US states sue Meta over teen social media addiction and data misuse
Consensus Summary
A coalition of 29 US states is suing Meta in a landmark trial alleging its platforms, particularly Instagram, were deliberately designed to addict teenagers and harm their mental health. The lawsuit, filed in October 2023, accuses Meta of collecting data on children under 13 without parental permission and hiding research showing its products were harmful. The trial, taking place in Oakland, California, could result in damages of up to $200bn, equivalent to Meta’s 2025 revenue, and force changes to its addictive features like infinite scrolling. Meta denies wrongdoing, arguing it has taken steps to protect teens and that the claims are unsubstantiated. The case draws parallels to the 1990s tobacco lawsuits, which led to a $200bn settlement and marketing reforms. While Meta estimates potential penalties could reach $1.4tn, the judge dismissed this as unreasonable. The trial follows earlier victories for plaintiffs, including a $6m award in a Los Angeles case and a $567m penalty in New Mexico, bringing Meta’s total penalties to $942m. The outcome could reshape social media design globally, with regulators and attorneys general pushing for stricter controls on addictive algorithms.
✓ Verified by 2+ sources
Key details reported by multiple sources:
- 29 US states are suing Meta in a trial alleging Instagram was designed to be addictive for teenagers and harmed their mental health
- The lawsuit was first filed in October 2023 and involves allegations of Meta collecting data on children under 13 without parental permission
- The trial is taking place in federal court in Oakland, California, and is expected to last between six and eight weeks
- Meta has been ordered to pay $567m to New Mexico in a similar case, bringing its total penalty to $942m
- The attorneys general are seeking damages of up to $200bn, equivalent to Meta’s 2025 annual revenue
- Meta CEO Mark Zuckerberg and Instagram CEO Adam Mosseri are expected to testify in the trial
- The trial follows a Los Angeles jury case in February where Meta and YouTube were ordered to pay $6m to a young woman for addiction claims
- The lawsuit references the 1990s tobacco settlement, where companies paid $200bn and changed marketing practices
- Meta claims penalties could reach $1.4tn, but the judge called this estimate 'unreasonable'
- The trial began in 2023, following a multi-state investigation into Instagram and Facebook’s impact on young users
- The states are seeking changes to Meta’s algorithm, including removing infinite scroll and age restrictions
Points of Difference
Details reported by only one source:
- The lawsuit alleges Meta ‘refuses to abandon its use of known harmful features’ like infinite scrolling and notification alerts
- The trial is part of a broader legal strategy inspired by the tobacco lawsuits of the 1990s, which resulted in a $200bn settlement in 1998
- A Tennessee state trial is also underway alongside the federal case
- Meta disabled over 1 million accounts of children under 13, according to its defense
- The attorneys general compare Meta’s actions to the opioid crisis and tobacco industry lawsuits
- The lawsuit references internal Meta documents stating 'Teens are hooked despite how it makes them feel' and 'the young ones are the best ones'
- Meta claims it has made 'a huge effort to keep kids safe online' and denies misleading statements about safety
- The trial is the biggest legal test of social media’s effects on young users globally
- Meta’s penalties could be as high as $1.4 trillion ($1.9 trillion), close to its market value
- The lawsuit began after whistleblower Frances Haugen testified in 2021 that Meta knew its products harmed young users
- The states are seeking $200 billion ($282 billion) in damages, equivalent to three years of Meta’s after-tax profit
- The trial follows a March case where a Los Angeles jury ordered Meta and Google to pay $6 million to a 20-year-old woman for addiction claims
Contradictions
Conflicting information between sources:
- The Guardian states the lawsuit was filed in October 2023, while ABC mentions the investigation began in 2023 but does not specify the filing date
- The Guardian says the trial is expected to last six to eight weeks, while ABC states it is scheduled to last six weeks
- The Guardian references a $200bn damage claim equivalent to Meta’s 2025 revenue, while ABC states the claim is equivalent to three years of after-tax profit without specifying the year
- The Guardian mentions a $942m total penalty from New Mexico cases, while ABC only references the $567m payment 'earlier this month' without mentioning the cumulative total
Source Articles
US states accuse Meta of covering up research on teen social media addiction in pivotal trial
State attorneys general claim tech company intentionally designed addictive products that harm young people Lawyers representing 29 US states have accused Meta of covering up internal research that showed that Instagram was addictive for teenagers. In a packed courtroom on the opening day of a landmark legal challenge, they said that the company knew its products harmed children but hid that information from the public. Continue reading...
Social media on trial as $200bn case against Facebook and Instagram begins
Twenty-nine US states are seeking huge damages, claiming Meta’s platforms were addictive by design In 1994, more than 40 US states came together to sue one of the most powerful industries on Earth: big tobacco. The suits brought together diverse claims centred on tobacco companies’ misleading advertising and contribution to a mounting public health crisis. They ended in a negotiated settlement with the US government, in which the companies agreed to pay more than any industry ever, and the state
Pivotal Meta trial over social media addiction in children gets underway
US states suing the parent company of Facebook and Instagram begin making their case in a California court in a trial that could reshape some of the most popular apps on the planet.
These states have a united case against Meta. It could be social media's 'tobacco' moment
The trial's outcome could help reshape Facebook and Instagram, and leave Meta with billions of dollars to pay in penalties.