← Back to Stories

COP31 climate summit fails to reach consensus on fossil fuel phaseout

By Updated 23 November 20266 articles from 2 independent sources

Consensus Summary

The COP31 climate summit in Antalya, Turkey, concluded without a consensus agreement after negotiations stretched beyond the scheduled deadline by 44 hours, ending on Sunday afternoon, local time. The failure stemmed from deep divisions over whether to explicitly name fossil fuels as the primary driver of climate change, with the EU, UK, Panama, Marshall Islands, and Norway rejecting a draft deal that omitted this critical language. More than 130 countries had demanded the inclusion of fossil fuels, but Saudi Arabia and Russia led opposition to the explicit mention, forcing the summit’s co-presidents, Australia’s Chris Bowen and Turkey’s Murat Kurum, to abandon the final draft. This marks the first time since Copenhagen in 2009 that a COP summit failed to reach a consensus, underscoring the persistent geopolitical and ideological rifts among nations.

The summit’s breakdown was the culmination of years of strained negotiations under the 2015 Paris Agreement, which aimed to limit global heating to 1.5C above pre-industrial levels. For the first time, COP31 openly acknowledged that this threshold would likely be breached, a stark admission that underscored the urgency of the climate crisis. The draft deal included ambitious but non-binding targets, such as increasing the share of electricity in global energy consumption to 35% by 2035, while avoiding hard commitments on fossil fuel phaseout or carbon capture technology. The summit’s co-presidents attempted to bridge divides by referencing a 2023 agreement from COP28 in Dubai, which had included fossil fuels in its text, but this oblique approach failed to satisfy critics who viewed it as insufficient.

Key figures at the summit, including Ireland’s climate minister Darragh O’Brien speaking for the EU, condemned the final draft as a failure to meet the moment, calling it a 'greenwash' of fossil fuels. O’Brien’s intervention was met with applause, signaling broad dissatisfaction among developed and vulnerable nations. Meanwhile, Australia’s Chris Bowen defended his leadership, stating that the red lines drawn by opposing factions were 'unbridgeable,' while Turkey’s Murat Kurum acknowledged the absence of consensus. The UN secretary general, António Guterres, expressed deep disappointment, emphasizing that the lack of consensus did not alter the scientific reality of the climate crisis. The summit’s failure also highlighted the challenges of the UN’s consensus-based system, which allows any single nation to block progress, as seen with Panama’s formal objection to eight unresolved issues.

While the Guardian and ABC both confirmed the summit’s failure, they diverged in emphasis and detail. The Guardian provided deeper context on the summit’s zero waste initiatives, including practical demonstrations in the green zone, and highlighted the frustration of Pacific island nations over inadequate climate finance, such as the Pacific Resilience Facility’s shortfall of $300 million. ABC, meanwhile, focused more on the procedural breakdown, noting that negotiators were given only three hours to review the final draft before objections were due, contributing to the chaos of the summit’s conclusion. The Guardian also included a live Q&A with climate experts discussing super pollutants like black carbon and methane, while ABC emphasized the geopolitical tensions, including the influence of oil-producing states like Saudi Arabia and Russia in blocking progress.

Despite the summit’s failure, some progress was made on secondary issues, such as the 'just transition' provisions for workers in fossil fuel industries, which were adopted separately. However, the absence of a unified agreement leaves critical questions unresolved, including how to finance climate adaptation for vulnerable nations and how to accelerate the transition away from fossil fuels. The Guardian noted that the summit’s overrunning schedule was typical, with the last on-time COP held in Italy in 2003, while ABC underscored the unprecedented nature of the failure in recent years. As the summit concluded, the UN’s executive secretary, Simon Stiell, acknowledged that while significant progress was made on individual agenda items, the collective failure to address fossil fuels exposed a 'failure of collective will' among wealthy nations to confront the climate crisis’s urgency.

