US-Vatican-Italy tensions over Trump’s attacks on Pope Leo and Iran war
Consensus Summary
US Secretary of State Marco Rubio visited Rome and the Vatican from May 2–3, 2026, to repair strained relations after President Donald Trump’s repeated attacks on Pope Leo over his opposition to the US-Israeli war on Iran. Trump accused Leo of ‘endangering Catholics’ and supporting Iran’s nuclear ambitions, calling him ‘weak’ and sharing a deleted AI-generated Christ-like image of himself. Rubio met Leo at the Vatican, exchanging gifts, and held talks with Italian Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni and Foreign Minister Antonio Tajani amid threats to withdraw US troops from Italy. The visit followed Trump’s broader diplomatic fallout, including troop reductions in Germany and tensions with European allies over the Iran conflict. Analysts suggest Rubio’s mission is more about damage control for US politics than substantive resolution, with Italy’s public opinion increasingly critical of Trump’s stance.
✓ Verified by 2+ sources
Key details reported by multiple sources:
- Marco Rubio, US Secretary of State, visited Rome on May 2–3, 2026, to meet Pope Leo (first US-born pontiff) and Italian officials to mend relations
- Rubio met Pope Leo at the Vatican’s Apostolic Palace on May 2, 2026, at 11:30am (10:30 GMT)
- Donald Trump accused Pope Leo of ‘endangering Catholics’ and supporting Iran’s nuclear ambitions on May 5, 2026, during an interview with Hugh Hewitt
- Trump previously called Pope Leo ‘weak on crime’ and ‘terrible on foreign policy’ in April 2026, after Leo condemned the US-Israeli war on Iran
- Trump threatened to withdraw 5,000 US troops from Germany (and earlier hinted at Italy/Spanish bases) in response to European criticism of the Iran war
- Rubio also met Vatican Secretary of State Cardinal Pietro Parolin and Italian Foreign Minister Antonio Tajani during his visit
- Italy’s Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni initially refused Rubio’s request for a meeting but later indicated she would meet him on May 3, 2026
- Pope Leo’s first anniversary as pontiff is May 2026, marked by a mass in Pompeii on May 3
- Trump shared (then deleted) an AI-generated image depicting himself as Christ-like, which sparked backlash
- Rubio presented Pope Leo with a crystal football paperweight (referencing Leo’s Chicago White Sox allegiance) and received an olive wood pen and Vatican art book
Points of Difference
Details reported by only one source:
- US ambassador to Rome, Tilman Fertitta, wrote a letter to the Italian government to ‘rebuild the bridge’ between the US and Italy after Trump’s remarks
- Corriere della Sera reported Rubio’s visit aims to ‘thaw’ relations with both Rome and the Vatican, described as ‘not impossible, but complicated’
- Pentagon withdrew 5,000 troops from Germany on May 3, 2026, citing ‘inappropriate’ German rhetoric; Trump suggested the number may increase
- Italy’s Defense Minister Guido Crosetto denied accusations Rome had not helped the US, especially regarding maritime security
- US Vice-President JD Vance criticized Pope Leo for ‘talking about theology and war’ and urged the Vatican to ‘stick to matters of morality’
- Analyst Lorenzo Castellani (Luiss Guido Carli University) noted 80–90% of Italian public opinion now opposes Trump’s stance on the Iran war
- Trump accused Meloni of ‘lacking courage’ for refusing US use of an Italian airbase for Iran war weapons in late March 2026
- Rubio and Vance attended Pope Leo’s inauguration in May 2025 and gave him an invitation to the White House from Trump, which Leo has not accepted
- Trump suggested naval assets deployed in the Middle East could return to the US via Cuba after the Iran war
- Italy hosts ~13,000 US military personnel across seven naval bases, a key topic in Rubio’s talks with Meloni
- US State Department described Rubio’s meetings as underscoring the ‘strong relationship’ between the US and the Holy See, focusing on Middle East peace and Western Hemisphere topics
- Giampiero Gramaglia (former ANSA Washington correspondent) doubted Rubio’s visit would significantly improve Vatican or Italian relations, suggesting it was for Rubio’s political ambitions
- Rubio mentioned Cuba was on the agenda, citing concerns over Trump’s threats of military action there post-Maduro’s ouster in Venezuela
- Trump’s April 2026 attacks on Leo included claims the pope was ‘soft on crime and terrorism’ regarding immigration policies and deportations
- Leo responded to Trump’s nuclear weapon accusations by stating the Church has ‘spoken out against all nuclear weapons for years’
Contradictions
Conflicting information between sources:
- The Guardian reports Trump threatened to withdraw US troops from Italy and Spain on May 3, 2026, while ABC does not mention Spain in this context
- Guardian states Rubio’s meeting with Meloni was ‘not yet granted’ initially but later confirmed; ABC implies it was arranged after back-and-forth
- Guardian notes Trump’s troop withdrawal threat came after Merz’s ‘humiliation’ remark about Iran, while ABC does not specify Germany’s role in the timeline
- Guardian includes a Pentagon official calling German rhetoric ‘inappropriate and unhelpful,’ but ABC omits this detail entirely
- ABC describes Rubio’s visit as ‘complicated at the last minute’ by Trump’s latest criticism, while Guardian frames it as a pre-planned trip with added urgency
Source Articles
Marco Rubio to visit Rome, reportedly to ‘thaw’ US relations with Pope and Meloni
US secretary of state will be in Italian capital on Thursday and Friday, the one-year anniversary of Pope Leo’s papacy The US secretary of state, Marco Rubio, is to travel to Rome this week for a visit reportedly aimed at thawing frosty relations with the Italian government and the Vatican. Rubio is scheduled to be in the Italian capital on Thursday and Friday, which will also mark the one-year anniversary of the papacy of Pope Leo, the first US-born pontiff. Continue reading...
Marco Rubio to meet pope at the Vatican after Trump attacks on pontiff
US secretary of state will hold talks with Italian government, also berated by Trump for not supporting Iran war The US secretary of state, Marco Rubio, is to meet Pope Leo at the Vatican on Thursday in an effort to ease tensions after Donald Trump’s repeated criticisms of the first North American pontiff. Amid unprecedented strain on relations between the Holy See and Washington, Rubio is expected to meet Leo at the Apostolic Palace in the morning, before holding a series of meetings with the I
Trump accuses pope of ‘endangering a lot of Catholics’ with Iran stance
US president directs fresh criticism at pontiff days before secretary of state Marco Rubio’s visit to Vatican Middle East crisis – live updates Donald Trump has issued a fresh verbal attack against Pope Leo XIV, accusing the pontiff of “endangering a lot of Catholics” because “he thinks it’s fine for Iran to have a nuclear weapon”. The remarks come two days before Marco Rubio, the US secretary of state, meets Leo at the Vatican in an effort to ease the tensions sparked by Trump’s previous broads
Marco Rubio to meet pope this week after Trump’s broadside against Leo
US secretary of state’s two-day visit reportedly intended to thaw Washington’s frosty relations with Vatican and Italy The US secretary of state, Marco Rubio, will meet Pope Leo on Thursday, weeks after Donald Trump’s unprecedented broadside against the pontiff. Rubio will meet the first US-born pope privately in the Vatican’s apostolic palace at 11.30am (10.30 GMT), the Holy See’s press office confirmed on Monday after media reports on Sunday. Continue reading...
Rubio visits the Vatican after Trump's attacks on Pope Leo XIV
The secretary of state was seeking to mend fences after US President Donald Trump's social media broadsides against the pope for his opposition to the Iran war.