NSW government pauses new real estate underquoting laws amid housing downturn
Consensus Summary
The NSW government has paused new laws designed to crack down on real estate underquoting, just hours before they were set to take effect on Tuesday. Premier Chris Minns announced the delay on Monday morning after receiving concerns from agents in his Sydney electorate, arguing the rules would backfire in a declining housing market. The laws, passed in June, would have banned agents from advertising properties below a previously rejected written offer, with penalties including fines of up to $110,000. Both the Guardian and ABC confirm the changes will be on hold for up to a year while the government reassesses their impact.
The decision follows a sharp downturn in Sydney’s property market, with home values dropping by 10.1% from their 2026 peak, according to the Guardian, and the ABC reporting a 9.7% decline since January. Minns acknowledged the legislation assumed property prices would always rise, a premise no longer valid in the current economic climate. The rules were modeled on Victoria’s transparency measures, which require sellers to disclose reserve prices at least one week before a sale. However, critics argue the NSW laws would have prevented agents from adjusting prices downward even as market conditions worsened, potentially misleading buyers and sellers alike.
Key figures in the dispute include Premier Minns, who defended the pause as a pragmatic response to agent feedback, and Fair Trading Minister Anoulack Chanthivong, who faces a preselection battle in his seat of Macquarie Fields. Chanthivong, who had previously praised the laws as ‘important reforms’ as recently as 1 November, now argues they were designed for a different economic context. The Guardian notes Minns has overruled Chanthivong on past policies, including rental and prison reforms, adding political tension to the reversal. Meanwhile, the Real Estate Institute of NSW warned the government had ignored industry concerns, with CEO Tim McKibbin telling the ABC the rules would have ‘mislead and disadvantaged’ both buyers and sellers.
While both outlets agree on the core event—the shelving of the underquoting laws—they differ in specific details. The Guardian emphasizes the Coalition’s polling at 23% in October and One Nation’s potential to win 20 seats, framing the government’s reversal as part of broader election-year pressure. The ABC, however, focuses more on the technical flaws of the legislation, such as the example of a seller rejecting a $1.3 million offer while the market later made the property more affordable. The Guardian also highlights the government’s recent drop of plastics legislation last month, while the ABC notes the delay will be implemented via regulation due to limited parliamentary time before the year’s end.
With the March state election looming, the government’s U-turn raises questions about its ability to balance reform with political pragmatism. The Guardian reports internal Labor polling shows One Nation leading the Coalition, while the ABC suggests the reversal could weaken Chanthivong’s position ahead of his preselection. Both sources agree the laws will remain paused for up to a year, but the long-term fate of the reforms—and whether they will be reintroduced in amended form—remains uncertain. Minns has not ruled out further intervention, though the political and market pressures shaping the decision are unlikely to disappear soon.
✓ Verified by 2+ sources
Key details reported by multiple sources:
- The NSW government shelved new laws targeting real estate underquoting, which were due to come into effect on Tuesday.
- The laws would have banned agents from advertising a property below a previously rejected written offer, with fines of up to $110,000 or three times an agent’s commission.
- The changes were paused for up to a year after Premier Chris Minns intervened on Monday morning, citing concerns from agents in his electorate.
- Sydney home values have dropped by 10.1% from their 2026 peak, according to Cotality data (Guardian) and close to 9.7% since January (ABC).
- The laws were passed in June and modeled on Victoria’s existing rules, which require sellers to reveal reserve prices at least one week before a sale.
- Fair Trading Minister Anoulack Chanthivong, who faces a preselection battle in Macquarie Fields, previously praised the laws as ‘important reforms’ on 1 November.
- The government is under pressure ahead of the March state election, with One Nation polling at 26% in October (Guardian) and potentially winning 20 seats.
How the outlets covered it
2 outlets reported this story. ABC News published first; The Guardian followed 2.3 h later.
