← Back to Stories

One Nation proposes 90% cut to refugee intake and scraps parent visas

By Updated 19 November 20265 articles from 3 independent sources

Consensus Summary

One Nation has unveiled a hardline immigration plan to slash Australia’s annual refugee intake by 90%, from 20,000 to just 2,000 places, while scrapping the permanent parent visa program. The policy, led by Pauline Hanson, also proposes a three-year period of net-negative migration, targeting temporary visa holders to reduce overall migration numbers. The party claims the measures would save taxpayers $140 billion over a decade, citing Treasury modelling that estimates each humanitarian entrant costs $500,000 or more over their lifetime. One Nation argues Australia would still remain above the OECD average for per capita refugee intake even with the drastic cut, though critics dispute this claim, noting Australia’s generosity in global comparisons.

The proposal follows a broader political push to reduce migration amid concerns about housing affordability and economic strain. One Nation’s plan builds on earlier announcements in September, when the party targeted 750,000 temporary visa holders for reduction over three years. Labor and the Coalition have also moved to tighten migration policies, with Labor adjusting its working holidaymaker visa limits from 5,000 to 25,000 after industry backlash, while the Coalition has pledged to halve the refugee intake to 10,000. The political debate has intensified as all major parties acknowledge the post-pandemic migration surge has exacerbated housing pressures, though they differ on the scale and approach to cuts.

Key figures in the debate include Pauline Hanson, who framed the policy as 'tough love' for Australians, and Foreign Minister Penny Wong, who dismissed the proposal as 'very harsh' and defended Australia’s existing refugee intake as a 'right balance.' Treasury estimates underpin One Nation’s financial claims, though the party’s analysis has not been independently costed by the Parliamentary Budget Office. Hanson also faced criticism from Labor’s Patrick Gorman, who accused her of seeking a 'discriminatory' migration system. Meanwhile, advocacy groups like the Asylum Seeker Resource Centre condemned the plan as a 'cheap attack' on refugees, arguing it would not address economic challenges but would instead divide the community.

While all sources agree on the core details of One Nation’s proposal—including the 90% refugee intake cut and the scrapping of parent visas—there are discrepancies in financial claims and global comparisons. The ABC and Guardian report a $100 billion savings figure, whereas SMH and Guardian cite $140 billion over 10 years. Additionally, the Guardian highlights that Australia’s refugee intake per capita may not be as generous as One Nation claims when accounting for asylum seekers processed at borders in other countries. The Coalition’s specific target of halving the refugee intake to 10,000 is mentioned only by ABC, while SMH and THEAGE focus more on Labor’s internal policy reversals and the economic trade-offs of migration cuts.

The political fallout from the proposal remains unresolved, with One Nation’s internal divisions and Hanson’s shifting stance on net migration targets adding to the uncertainty. Labor and the Coalition continue to navigate their own migration policies amid voter frustration over housing costs, while advocacy groups warn against further reductions in humanitarian programs. The next election will likely hinge on how these parties balance economic concerns with ethical obligations, particularly as global displacement reaches unprecedented levels, with the UN estimating 118 million people displaced by conflicts like those in Sudan and Ukraine.

✓ Verified by 2+ sources

Key details reported by multiple sources:

  • One Nation proposes cutting Australia’s annual refugee intake from 20,000 to 2,000, a 90% reduction.
  • One Nation plans to scrap the permanent parent visa program, affecting roughly 7,000 visas granted annually.
  • One Nation’s policy would save taxpayers an estimated $140 billion over 10 years, based on Treasury modelling.
  • The lifetime cost of a humanitarian entrant is estimated at $500,000 or $523,000 (adjusted for inflation) by One Nation’s analysis.
  • One Nation’s plan includes a three-year net-negative migration policy, targeting temporary visa holders.
  • Australia’s current refugee intake is 20,000 per year, with the Coalition promising to halve it to 10,000.
  • One Nation claims Australia would still remain above the OECD average for per capita refugee intake if the cap is set at 2,000.
  • The current parent visa cap is 8,500 per financial year, down from 7,060 the previous year.
  • One Nation’s policy would allow parents to visit on three-, six-, or 12-month visitor visas instead of permanent residency.
  • Labor’s net overseas migration target remains at 225,000, with adjustments to working holidaymaker visas from 5,000 to 25,000.

How the outlets covered it

4 outlets reported this story. Sydney Morning Herald published first; ABC News followed 7.0 h later.

Who reported which facts

FactSMHThe AgeGuardianABC
One Nation proposes cutting Australia’s annual refugee intake from 20,000 to 2,000, a 90% reduction.✓✓✓✓
One Nation plans to scrap the permanent parent visa program, affecting roughly 7,000 visas granted annually.✓✓✓✓
One Nation’s policy would save taxpayers an estimated $140 billion over 10 years, based on Treasury modelling.✓·✓·
The lifetime cost of a humanitarian entrant is estimated at $500,000 or $523,000 (adjusted for inflation) by One Nation’s analysis.✓·✓·
One Nation’s plan includes a three-year net-negative migration policy, targeting temporary visa holders.✓✓·✓
Australia’s current refugee intake is 20,000 per year, with the Coalition promising to halve it to 10,000.··✓✓
One Nation claims Australia would still remain above the OECD average for per capita refugee intake if the cap is set at 2,000.✓✓✓✓
The current parent visa cap is 8,500 per financial year, down from 7,060 the previous year.···✓

Times are when each outlet published, from its own feed, in Sydney time. Outlets whose feeds don’t give a publish time are listed last. Ticks show which outlets the analysis found reporting each fact. See how this works.

