Liberal MP Andrew Hastie’s open stance on 25% gas profit tax amid global energy crisis
Consensus Summary
Liberal MP Andrew Hastie has signaled openness to a 25% tax on gas profits, aligning with proposals from the Greens and Senator David Pocock, as Treasury models the potential impact. The move follows rising global energy prices linked to Iran’s blockade of the Strait of Hormuz, with Santos reportedly earning $120 million from a single gas shipment. Hastie acknowledged public anger over corporate profits and cited Norway’s $3.2 trillion sovereign wealth fund as a model, arguing governments should balance budgets like households. While both sources agree on Hastie’s stance and the Greens’ estimates of $17 billion in annual revenue, the Guardian adds political pushback from shadow treasurer Tim Wilson and warnings from the International Energy Agency about investor sentiment. NEWSCOMAU emphasizes community support from groups like ACOSS, while the Guardian details Hastie’s broader critique of US military strategy in Iran and potential internal Liberal Party divisions over the proposal.
✓ Verified by 2+ sources
Key details reported by multiple sources:
- Andrew Hastie, Liberal MP and shadow minister for sovereign capability, is open to a 25% tax on gas profits, reportedly modelled by Treasury on request of the Department of the Prime Minister and Cabinet
- The Greens and former Climate 200-backed Senator David Pocock have championed a 25% export tax on gas profits, with the Greens estimating it could raise $17 billion per year
- Hastie referenced Norway’s sovereign wealth fund, which has assets worth over $3.2 trillion ($US2.2tn), as a model for Australia
- Hastie stated ‘multinationals don’t have a social licence’ and ‘have had a really good run of our wealth here’ during an interview with The Guardian
- The Iranian regime’s blockade of the Strait of Hormuz has contributed to the global energy crisis, per warnings from the US and Israeli-led bombings of Iran
- Santos reportedly negotiated $120 million from a single shipment of gas, as cited by Greens senator Steph Hodgins-May
Points of Difference
Details reported by only one source:
- ACOSS chief executive Cassandra Goldie welcomed Hastie’s comments, stating ‘people on low and modest incomes are already doing it tough’ while gas corporations profit
- Hastie’s comments were reported in The Guardian, but NEWSCOMAU does not mention the specific Australian Politics podcast interview
- The article highlights the Australian Council of Social Service’s (ACOSS) endorsement of the tax proposal
- The Guardian explicitly states Hastie’s remarks were made on the Australian Politics podcast, while NEWSCOMAU does not mention this medium
- Shadow treasurer Tim Wilson’s opposition to new taxes is reported only in the Guardian, not in NEWSCOMAU
- The Guardian includes Hastie’s criticism of Donald Trump’s overconfidence in US military actions against Iran, including the Strait of Hormuz blockade
- The Guardian cites the International Energy Agency’s Fatih Birol warning that sudden corporate tax changes would spook investors, a detail absent in NEWSCOMAU
- The Guardian notes that gas giants like Santos will fight any new tax, with the Australian Energy Producers warning it would harm Australia’s economy and energy security
Contradictions
Conflicting information between sources:
- NEWSCOMAU does not mention the Australian Energy Producers’ warning that a new export levy would come at the ‘worst possible time’ for Australia’s economy, which the Guardian includes
- The Guardian reports that shadow treasurer Tim Wilson said new taxes would ‘freeze investment and private jobs growth,’ but NEWSCOMAU does not reference this statement
- The Guardian attributes Hastie’s comments about Trump’s overconfidence in military actions to a specific podcast interview, while NEWSCOMAU does not specify the medium for these remarks
- NEWSCOMAU does not mention the International Energy Agency’s warning about investor reactions to sudden tax changes, which the Guardian includes
- The Guardian highlights Hastie’s potential conflict with senior Liberals like Angus Taylor over the tax proposal, but NEWSCOMAU does not explicitly state this tension
Source Articles
Andrew Hastie open to 25% tax on gas profits and says multinationals have ‘had a really good run’ on Australian wealth
Exclusive : Speaking with the Australian Politics podcast, the Liberal frontbencher says a sovereign wealth fund would set Australians up for generations to come Follow our Australia news live blog fo...
Liberal MP’s big call on Greens’ gas tax
Liberal frontbencher Andrew Hastie says he’s open to a 25 per cent tax on gas profits as multinationals reap huge gains from Iran war price spikes....