← Back to Stories

Greens sue over misleading how-to-vote cards in Prahran seat

By Updated 22 November 20262 articles from 2 independent sources

Consensus Summary

The Victorian Greens have secured a Supreme Court victory against independent candidate Tosh-Jake Finnigan, who was distributing how-to-vote cards designed to mimic the Greens’ branding while directing preferences away from the party. The court ruled that Finnigan’s cards—featuring the Greens’ colours, font, and logo—were deliberately misleading and ordered their distribution to stop. Both the ABC and the Guardian report that the Greens lost the Prahran seat in a by-election in February 2025 and are now seeking to reclaim it, with Finnigan’s campaign further complicating their efforts by confusing voters with deceptive materials.

The dispute stems from Finnigan’s initial how-to-vote cards, which bore the banner ‘Vote 1 Green Values’ but instructed voters to preference the Greens last, ultimately benefiting the Liberals. After the Greens threatened legal action, Finnigan quickly revised the cards to use a different shade of green and changed the banner to ‘Vote 1 Trans Greens Values,’ though the party remained unsatisfied. The Guardian notes that Finnigan’s campaign team wore matching green shirts at prepoll, standing near Greens placards, which the Greens argued was deliberate deception. Finnigan, however, claimed the colour was chosen for personal reasons tied to their Irish heritage and denied coordinating with the Greens’ volunteers.

Key figures in the case include Finnigan, who has a history of political activism, including serving as Victoria’s first openly transgender councillor in 2023 and founding the Restore Democracy Sack Dan Andrews party in 2022. Both outlets highlight Finnigan’s whistleblowing role in the 2014 ‘Red Shirts’ scandal, where taxpayer funds were allegedly misused for Labor campaigning. The Greens’ legal team, led by Adam McBeth, argued that Finnigan’s actions were a calculated attempt to mislead voters, while Finnigan accused the Greens of using ‘legal manoeuvres’ to suppress his campaign ahead of a busy prepoll day.

While both sources agree on the core facts of the injunction and Finnigan’s background, they differ in emphasis. The ABC focuses on the broader political context, including the Liberals’ proposal to force Victoria’s Director of Public Prosecutions to face annual parliamentary scrutiny and Labor’s pledge of almost $450,000 to the Pat Cronin Foundation, which advocates against violence after a 19-year-old’s death in a 2016 one-punch attack. The Guardian, meanwhile, delves deeper into the legal tactics and Finnigan’s personal justifications for the colour choice, as well as the party’s 1% vote share in a 2022 upper house bid. These differences highlight the ABC’s broader policy focus versus the Guardian’s attention to procedural and personal details.

The case is now adjourned until further testimony from the Victorian Election Commission, with the Greens determined to prevent any further distribution of misleading materials. Finnigan’s campaign, however, continues to face scrutiny over its branding and messaging, particularly as the election approaches. The unresolved question remains whether the injunction will be fully enforced and how Finnigan’s revised materials will be received by voters in the tightly contested Prahran seat.

✓ Verified by 2+ sources

Key details reported by multiple sources:

  • The Greens won a Supreme Court injunction against independent candidate Tosh-Jake Finnigan for distributing how-to-vote cards mimicking the Greens’ colours, font, and logo, which directed preferences away from the Greens.
  • Finnigan’s initial how-to-vote cards used the Greens’ colour scheme, font, and triangle logo with the banner ‘Vote 1 Green Values’ and instructed voters to preference the Greens last.
  • The Greens lost the Prahran seat in a by-election in February 2025.
  • Finnigan’s campaign Facebook page describes them as a ‘Green Independent’ for the seat of Prahran.
  • Finnigan was Victoria’s first openly transgender councillor in 2023.
  • Finnigan resigned from the Colac Otway shire council in October 2024.
  • Finnigan founded the Restore Democracy Sack Dan Andrews party in 2022.
  • Finnigan worked in Labor minister offices during the 2014 state campaign and later became a whistleblower in the ‘Red Shirts’ scandal.

How the outlets covered it

2 outlets reported this story. The Guardian published first; ABC News followed 26 h later.

Who reported which facts

FactGuardianABC
The Greens won a Supreme Court injunction against independent candidate Tosh-Jake Finnigan for distributing how-to-vote cards mimicking the Greens’ colours, font, and logo, which directed preferences away from the Greens.✓✓
Finnigan’s initial how-to-vote cards used the Greens’ colour scheme, font, and triangle logo with the banner ‘Vote 1 Green Values’ and instructed voters to preference the Greens last.✓✓
The Greens lost the Prahran seat in a by-election in February 2025.✓✓
Finnigan’s campaign Facebook page describes them as a ‘Green Independent’ for the seat of Prahran.✓✓
Finnigan was Victoria’s first openly transgender councillor in 2023.✓✓
Finnigan resigned from the Colac Otway shire council in October 2024.✓✓
Finnigan founded the Restore Democracy Sack Dan Andrews party in 2022.✓✓
Finnigan worked in Labor minister offices during the 2014 state campaign and later became a whistleblower in the ‘Red Shirts’ scandal.✓✓

Times are when each outlet published, from its own feed, in Sydney time. Outlets whose feeds don’t give a publish time are listed last. Ticks show which outlets the analysis found reporting each fact. See how this works.

Points of Difference

Details reported by only one source:

ABC News
  • The Liberals announced a coalition government would force Victoria’s top prosecutor to face annual parliamentary questions about the justice system.
  • Labor announced funding of almost $450,000 dollars for the Pat Cronin violence prevention foundation if it won the election.
  • The Pat Cronin Foundation was established after a 19-year-old died in a one-punch attack in 2016.
  • Coward punch laws, introduced in 2014, have rarely been prosecuted since their introduction.
The Guardian
  • The Greens sought an urgent injunction after Finnigan’s team distributed cards at prepoll on Wednesday morning, with volunteers wearing matching green shirts.
  • Finnigan’s revised how-to-vote card included a disclaimer stating, ‘I confirm that I am not an endorsed Greens party candidate,’ but the Greens were unsatisfied.
  • Finnigan claimed the green colour was chosen because it is called ‘Irish green’ and they are of Irish background.
  • Finnigan’s campaign secured 1% of first preference votes in an unsuccessful upper house bid for their party in 2022.

Where the reporting differs

Details that conflict, or appear in only some outlets:

  • The ABC states the Greens lost Prahran in a by-election in 2025, while the Guardian specifies the loss occurred in February 2025 with a 1.3% margin.
  • The Guardian reports Finnigan’s team stood next to Greens placards at prepoll, but Finnigan denied instructing his team to do so.

Source Articles

ABC

Greens win court fight against Prahran independent how to-vote-cards

The Greens took independent candidate Tosh-Jake Finnigan to the Supreme Court, arguing they were imitating the minor party's colours and font.

GUARDIAN

Victorian Greens seek urgent injunction over how-to-vote cards mimicking party’s branding but preferencing it last

Exclusive: Independent candidate Tosh-Jake Finnigan’s cards instruct people to vote in a way that would benefit Liberal party Get our daily political email , free app or daily news podcast The Victorian Greens are seeking an urgent injunction from the supreme court to stop an independent candidate distributing how-to-vote cards that allegedly mimic the party’s branding and urge people to preference it last. As prepoll opened on Wednesday morning, Tosh-Jake Finnigan’s campaign team handed out how

More Crime stories

Latest cross-verified stories

Browse all stories from November 2026 in the archive.