Trial of Liam and Brian Slann for alleged murder of 21-year-old William Holdback in Adelaide
Consensus Summary
A 21-year-old man, William Holdback, was fatally stabbed 10 times in Welland, Adelaide, during an alleged drug deal on April 10, 2024, at around 1.15am. The incident has led to a murder trial against Liam Slann, 29, and his father, Brian Slann, 54, in South Australia’s Supreme Court. Liam Slann has pleaded guilty to manslaughter, though the prosecution rejected this plea, insisting the case should be treated as murder. Both men deny the charge of murder, with Liam Slann’s testimony painting a chaotic scene where he claims William Holdback initially wielded a knife, leading to a violent confrontation that ended in Holdback’s death. The trial hinges on conflicting accounts of who struck first and whether the stabbing was premeditated or a result of escalating aggression.
The confrontation began when Liam Slann and his father drove to Welland to complete a drug transaction, according to both ABC and 7NEWS. Liam Slann testified that William Holdback approached their car, demanded to see the drugs, and then lunged at him with a knife, shattering a window in the process. Prosecutors, however, allege that Holdback was the aggressor, smashing the rear passenger window before fleeing the scene. Liam Slann pursued him, claiming he intended only to retrieve the cocaine and retaliate for the initial attack. Despite hearing Holdback’s desperate cries for help after the stabbing, Liam Slann admitted he and his father drove away, leaving the victim to bleed out on the street. A nearby resident later discovered Holdback and called emergency services, but he could not be saved.
Liam Slann’s testimony has been marked by contradictions and emotional outbursts, with ABC reporting that he described feeling 'in shock' after the stabbing and struggling to recall details. He claimed he only remembered stabbing Holdback’s shoulder before his memory became 'hazy,' though prosecutors argue he repeatedly stabbed the victim. Under cross-examination, Liam Slann denied premeditation, insisting he had not left the house with a knife and that his actions were driven by fear and anger. He also revealed he had wiped his phone on April 12, 2024, following legal advice from his father, further complicating his defense. His mental health struggles, including diagnoses of bipolar disorder and schizo-affective disorder, were raised as potential mitigating factors, though their relevance to the trial remains unclear.
While both ABC and 7NEWS agree on the core details of the incident—including the date, location, and number of stab wounds—they differ slightly in their descriptions of the confrontation. ABC emphasizes Liam Slann’s claim that Holdback smashed the *back* window, whereas 7NEWS cites prosecutors alleging damage to the *rear passenger* window, a discrepancy that could influence perceptions of who initiated the violence. Additionally, 7NEWS provides specific ages for Liam Slann (29) and Brian Slann (54), information absent from ABC’s reporting. These nuances, though minor, highlight the trial’s reliance on subjective interpretations of the same events, with each side presenting a version of the night’s events that exonerates their client.
The trial is expected to conclude later this week, with the jury tasked with determining whether Liam Slann’s actions constituted murder or manslaughter. Prosecutors have not wavered in their assertion that the stabbing was premeditated, pointing to Liam Slann’s alleged intent to 'hurt' Holdback and his failure to seek help afterward. Meanwhile, Liam Slann’s defense has focused on his state of mind, his claim of self-defense, and the chaotic nature of the encounter. The outcome will hinge on which narrative the jury finds more credible, with the case serving as a stark reminder of how easily a drug deal can spiral into tragedy. Regardless of the verdict, the trial has already laid bare the deep divisions between the Slanns and the Holdback family, whose grief and anger have been palpable throughout the proceedings.
✓ Verified by 2+ sources
Key details reported by multiple sources:
- 21-year-old William Holdback was stabbed 10 times during an alleged drug deal in April 2024
- Liam Slann (age unspecified) and his father Brian Slann (age unspecified) are on trial for the murder of William Holdback
- Liam Slann pleaded guilty to manslaughter but the prosecution did not accept this plea
- The incident occurred in Welland, Adelaide's inner north-west
- The alleged stabbing took place on April 10, 2024, at approximately 1.15am
- Liam Slann claims William Holdback initially swung a knife at him during the confrontation
- Liam Slann admitted hearing William Holdback's cries for help but left the scene
- The trial is taking place in South Australia's Supreme Court
How the outlets covered it
2 outlets reported this story. 7News published first; ABC News followed 1.2 h later.
