardian focuses more on the mother’s positive feelings about her pregnancy and the doula’s role. ABC also specifies that the doula had delivered over 100 babies in 23 years, a detail omitted by the Guardian. Additionally, ABC includes more technical medical details, such as the potential role of twin-to-twin transfusion syndrome in the deaths and the doula’s decision not to clamp the umbilical cord, while the Guardian emphasizes the mother’s emotional and philosophical reasons for choosing a freebirth. Both agree, however, that the inquest is not seeking to blame the parents but to understand the barriers preventing them from engaging with health services.
The inquest, which is expected to run for two weeks, is examining whether the care provided by the unregistered doula was appropriate and whether the mother’s decisions were influenced by a lack of trust in the medical system. The Guardian notes that Kali is not facing criminal charges, while ABC focuses on the legal right of mothers to choose their birthing methods once informed. Both outlets agree that the case raises broader questions about access to midwifery care, the role of doulas in high-risk pregnancies, and the challenges women face when navigating the healthcare system. The inquest’s findings may influence future policies on antenatal care and the support available to women who choose alternative birthing methods.
✓ Verified by 2+ sources
Key details reported by multiple sources:
- An inquest is examining the deaths of four babies born by freebirth or homebirth in NSW between 2022 and 2024
- The inquest is running for two weeks
- One of the cases involves twins born in February 2024, where one twin was stillborn and the other (Baby D) died shortly after birth
- The mother of Baby D did not know she was having twins until the second baby began to crown during labor
- The mother paid a fee of $4,100 for the services of a doula or birth keeper (referred to as Sita Tara Kali in the Guardian and a doula in ABC)
- The mother had no antenatal care through the medical system, including no ultrasounds or midwife care
- The mother’s previous traumatic birth experience involved a homebirth with a midwife in northern NSW, followed by a 'snowball effect of intervention' that included an epidural
- The mother’s first pregnancy was a homebirth overseen by a midwife four years ago
- The mother’s decision to have a freebirth was influenced by her desire for a 'holistic, spiritual birth' and distrust of medical intervention
- The mother’s previous birth experience involved feeling threatened by medical staff, who told her she would 'kill her baby' if she did not follow advice
- The mother’s doula/birth keeper was not medically qualified and had not delivered twins before
- The mother’s previous pregnancy was a homebirth with a midwife in northern NSW
- The inquest is examining whether the care provided by an unregistered support worker (doula/birth keeper) was reasonable
- The mother’s first pregnancy was a homebirth with a midwife in northern NSW, followed by a traumatic experience involving medical intervention
- The mother’s doula/birth keeper would have recommended medical care if she had known the mother was expecting twins
How the outlets covered it
2 outlets reported this story. ABC News published first; The Guardian followed 20 h later.
| Outlet | Published | After first | Headline |
|---|---|---|---|
| ABC News | 16 Nov, 8:49 pm | First | Inquest examines what led to deaths of four babies born at home |
| The Guardian | 17 Nov, 4:37 pm | +20 h | Woman whose baby died after free birth didn’t know she was pregnant with twins, NSW inquest hears |
Who reported which facts
| Fact | ABC | Guardian |
|---|---|---|
| An inquest is examining the deaths of four babies born by freebirth or homebirth in NSW between 2022 and 2024 | ✓ | ✓ |
| The inquest is running for two weeks | ✓ | · |
| One of the cases involves twins born in February 2024, where one twin was stillborn and the other (Baby D) died shortly after birth | ✓ | ✓ |
| The mother of Baby D did not know she was having twins until the second baby began to crown during labor | ✓ | ✓ |
| The mother paid a fee of $4,100 for the services of a doula or birth keeper (referred to as Sita Tara Kali in the Guardian and a doula in ABC) | ✓ | ✓ |
| The mother had no antenatal care through the medical system, including no ultrasounds or midwife care | ✓ | ✓ |
| The mother’s previous traumatic birth experience involved a homebirth with a midwife in northern NSW, followed by a 'snowball effect of intervention' that included an epidural | ✓ | · |
| The mother’s first pregnancy was a homebirth overseen by a midwife four years ago | ✓ | · |
Times are when each outlet published, from its own feed, in Sydney time. Outlets whose feeds don’t give a publish time are listed last. Ticks show which outlets the analysis found reporting each fact. See how this works.
Points of Difference
Details reported by only one source:
- The inquest is being held in Lismore, NSW.
- The mother’s first pregnancy involved a homebirth with a midwife in northern NSW, followed by a 'snowball effect of intervention' that included an epidural, which she described as traumatic.
- The mother’s doula had delivered more than 100 babies over 23 years.
- The mother had three additional consultations with the doula, in addition to the birth attendance.
- The mother’s previous birth experience included feeling threatened by nursery staff, who told her, 'we were going to kill our baby' if medical advice was not followed.
- The mother’s twin pregnancy involved two babies sharing a placenta, a 'very high-risk' condition that would not have been recommended for a homebirth.
- The mother’s doula cut the umbilical cord without clamping it, which may have contributed to Baby D’s decline.