✓ Verified by 2+ sources

Key details reported by multiple sources:

  • COP31 climate summit took place in Antalya, Turkey, with negotiations running from Tuesday, 17 November to Sunday afternoon, local time, exceeding the scheduled deadline by 44 hours.
  • The summit’s final draft deal was rejected by the EU, UK, Panama, Marshall Islands, and Norway due to the absence of explicit mention of fossil fuels, which more than 130 countries had demanded.
  • The draft deal included a goal of 35% of the world’s final energy coming from electricity by 2035, alongside efforts to expand clean energy, but omitted a hard numerical target for carbon capture technology.
  • The summit’s co-presidents were Australia’s Chris Bowen and Turkey’s Murat Kurum, with Bowen calling the failure 'very disappointing' and Kurum acknowledging no consensus on the final draft.
  • The summit’s draft text referenced a 2023 agreement from COP28 (Dubai) to shift away from fossil fuels but avoided explicitly naming them, leading to objections from multiple countries.
  • The summit’s plenary sessions were scheduled to start at 5pm GMT (12pm EST) on Tuesday, 17 November, and later at 5pm AEDT (0600 GMT) on Sunday, with objections allowed until 0300 GMT.
  • The 18-page draft text initially contained 144 separate items, which were later reduced to 94 paragraphs across 10 pages in the final version.
  • The summit’s failure to reach consensus was the first since Copenhagen in 2009, with Saudi Arabia and Russia supporting the exclusion of fossil fuels from the final text.
  • The summit acknowledged that the 1.5C global heating threshold from the 2015 Paris Agreement would likely be breached, marking the first COP to admit this openly.
  • The summit’s 'just transition' provisions for workers in high-carbon industries were passed separately, despite the failure of the main deal.

How the outlets covered it

2 outlets reported this story. The Guardian published first; ABC News followed 45 h later.

OutletPublishedAfter firstHeadline
The Guardian20 Nov, 7:15 pmFirstCop31 live: crunch time as deeply divided climate talks enter final day
ABC News22 Nov, 4:04 pm+45 hCOP31 struggles to reach deal with parties at odds over fossil fuels

Who reported which facts

FactGuardianABC
COP31 climate summit took place in Antalya, Turkey, with negotiations running from Tuesday, 17 November to Sunday afternoon, local time, exceeding the scheduled deadline by 44 hours.✓✓
The summit’s final draft deal was rejected by the EU, UK, Panama, Marshall Islands, and Norway due to the absence of explicit mention of fossil fuels, which more than 130 countries had demanded.✓✓
The draft deal included a goal of 35% of the world’s final energy coming from electricity by 2035, alongside efforts to expand clean energy, but omitted a hard numerical target for carbon capture technology.✓✓
The summit’s co-presidents were Australia’s Chris Bowen and Turkey’s Murat Kurum, with Bowen calling the failure 'very disappointing' and Kurum acknowledging no consensus on the final draft.✓✓
The summit’s draft text referenced a 2023 agreement from COP28 (Dubai) to shift away from fossil fuels but avoided explicitly naming them, leading to objections from multiple countries.✓✓
The summit’s plenary sessions were scheduled to start at 5pm GMT (12pm EST) on Tuesday, 17 November, and later at 5pm AEDT (0600 GMT) on Sunday, with objections allowed until 0300 GMT.✓✓
The 18-page draft text initially contained 144 separate items, which were later reduced to 94 paragraphs across 10 pages in the final version.✓·
The summit’s failure to reach consensus was the first since Copenhagen in 2009, with Saudi Arabia and Russia supporting the exclusion of fossil fuels from the final text.✓✓

Times are when each outlet published, from its own feed, in Sydney time. Outlets whose feeds don’t give a publish time are listed last. Ticks show which outlets the analysis found reporting each fact. See how this works.

Points of Difference

Details reported by only one source:

The Guardian
  • The Guardian reported that campaigners, including Tzeporah Berman, dismissed the mention of fossil fuels in the draft as fleeting, lasting 'about 2 minutes', and that only 91 national leaders attended the opening summit, with Donald Trump and Xi Jinping absent.
  • The Guardian noted that the summit’s zero waste agenda included a zero waste center in the blue zone and pavilions in the green zone, though Turkey still has uncapped landfill sites leaking methane.
  • The Guardian highlighted that the summit’s draft text was reduced from 144 items to 79, and that the last COP to finish on time was in Italy in 2003.
  • The Guardian mentioned that the Marshall Islands diplomat Albon Ishoda expressed frustration over the lack of funding for climate adaptation, with the Pacific Resilience Facility still $300m short of its $500m goal.
  • The Guardian reported that the summit’s failure was described as 'the worst Cop ever' by Mohamed Adow of Power Shift Africa, who criticized Europe’s hypocrisy in expanding fossil fuels while demanding roadmaps from others.
  • The Guardian included a live Q&A with Fiona Harvey and Ajit Niranjan, where they discussed super pollutants like black carbon and methane, and the potential of halving methane emissions to cut temperature rises by 0.3C.
  • The Guardian noted that the summit’s draft text included an oblique reference to the 2023 COP28 agreement to acknowledge support for transitioning away from fossil fuels without explicitly naming them.
ABC News
  • ABC reported that the summit’s final deal was rejected 44 hours after its official close, with the plenary session running into overtime until the presidencies confirmed no further draft would be proposed.
  • ABC noted that the summit’s draft text included a call to electrify the global economy but made no explicit mention of fossil fuels, despite fierce backlash when they were stripped from an earlier proposal.
  • ABC highlighted that the summit’s failure was attributed to irreconcilable differences over fossil fuels, finance, and the fairness of the transition, with Saudi Arabia and Russia supporting the exclusion of fossil fuels.
  • ABC mentioned that the summit’s draft text retained a proposal to boost electricity’s share of total final energy consumption to 35% by 2035, alongside efforts to expand clean energy.
  • ABC reported that the summit’s final draft was given to negotiators with only three hours to raise objections before presentation, leading to confusion and concerns over whether enough delegates would remain to pass it.