Points of Difference

Details reported by only one source:

ABC News
  • One Nation’s September plan targeted cutting 750,000 temporary visa holders over three years, with net migration capped at 130,000 annually after that.
  • Foreign Minister Penny Wong called One Nation’s proposal 'very harsh' and argued Australia has a duty to accept refugees.
  • The Coalition has promised to halve the refugee intake to 10,000, while Labor previously considered cutting it to 13,750 before intervention by Prime Minister Anthony Albanese.
  • There are about 157,000 migrants on bridging visas whose application fees would be refunded under One Nation’s plan, but they would have to leave unless they find another pathway.
The Guardian
  • One Nation’s analysis claims the lifetime cost of a humanitarian entrant is $523,000, with 90% of costs borne by the federal government, based on December 2021 Treasury modelling.
  • The Greens leader, David Shoebridge, accused One Nation and major parties of engaging in a 'race to the bottom' to turn back refugees.
  • The Asylum Seeker Resource Centre called One Nation’s proposal a 'predictable and cheap attack' on refugees, arguing it would not make Victorians richer or safer.
  • Pauline Hanson claimed Australia’s refugee program is second only to Canada’s in generosity, though OECD data shows Australia ranks below Germany, France, and New Zealand per capita.
Sydney Morning Herald
  • Labor was considering cutting the humanitarian program from 20,000 to a long-run base figure, costing the budget $1 billion.
  • One Nation’s policy relies on Treasury estimates that parent and refugee arrivals cost taxpayers over $500,000 each over their lifetimes, while skilled migrants contribute a net $260,000.
  • Home Affairs Minister Tony Burke reversed Labor’s plan to cut third-year working holidaymakers to 5,000, adjusting it to 25,000 after backlash from regional businesses.
  • One Nation’s policy was initially framed as a 130,000 permanent visa cap but shifted to three years of net-negative migration after criticism from hard-right influencers.
The Age
  • One Nation’s policy shift followed mixed messages about the level of their cuts, with Hanson focusing on permanent intake after promising in September to cut temporary visas.
  • Assistant Minister Patrick Gorman accused Hanson of wanting to create a 'discriminatory migration system like the old one based on race or religion'.

Where the reporting differs

Details that conflict, or appear in only some outlets:

  • The ABC and Guardian report that One Nation’s policy would save $100 billion over a decade, while SMH and Guardian state it would save $140 billion over 10 years.
  • The ABC states the Coalition has promised to halve the refugee intake to 10,000, but SMH and THEAGE do not explicitly mention this figure in their articles.
  • The Guardian claims Australia ranks below Germany, France, and New Zealand in per capita refugee intake, while One Nation argues Australia would still be above the OECD average at 2,000 refugees per year.
  • SMH and THEAGE mention Labor considering cutting the humanitarian program to a 'long-run base figure,' but do not specify the exact number, while ABC states Labor previously considered cutting it to 13,750 before intervention by Albanese.

Source Articles

SMH

Pauline Hanson unveils plan to scrap parent visas and slash refugee intake by 90 per cent

The populist-right leader wants to slash refugee numbers by 90 per cent, reigniting debate on migration as One Nation braces for a poor result in a state election.

ABC

One Nation to scrap visa program for parents in 'tough love' plan

Pauline Hanson describes the scrapping of visas for the parents of migrants and a massive reduction to the humanitarian intake as "tough love".

GUARDIAN

One Nation says it would cut Australia’s refugee intake by 90% under ‘tough stance’

Pauline Hanson opens new war of words on immigration as Penny Wong accuses populist party of ‘dividing Australians’ Get our daily political email , free app or daily news podcast One Nation has vowed to cut Australia’s refugee intake by 90% and scrap the permanent parent visa program under its latest hardline plan to slash migration. Pauline Hanson announced the policy on Tuesday, labelling it a “tough” approach to migration. Sign up for Guardian Australia’s Politics, really newsletter here Cont

GUARDIAN

Does Australia really have the world’s second most generous refugee scheme?

One Nation wants to slash the program by 90%. But OECD data shows several countries rank higher and critics say it betrays Australia’s history Pauline Hanson has claimed Australia’s refugee program is so generous it ranks second in the world only just behind Canada. The One Nation leader used the claim on Wednesday to justify proposing the program be slashed by 90% from 20,000 places a year to just 2,000 if the minor rightwing party were to lead government. Continue reading...

THEAGE

Pauline Hanson unveils plan to scrap parent visas and slash refugee intake by 90 per cent

The populist-right leader wants to slash refugee numbers by 90 per cent, reigniting debate on migration as One Nation braces for a poor result in a state election.

More Politics stories

Latest cross-verified stories

Browse all stories from November 2026 in the archive.