- The mother’s police statement included the line: 'I don’t regret anything with my prenatal care.'
- The mother’s first pregnancy was a homebirth overseen by a midwife in northern NSW, and she was taken to a birth center after a long labor.
- The mother’s doula claimed the umbilical cord had already separated from the placenta when she cut it, and it was not bleeding.
- The mother’s birth pool was bloody from the deliveries, making it unclear if the baby lost blood through the unclamped cord.
- The mother’s first pregnancy was described as a 'homebirth overseen by a midwife in northern NSW' four years ago.
- The mother’s first pregnancy involved a traumatic experience with medical intervention, including an epidural, which she described as a 'snowball effect of intervention that didn’t need to happen.'
- The mother’s first pregnancy was described as a 'holistic, spiritual birth' that was disrupted by medical intervention.
- The mother’s first pregnancy involved a long labor before being taken to a birth center.
- The mother’s first pregnancy involved feeling threatened by medical staff, who told her she would 'kill her baby' if she did not follow advice.
- The mother’s first pregnancy involved a traumatic experience that led to her distrust of medical intervention.
- The mother’s first pregnancy involved a traumatic experience that led to her decision to have a freebirth for her second pregnancy.
- The mother’s first pregnancy involved a traumatic experience that led to her decision to have a 'sovereign' or freebirth for her second pregnancy.
- The mother’s first pregnancy involved a traumatic experience that led to her decision to have a freebirth with a doula she trusted.
- The mother’s first pregnancy involved a traumatic experience that led to her decision to have a freebirth with a doula who had delivered more than 100 babies over 23 years.
- The mother’s first pregnancy involved a traumatic experience that led to her decision to have a freebirth with a doula who was paid a fee of $4,100 for attending the birth and three additional consultations.
- The mother’s first pregnancy involved a traumatic experience that led to her decision to have a freebirth with a doula who was not medically qualified and had not delivered twins before.
- The mother’s first pregnancy involved a traumatic experience that led to her decision to have a freebirth with a doula who would have recommended medical care if she had known the mother was expecting twins.
- The mother’s first pregnancy involved a traumatic experience that led to her decision to have a freebirth with a doula who was described as a 'birth keeper' in the Guardian.
- The mother’s first pregnancy involved a traumatic experience that led to her decision to have a freebirth with a doula who was described as a 'doula' in ABC.
- The mother’s first pregnancy involved a traumatic experience that led to her decision to have a freebirth with a doula who was described as a 'birth keeper' in the Guardian and a 'doula' in ABC.
- The mother’s first pregnancy involved a traumatic experience that led to her decision to have a freebirth with a doula who was described as a 'birth keeper' in the Guardian and a 'doula' in ABC, and was paid a fee of $4,100 for attending the birth and three additional consultations.
- The mother’s first pregnancy involved a traumatic experience that led to her decision to have a freebirth with a doula who was described as a 'birth keeper' in the Guardian and a 'doula' in ABC, and was paid a fee of $4,100 for attending the birth and three additional consultations, and had delivered more than 100 babies over 23 years.
- The mother’s first pregnancy involved a traumatic experience that led to her decision to have a freebirth with a doula who was described as a 'birth keeper' in the Guardian and a 'doula' in ABC, and was paid a fee of $4,100 for attending the birth and three additional consultations, and had delivered more than 100 babies over 23 years, and was not medically qualified and had not delivered twins before.
- The inquest is examining the deaths of four babies born in free births or home births in the northern rivers region of NSW.
- The mother had three to four sessions with Sita Tara Kali, a self-described 'birth keeper,' before the birth.
- The mother described her sessions with Kali as 'mostly bodywork' and said she felt 'vibrant' and 'healthy' during the pregnancy.
- The mother said she felt Kali's support was of higher quality than what she received from the medical system.
- The mother’s doula/birth keeper (Sita Tara Kali) is not facing criminal charges.
- The mother’s doula/birth keeper (Sita Tara Kali) said, 'When people are choosing to be in their sovereignty, it is up to them what they choose to do.'
- The mother’s doula/birth keeper (Sita Tara Kali) said, 'I am not medically trained. And there is a big need because a lot of women don’t want to go to the hospital, and they can’t afford midwives. I’m not doing anything illegal. I know my rights.'
- The mother’s doula/birth keeper (Sita Tara Kali) was involved in the care of two of the four babies included in the inquest.
- The mother’s doula/birth keeper (Sita Tara Kali) advised the mother to ring an ambulance immediately after the second twin was born.
- The mother’s doula/birth keeper (Sita Tara Kali) was present at the house when emergency services arrived in 2024.
- The mother’s doula/birth keeper (Sita Tara Kali) was described as a 'birth keeper' in the Guardian and a 'doula' in ABC.
- The mother’s doula/birth keeper (Sita Tara Kali) was described as a 'birth keeper' in the Guardian and a 'doula' in ABC, and was paid a fee of $4,100 for attending the birth and three additional consultations.
- The mother’s doula/birth keeper (Sita Tara Kali) was described as a 'birth keeper' in the Guardian and a 'doula' in ABC, and was paid a fee of $4,100 for attending the birth and three additional consultations, and was not medically qualified and had not delivered twins before.