| Outlet | Published | After first | Headline |
|---|---|---|---|
| 7News | 17 Nov, 7:20 pm | First | Liam and Brian Slann trial: Accused heard victim’s cries before driving away, jury told |
| ABC News | 17 Nov, 8:31 pm | +1.2 h | Alleged murderer thought he was being robbed during drug deal, jury told |
Who reported which facts
| Fact | 7News | ABC |
|---|---|---|
| 21-year-old William Holdback was stabbed 10 times during an alleged drug deal in April 2024 | ✓ | ✓ |
| Liam Slann (age unspecified) and his father Brian Slann (age unspecified) are on trial for the murder of William Holdback | ✓ | ✓ |
| Liam Slann pleaded guilty to manslaughter but the prosecution did not accept this plea | ✓ | ✓ |
| The incident occurred in Welland, Adelaide's inner north-west | ✓ | ✓ |
| The alleged stabbing took place on April 10, 2024, at approximately 1.15am | ✓ | ✓ |
| Liam Slann claims William Holdback initially swung a knife at him during the confrontation | ✓ | ✓ |
| Liam Slann admitted hearing William Holdback's cries for help but left the scene | ✓ | ✓ |
| The trial is taking place in South Australia's Supreme Court | ✓ | ✓ |
Times are when each outlet published, from its own feed, in Sydney time. Outlets whose feeds don’t give a publish time are listed last. Ticks show which outlets the analysis found reporting each fact. See how this works.
Points of Difference
Details reported by only one source:
- Liam Slann stated he was 'worried and angry' after believing he was being robbed during the drug deal.
- Liam Slann claimed William Holdback smashed his father's back window and taunted him before the stabbing.
- Liam Slann said he chased William Holdback 'to get the coke back' and intended to 'hurt him' but denied repeatedly stabbing him.
- Liam Slann mentioned he had been treated for 'bipolar, schizo-affective, manic depression, personality disorders' and was released from hospital 'two and a half months' before the incident.
- Liam Slann denied leaving the house with a knife before the incident, stating this was incorrect.
- Liam Slann wiped his phone 'back to factory settings' on April 12, 2024, based on legal advice given to his father.
- Liam Slann claimed he threw the knife out of the car window after the incident, and it has never been recovered.
- Liam Slann is 29 years old and Brian Slann is 54 years old.
- Liam Slann claimed William Holdback had a knife and swung first during the confrontation.
- Prosecutors allege William Holdback smashed the rear passenger window of the Slann’s car with a metal bar before running from the scene.
Where the reporting differs
Details that conflict, or appear in only some outlets:
- ABC reports Liam Slann claimed William Holdback smashed the *back* window, while 7NEWS states prosecutors allege he smashed the *rear passenger* window.
- ABC does not specify Liam Slann's age, while 7NEWS explicitly states he is 29 years old.
Source Articles
Alleged murderer thought he was being robbed during drug deal, jury told
An Adelaide man has given evidence in his murder trial, telling a jury he wanted to "get back" at a man who had swung a knife at him during an attempted drug deal.
Alleged murderer got legal advice to wipe phone, jury hears
Liam Slann and his father, Brian Slann, are standing trial in South Australia's Supreme Court over the alleged murder of 21-year-old William Holdback at Welland in 2024.
Liam and Brian Slann trial: Accused heard victim’s cries before driving away, jury told
A 21-year-old man was allegedly stabbed 10 times during what prosecutors claim was a botched drug deal.
More Crime stories
Former police officer Beau Lamarre-Condon on trial for double murder of Jesse Baird and Luke Davies
Russell Brand convicted of rape and sexual assault, facing prison and ongoing investigations
Robert Crawford on trial for alleged murder of wife Frances Crawford in 2024 lawnmower incident
17-year-old William survives six days lost in Victorian bushland after camping mishap
Former Bachelor star Sam Wood’s third bail appeal for domestic violence charges
Rural shooting in Keysbrook orchard leads to murder charge and police operation
Latest cross-verified stories
Ukraine strikes Crimean Bridge, escalating war with Russia in 2026
Theft of Melbourne Cup and Caulfield Cup trophies during 2026 Spring Racing Carnival
General Pants Co enters voluntary administration, risking 500 jobs and 35 stores
NSW inquest examines neonatal deaths from freebirths and homebirths (2022–2024).
Australia’s Albanese at APEC summit amid Ukraine war and Putin’s presence
Australia's government revises backpacker visa policy amid industry pressure
Browse all stories from November 2026 in the archive.