Andrew Hastie vs One Nation over 'traitor' claims and Ben Roberts-Smith war crimes case
Consensus Summary
Liberal MP Andrew Hastie is engaged in a public dispute with One Nation over a cartoon and video that describe him as a traitor for testifying in the 2022 defamation case against Ben Roberts-Smith. Hastie, a former SAS officer, denies the accusations and has vowed to fight to retain his West Australian seat of Canning at the next federal election in 2028. Roberts-Smith, a Victoria Cross recipient, was charged with five counts of the war crime of murder over alleged killings between 2009 and 2012, which he denies. Pauline Hanson and Barnaby Joyce have denied calling Hastie a traitor, though a satirical cartoon posted by Hanson on social media has been cited as the source of the claim. Hastie has distributed his military records, including a performance review from October 23, 2012, to rebut attacks on his service and integrity. One Nation won a by-election in the Western Australian seat of Secret Harbour this month, which overlaps Hastie’s federal electorate, signaling a potential challenge in the upcoming election. Hastie has also faced threats and abuse, prompting increased security for his family and office earlier this year.
✓ Verified by 2+ sources
Key details reported by multiple sources:
- Andrew Hastie was subpoenaed to give evidence in the 2022 trial involving Ben Roberts-Smith's defamation case
- Ben Roberts-Smith was charged with five counts of the war crime of murder over alleged killings between 2009 and 2012
- Pauline Hanson and Barnaby Joyce denied calling Andrew Hastie a 'traitor'
- One Nation won a by-election in the Western Australian seat of Secret Harbour this month
- Andrew Hastie is fighting to retain his West Australian seat of Canning at the next federal election in 2028
- Andrew Hastie served in Afghanistan and was part of an SAS operation on October 23, 2012, in Syahchow, Afghanistan
- Andrew Hastie was ranked fourth out of five captains in his SAS company in a performance review dated October 23, 2012
- Andrew Hastie was given command of an SAS platoon in 2012
- Andrew Hastie failed the SAS’s close quarters battle course in 2011
- Andrew Hastie was open about his close relationship with journalists who first reported on war crimes allegations against Ben Roberts-Smith
Points of Difference
Details reported by only one source:
- Andrew Hastie called Pauline Hanson and Barnaby Joyce 'lying cowards' in an escalating dispute over a One Nation video describing him as a 'traitor'
- Andrew Hastie said One Nation must either delete the video or 'own' the accusation made against him
- Andrew Hastie said he was going to fight 'exceptionally hard' to hold onto Canning against both One Nation and Labor at the next election in 2028
- Andrew Hastie said One Nation had 'picked a fight with the wrong veteran'
- Andrew Hastie said he is not worried about losing his seat but is worried about being called a traitor after serving his country
- Andrew Hastie said One Nation had 'unlocked an achievement' by provoking him to fight back
- Andrew Hastie distributed copies of his confidential military records to supporters on Tuesday to rebut One Nation's attacks
- Andrew Hastie's performance review from October 23, 2012, praised his communication skills, judgment, and ethical standards
- Andrew Hastie was part of an operation in Syahchow, Afghanistan, three days before his October 23, 2012, performance review
- Andrew Hastie said he may be a witness in Ben Roberts-Smith’s murder trial
- Andrew Hastie testified in the defamation case that he did not see anyone executed during the Syahchow operation
- Andrew Hastie said he was targeted by Indonesian 'bot farms' and received extra security protection for his family and electorate office
- Andrew Hastie said he considered running for leader of the Liberal Party at the start of this year
- Andrew Hastie's performance reviews were previously shared with News24 commentator Andrew Bolt
- Andrew Hastie threatened Pauline Hanson and One Nation strategist James Ashby with a 'costly' fight over claims he is a 'traitor' to Australia
- Andrew Hastie said he would make it a 'costly exercise in time, money, and political capital' if Hanson and Ashby come after him