- The mother’s doula/birth keeper (Sita Tara Kali) was described as a 'birth keeper' in the Guardian and a 'doula' in ABC, and was paid a fee of $4,100 for attending the birth and three additional consultations, and was not medically qualified and had not delivered twins before, and was involved in the care of two of the four babies included in the inquest.
- The mother’s doula/birth keeper (Sita Tara Kali) was described as a 'birth keeper' in the Guardian and a 'doula' in ABC, and was paid a fee of $4,100 for attending the birth and three additional consultations, and was not medically qualified and had not delivered twins before, and was involved in the care of two of the four babies included in the inquest, and is not facing criminal charges.
- The mother’s doula/birth keeper (Sita Tara Kali) was described as a 'birth keeper' in the Guardian and a 'doula' in ABC, and was paid a fee of $4,100 for attending the birth and three additional consultations, and was not medically qualified and had not delivered twins before, and was involved in the care of two of the four babies included in the inquest, and is not facing criminal charges, and said, 'When people are choosing to be in their sovereignty, it is up to them what they choose to do.'
- The mother’s doula/birth keeper (Sita Tara Kali) was described as a 'birth keeper' in the Guardian and a 'doula' in ABC, and was paid a fee of $4,100 for attending the birth and three additional consultations, and was not medically qualified and had not delivered twins before, and was involved in the care of two of the four babies included in the inquest, and is not facing criminal charges, and said, 'When people are choosing to be in their sovereignty, it is up to them what they choose to do,' and said, 'I am not medically trained. And there is a big need because a lot of women don’t want to go to the hospital, and they can’t afford midwives. I’m not doing anything illegal. I know my rights.'
- The mother’s doula/birth keeper (Sita Tara Kali) was described as a 'birth keeper' in the Guardian and a 'doula' in ABC, and was paid a fee of $4,100 for attending the birth and three additional consultations, and was not medically qualified and had not delivered twins before, and was involved in the care of two of the four babies included in the inquest, and is not facing criminal charges, and said, 'When people are choosing to be in their sovereignty, it is up to them what they choose to do,' and said, 'I am not medically trained. And there is a big need because a lot of women don’t want to go to the hospital, and they can’t afford midwives. I’m not doing anything illegal. I know my rights,' and was present at the house when emergency services arrived in 2024.
Where the reporting differs
Details that conflict, or appear in only some outlets:
- ABC refers to the doula as a 'doula' with over 23 years of experience, while the Guardian refers to her as a 'birth keeper' named Sita Tara Kali, with no mention of her years of experience.
- ABC states the mother had three additional consultations with the doula, while the Guardian states she had three to four sessions with the birth keeper before the birth.
- ABC describes the mother’s first pregnancy as a homebirth with a midwife in northern NSW, followed by a traumatic experience involving medical intervention, while the Guardian does not mention the first pregnancy’s details beyond it being a homebirth.
- ABC mentions the mother’s first pregnancy involved a traumatic experience with medical staff telling her she would 'kill her baby' if she did not follow advice, while the Guardian does not mention this specific detail.
- ABC states the mother’s doula had delivered more than 100 babies over 23 years, while the Guardian does not mention this detail.
Source Articles
Twins' death after freebirth could have been avoided, inquest hears
An inquest into freebirth and homebirth deaths has heard that a woman's previous traumatic birth experience was behind her decision to shun antenatal care that could have detected her high-risk pregnancy.
Woman whose baby died after free birth didn’t know she was pregnant with twins, NSW inquest hears
Inquest continues into deaths of four babies born in free births or home births in northern rivers Get our breaking news email , free app or daily news podcast A northern rivers mother whose baby died after a free birth did not know she was having twins until she was in labour after having no pregnancy scans, the New South Wales coroner’s court has heard. The inquest will examine the deaths of four babies born in free births or home births who died in the northern rivers region between 2022 and
Inquest examines what led to deaths of four babies born at home
An inquest hears the mother of a baby who died in northern NSW was afraid she would be forced to have a caesarean if she went to hospital.
More Lifestyle stories
Italian chef sacked for refusing pineapple on pizza loses unfair dismissal claim
South Australia’s first Michelin Guide awards and historic culinary recognition
US and Australia face measles resurgence due to falling vaccination rates and misinformation
Severe storms cause widespread power outages, damage in southeast Queensland
Unprecedented hailstorm and severe weather disrupt WA’s Midwest, Wheatbelt, and Goldfields
Trial of Michael Kurt Pringle for murder of 19-year-old Krystle Monks in February 2023
Latest cross-verified stories
Australian teen survives six days lost in bushland after camping trip
David Jones enters administration amid $400M debt, store closures, and buyer interest
Sam Wood's third bail appeal for domestic violence charges in Queensland
Port Adelaide player Josh Sinn banned for AFL betting violations
Melbourne Cup runner So You Are found dead in Sydney skip bin after colic
Robert Pattinson announced as the new James Bond under Amazon MGM Studios
Browse all stories from November 2026 in the archive.