Where the reporting differs

Details that conflict, or appear in only some outlets:

  • The Guardian states that the summit’s draft text was reduced to 79 items, while ABC does not mention this specific reduction in item count.
  • The Guardian reports that the summit’s zero waste agenda included practical demonstrations in the green zone, but ABC does not mention this aspect of the summit’s proceedings.
  • The Guardian notes that the summit’s failure was the first since Copenhagen in 2009, while ABC does not explicitly state this comparison but confirms it as the first failure since 2009.
  • The Guardian mentions that the summit’s draft text included an oblique reference to the 2023 COP28 agreement, but ABC only notes that the text alluded to a 2023 agreement without specifying COP28.
  • The Guardian reports that the summit’s plenary sessions were scheduled to start at 5pm GMT (12pm EST) on Tuesday, 17 November, while ABC states the final session was scheduled at 5pm AEDT (0600 GMT) on Sunday, reflecting different time references for key events.

Source Articles

GUARDIAN

Our climate experts Ajit Niranjan and Fiona Harvey answer your questions on Cop31 – live

The Guardian’s environment editor Fiona Harvey and Europe environment correspondent Ajit Niranjan are answering your questions on Cop31, the draft deal on fossil fuels, the fight over climate finance and what overshooting 1.5C means for the world. Ask a question: log in or sign up here Tim asks by email: I heard it was the first zero waste Cop. What positive outcomes have happened at Cop31 for zero waste agenda and how is it related to climate? Fiona: The waste agenda is one that has been propos

ABC

COP31 struggles to reach deal with parties at odds over fossil fuels

The language around fossil fuels remains a flashpoint at UN climate talks in Türkiye, where negotiations have gone into a second day past the deadline.

ABC

Breaking: COP31 deal failure 'very disappointing', Chris Bowen says

The UN climate summit collapses as nations fail to agree over whether to mention the fossil fuels that cause global warming in an agreement.

GUARDIAN

Cop31 live: A new draft deal on the table as talks go into final hours

A third version of the draft text was published overnight, and negotiators have now been called in for what organisers say will be the final plenary Full report: Climate talks stall as countries mull showdown with Saudi Arabia over fossil fuel phaseout Welcome to day 14 of the Cop31 climate summit. Hope you’ve had some rest. If so, that sets you apart from many of the dwindling number of people at the Antalya Expo Centre, Turkey, where they have been negotiating through the night. The talks grou

GUARDIAN

Cop31 live: crunch time as deeply divided climate talks enter final day

Disagreements between rich polluting countries and everyone else threaten to push UN summit beyond its official end “I need to go to sleep every night wondering what that means, you know?” says Albon Ishoda, leaning against a wall in a corridor at the UN climate summit in Turkey. “For us, it’s about existence.” Ishoda is a diplomat who works for the Marshall Islands – a group of low-lying atolls that are specks on a map in the ocean between Hawaii and Australia. Continue reading...

GUARDIAN

Cop31 climate talks break down as key deal rejected

EU, UK and some of developing world object to main text that ‘failed to meet the moment’ and did not mention fossil fuels • Cop31 live blog: longest climate summit ever faces collapse The EU, the UK and allies in the developing world rejected what they called an unacceptable deal on the future of the climate, which failed even to mention fossil fuels, in a dramatic finish to the Cop31 UN talks in Turkey. The proposed deal “failed to meet the moment”, said Ireland’s environment minister, Darragh

More Environment stories

Latest cross-verified stories

Browse all stories from November 2026 in the archive.