Essendon sacks Brad Scott, James Hird's return as coach sparks debate
Consensus Summary
Essendon has sacked coach Brad Scott after a dismal 2026 season, with the Bombers winning just one of their first 11 games and sitting at the bottom of the AFL ladder. Scott’s departure, announced on 2026-05-26, leaves Dean Solomon as interim coach for the remainder of the season. The sacking has reignited debate over whether James Hird, Essendon’s revered former player and coach, should return to the top job. Hird, who last coached the club in 2015 and was central to the supplements scandal that suspended 34 players in 2016, publicly declared his interest in the role on 2026-05-26. His candidacy has divided fans and potential candidates, with some arguing his presence could deter other qualified coaches from applying. Scott’s tenure was marked by instability, a lack of clear game style, and poor player development, despite efforts to rebuild the list through drafting. The club’s leadership, including president Andrew Welsh, has emphasized an open process for selecting Scott’s successor, though Hird’s high-profile push complicates the search. The Bombers face a critical decision: whether to prioritize tribal loyalty and Hird’s potential to galvanize the club or pursue an experienced outsider to lead their rebuild.
✓ Verified by 2+ sources
Key details reported by multiple sources:
- Brad Scott was sacked as Essendon coach on 2026-05-26 with over a year remaining on his contract.
- Essendon has won just one of their first 11 games in 2026, and are at the bottom of the AFL ladder.
- James Hird publicly declared his interest in coaching Essendon again on 2026-05-26 on Nine’s Footy Classified.
- Dean Solomon will serve as interim coach for the remainder of the 2026 season.
- Scott’s tenure at Essendon included 80 games, with a record of 29 wins, 50 losses, and 1 draw.
- Hird coached Essendon from 2011–2013 and again for 19 matches in 2015, winning 41 of 85 games.
- The supplements scandal (2012) led to 34 past and present Essendon players being suspended for the 2016 season.
- Essendon president Andrew Welsh stated the club is not ruling anyone in or out for the coaching role.
- Former Essendon assistant coach Ben Jacobs resigned on 2026-05-26, citing loyalty to Scott.
- Hird has been working as director of coaching at Port Melbourne in the VFL since 2024.
Points of Difference
Details reported by only one source:
- Essendon’s only win in 2026 was over Melbourne in Gather Round in early April.
- Scott’s management of Elijah Tsatas was criticized for not playing him despite strong VFL performances.
- Essendon’s senior players, including Zach Merrett, have struggled to instill a winning culture.
- Scott’s successor has a solid base of young players like Nate Caddy, Sullivan Robey, and Archie Roberts.
- Brad Scott’s exit was compared to his departure from North Melbourne in 2019, where he was seen as selfless.
- Scott was burdened by instability and injuries during his tenure, and his selection panel included Josh Mahoney, Andrew Thorburn, Jordan Lewis, and Robert Walls.
- Hird’s return is seen as a potential distraction from the club’s rebuild, with many doubting his ability to lead a young list.
- The club’s failure to move on from the supplements scandal is a recurring theme in the articles.
- Scott’s successor will have a $3 million war chest to advance the rebuild.
- Kevin Sheedy, a former Essendon board director, publicly endorsed Hird’s return after Scott’s sacking.
- Paul Little, a former Essendon chairman, was a key supporter of Hird’s return and criticized David Barham’s leadership.
- Hird’s campaign for the coaching role began in earnest in March 2025 after Essendon extended Scott’s contract.
- Hird’s interest in the role was initially unclear, but his public declaration on Footy Classified galvanized fan support.
- Former Swans coach John Longmire and West Coast coach Adam Simpson have expressed skepticism about entering the process while Hird is a candidate.
- Hird’s son Tom plays for Port Melbourne, where Hird has been involved in coaching and player development.
- Hird’s 2015 stint ended with a 112-point loss to Adelaide at Marvel Stadium.
- Hird’s 2022 application for the Essendon job was rejected in favor of Scott, despite Hird’s belief he was the intended choice.
Where the reporting differs
Details that conflict, or appear in only some outlets:
- The Guardian states Scott was not at the press conference announcing his departure, while The Age does not mention this detail.
- The Age reports Hird’s 2015 stint ended with a 112-point loss to Adelaide, but does not specify the exact date, while the Guardian does not mention this specific loss.
- The Guardian suggests Scott’s sacking was due to a lack of progress and instability, while ABC emphasizes Scott’s failure to develop a clear game style or improve selection integrity.
- The Age states Hird’s campaign was launched on Footy Classified on 2026-05-26, but the Guardian does not specify the exact date of his declaration.
- The Age mentions Hird’s 2014 suspension for his role in the supplements scandal, while the Guardian focuses more on the broader fallout of the scandal.
Source Articles
From the Pocket: Spectre of James Hird looms large but his return is the last thing Essendon need
Want to get this in your inbox every Wednesday afternoon? Sign up for the AFL newsletter here. Brad Scott’s exit from North Melbourne in 2019 was very different from his sacking at Essendon this week . “Brad’s offer to step aside is nothing short of selfless and honourable – terms befitting his character,” Kangaroos president Ben Buckley said at the time. “There’s nothing but blue sky for North,” Scott said. He said it three times. He thanked the individual board members, the coterie groups and
The Bombers start the next chapter under Dean Solomon with many questions to answer
The win didn’t come but the questions facing Essendon would have remained nonetheless. Sunday was just another day in the search for success that has eluded the Bombers for 20 years.
When Hird talks, players listen: Star’s footy journey since leaving Essendon
James Hird has been hands-on as coaching director at Port Melbourne in the VFL, but is it enough to ready himself to return as Essendon coach?
Who even wants the job? Hird is now a political problem for Essendon
James Hird’s pitch is tribal. The brilliance of the campaign, intended or not, is that it creates momentum for him, may dissuade other candidates, and is founded in Essendon patriotism.
Essendon part ways with Brad Scott, club great says Hird could return
The Bombers have won just one match in a year and slumped to the bottom of the ladder with Friday night’s loss to Richmond.
‘I can’t see anyone going for this job’: Simpson’s brutal call on Essendon process as Hird looms large
Premiership coaches Adam Simpson and John Longmire have given their thoughts on the Bombers coaching race.
Brad Scott sacked as Essendon coach pays price for dismal start to AFL season
Scott leaves after run of just one win in 11 games in 2026 Dean Solomon looms as a potential interim boss at Bombers Essendon have sacked coach Brad Scott with over a year remaining on his contract. Scott, 50, pays the price for the Bombers’ dismal start to the AFL season, having won just one of their first 11 games. The final straw was seemingly Essendon’s ugly loss to Richmond on Friday night that anchored the Bombers to the bottom of the ladder. Continue reading...
Inside the ‘redemption campaign’ to reinstall James Hird
It began with a telephone message from former Bombers chairman Paul Little to David Barham in the days following Essendon’s 10-goal loss to Adelaide in round two last year. Little wanted a meeting.
Breaking: Brad Scott sacked as Essendon coach
Essendon sacks head coach Brad Scott as the Bombers languish at the bottom of the AFL ladder.
Scott's sacking gives Essendon another chance to step out of Hird shadow
Essendon finds itself at a clear demarcation point after sacking Brad Scott as the shadow of James Hird once again looms large over the troubled club.