| Outlet | Published | After first | Headline |
|---|---|---|---|
| ABC News | 16 Nov, 5:33 pm | First | NSW real estate laws shelved day before coming into effect |
| The Guardian | 16 Nov, 7:53 pm | +2.3 h | NSW halts new law to crack down on underquoting by real estate agents at 11th hour |
Who reported which facts
| Fact | ABC | Guardian |
|---|---|---|
| The NSW government shelved new laws targeting real estate underquoting, which were due to come into effect on Tuesday. | ✓ | ✓ |
| The laws would have banned agents from advertising a property below a previously rejected written offer, with fines of up to $110,000 or three times an agent’s commission. | ✓ | ✓ |
| The changes were paused for up to a year after Premier Chris Minns intervened on Monday morning, citing concerns from agents in his electorate. | ✓ | ✓ |
| Sydney home values have dropped by 10.1% from their 2026 peak, according to Cotality data (Guardian) and close to 9.7% since January (ABC). | ✓ | ✓ |
| The laws were passed in June and modeled on Victoria’s existing rules, which require sellers to reveal reserve prices at least one week before a sale. | ✓ | ✓ |
| Fair Trading Minister Anoulack Chanthivong, who faces a preselection battle in Macquarie Fields, previously praised the laws as ‘important reforms’ on 1 November. | ✓ | ✓ |
| The government is under pressure ahead of the March state election, with One Nation polling at 26% in October (Guardian) and potentially winning 20 seats. | ✓ | ✓ |
Times are when each outlet published, from its own feed, in Sydney time. Outlets whose feeds don’t give a publish time are listed last. Ticks show which outlets the analysis found reporting each fact. See how this works.
Points of Difference
Details reported by only one source:
- The Guardian reports Sydney units have fallen by 5.2% (ABC does not specify units).
- The Guardian notes the government dropped parts of plastics legislation last month, requiring cafes to offer reusable mugs.
- The Guardian mentions One Nation announced four more upper house candidates on Sunday, with only one lower house candidate named so far.
- The Guardian states the Coalition was polling at 23% in October, behind Labor’s 30%.
- The Guardian includes a quote from Minns: ‘It has come across my desk from real estate agents in my electorate.’
- The Guardian specifies fines would be ‘three times an agent’s commission, whichever was greater.’
- The Guardian notes the decision is a ‘potential embarrassment’ for Chanthivong, who was overruled by Minns on rental and prison reforms.
- The ABC reports Sydney house prices have fallen by close to 9.7% since January, with units down 5.2%.
- The ABC provides an example: if a seller rejected a $1.3 million offer, agents could not advertise below that, even if the market later made the property more affordable.
- The ABC quotes Real Estate Institute of NSW CEO Tim McKibbin: ‘It misleads and disadvantages those purchasers and it certainly disadvantages the vendor.’
- The ABC notes the government will issue a regulation to pause the laws, as there are only a few days of parliament left for the year.
- The ABC mentions the requirement for agents to advertise selling prices or price ranges is also being delayed.
Where the reporting differs
Details that conflict, or appear in only some outlets:
- The Guardian states Sydney home values dropped by 10.1% from their 2026 peak, while the ABC says prices fell by close to 9.7% since January (no peak reference).
- The Guardian specifies fines of up to $110,000 or three times an agent’s commission, but the ABC does not mention the commission-based fine detail.
- The Guardian notes the Coalition was polling at 23% in October, while the ABC does not provide Coalition polling figures.
Source Articles
NSW halts new law to crack down on underquoting by real estate agents at 11th hour
Backdown is one of several premier Chris Minns has announced in recent weeks as state prepares for election in March Get our breaking news email , free app or daily news podcast The Minns government has mothballed laws intended to protect homebuyers from underquoting after the premier said real estate agents in his Sydney electorate had raised concerns about their effect amid a housing market downturn. Changes due to come into effect on Tuesday would have banned agents in New South Wales from lo
NSW real estate laws shelved day before coming into effect
Among the changes being cast aside will be the requirement for agents to advertise a selling price, or price range for properties.
More Politics stories
Jollibee fast-food chain expands into Australia with 35 restaurants
Australian PM Albanese's hot-mic gaffe at COP31 climate summit in Antalya, Türkiye
Government reverses sale of historic Victoria Barracks amid public backlash
Victoria’s Big Build royal commission investigates CFMEU’s role in 2022 Gap Road stop-work
Trump directs Vance to shift focus from Iran war to domestic issues, claiming no deal is needed
Trump replaces chief of staff with hardline immigration adviser Stephen Miller after midterm losses
Latest cross-verified stories
Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang resigns amid affair scandal and foreign intelligence concerns
Russell Brand convicted of rape and sexual assault, sentenced to over 10 years in prison
Robert Crawford on trial for alleged murder of wife Frances Crawford in Queensland, 2024
Sydney Swans players cleared of charges in Pullman Hotel sexual assault allegations
14-year-old Leihani Zoric wins ISA World Surfing Games, secures Olympic spot for Australia
Rural shooting in Keysbrook orchard leads to murder charge and police operation
Browse all stories from November 2026 in the archive.