- Andrew Hastie said One Nation won this month’s state by-election in the Western Australian seat of Secret Harbour, which overlaps his federal electorate of Canning
- Andrew Hastie said he opted not to contest a leadership race earlier this year
- Andrew Hastie said he could benefit from a looming opposition frontbench reshuffle, prompted by the upcoming retirement of shadow home affairs minister Jonno Duniam in the next month or two
- Andrew Hastie said he is considered the leading alternative to opposition leader Angus Taylor
- Angus Taylor told Liberal MPs in Canberra on Tuesday that One Nation is 'unfit to govern the country'
- Pauline Hanson said she was 'happy' with Warren Pickering as Victorian leader despite allegations of drug use
Where the reporting differs
Details that conflict, or appear in only some outlets:
- The Guardian says Andrew Hastie is considered the leading alternative to opposition leader Angus Taylor, but ABC and THEWEST do not mention this
- ABC and THEWEST mention Andrew Hastie's email to supporters on Tuesday, but GUARDIAN does not specify the day of the email
- THEWEST says Andrew Hastie's partner Sarah Matulin wrote 'you’re a traitor' on an Anzac Day post by Mr Hastie in late April, but this is not mentioned in ABC or GUARDIAN
- ABC and GUARDIAN mention Andrew Hastie's threat of costly legal action, but THEWEST does not mention this explicitly
- ABC and GUARDIAN mention Andrew Hastie's concern about being called a traitor after serving his country, but THEWEST focuses more on his military records
Source Articles
Andrew Hastie demands One Nation delete or own 'traitor' attack
Opposition frontbencher Andrew Hastie calls Pauline Hanson and Barnaby Joyce "lying cowards" as a dispute over a One Nation video describing him as a "traitor" intensifies.
Liberal MP Andrew Hastie doubles down on One Nation fight; Pauline Hanson calls him a ‘wanker’
The senior Liberal MP accused One Nation of calling him a ‘traitor’, a charged denied by party leader Pauline Hanson, who has now called him ‘a wanker’.
Andrew Hastie accuses Pauline Hanson and Barnaby Joyce of being ‘lying cowards’ over One Nation ‘traitor’ cartoon
The Canning MP says the cartoon, first posted by Hanson on social media over a month ago, calls him a traitor eight times Follow our Australia news live blog for latest updates Get our breaking news email , free app or daily news podcast Liberal frontbencher and SAS veteran Andrew Hastie has called Pauline Hanson and Barnaby Joyce “lying cowards”, after he claimed a One Nation cartoon portrayed him as a traitor for providing evidence in court against Ben Roberts-Smith. Hastie further escalated h
Andrew Hastie threatens One Nation with ‘costly’ fight over claims he is a ‘traitor’ to Australia
Liberal MP says One Nation is trying to unseat him because he gave evidence against Victoria Cross recipient Ben Roberts-Smith Follow our Australia news live blog for latest updates Get our breaking news email , free app or daily news podcast Andrew Hastie has threatened Pauline Hanson and One Nation strategist James Ashby with a “costly” fight over claims he is a traitor to Australia, labelling his critics “cowards” who don’t believe in the rule of law. In some of the Liberal MP’s strongest com
More Technology stories
Renoir Museum art heist on French Riviera steals four paintings, two abandoned
Obituary of Blanche d'Alpuget, writer and wife of Bob Hawke
Aryna Sabalenka reaches US Open 2026 semifinals after defeating Linda Noskova in quarterfinals
Qantas QF122 flight diverted due to engine fire from Queenstown to Sydney
One Nation's early superannuation access policy and political reactions
Lindsay Clancy murder trial ends in mistrial after jury deadlock over postpartum psychosis defense
Latest cross-verified stories
Trial of three men accused of killing Australian brothers and American friend in Mexico
Oasis reunion tour and documentary *Don’t Look Back in Anger* analysis
Mount Anak Krakatau volcanic eruption disrupts flights and travel in Indonesia
High Court hears challenge to White Australia neo-Nazi party ban
US-Iran conflict escalates with strikes on oil tankers in Strait of Hormuz
Alastair Clarkson's sacking as North Melbourne coach and its aftermath
Browse all stories from September 2026 in the archive.