Ecuadorian fishermen sue US over drone attack, claiming wrongful targeting and torture
Consensus Summary
On **17 March**, a US military drone attack targeted the Ecuadorian fishing vessel *La Negra Francesca Duarte II* in the Pacific Ocean, sinking the boat and injuring two fishermen with severe burns. The fishermen, who were returning from a **two-week fishing trip**, survived by jumping into emergency boats and were later detained by US military personnel, who restrained them with zip ties and hoods. Both the *Guardian* and 7News report that the men were subsequently held in El Salvador, with the *Guardian* stating they were imprisoned for **several weeks** in a detention center, while 7News says they were released by the **end of March** after **seven days** on a Salvadoran ship. The attack is part of the Trump administration’s **Operation Southern Spear**, launched in **November 2025** to combat ‘narco-terrorists,’ though the fishermen insist they had no connection to drug trafficking and were illegally targeted.
The lawsuit, filed in **US District Court for the Western District of Pennsylvania** on **Monday**, alleges the attack was **illegal** and conducted without congressional authority. The fishermen claim they were **kidnapped and tortured** after the strike, with the *Guardian* noting that Ecuadorian authorities had previously inspected the boat and found no drugs or cartel affiliations. The operation has resulted in at least **250 people** killed, according to the *Guardian*, or **240 people**, as reported by 7News, with no public evidence linking the victims to drug smuggling. Legal experts and Democratic lawmakers have criticized the strikes as **extrajudicial killings** on the high seas, violating international law.
Key figures in the case include the boat’s captain, **Hernán Flores**, who described the chaos after the attack in a **June** interview with the *Guardian*, and attorney **Dan Kovalik**, who is representing the fishermen. Kovalik argues the lawsuit will pressure the incoming Democratic Congress to hold hearings in **January**, while the *Guardian* also highlights the families of **Chad Joseph, 26**, and **Rishi Samaroo, 41**, who were killed in a separate US strike in **January**—three months before the *La Negra Francesca Duarte II* attack. The fishermen now face financial ruin, as the loss of their vessel has left them unable to work or support their families.
While both sources agree on the core events—including the **17 March** attack, the fishermen’s detention, and the broader context of Operation Southern Spear—differences emerge in specific details. The *Guardian* provides more granular information, such as the **385 nautical miles** distance from Manta and the captain’s **20 years** of service, while 7News focuses on the **seven-day** detention period and the type of facility where the men were held. The *Guardian* also includes the Pentagon’s **June** denial of involvement, whereas 7News does not mention it. These discrepancies highlight varying emphases in the reporting, though the overarching narrative of wrongful targeting and legal challenges remains consistent.
The outcome of the lawsuit remains uncertain, with the *Guardian* suggesting the Trump administration will contest the claims and the case may serve as a catalyst for broader investigations. The fishermen’s legal team hopes the publicity will force the US to account for its actions, particularly as Democratic lawmakers prepare to take control in **January**. Meanwhile, advocacy groups like the American Civil Liberties Union have condemned the strikes as part of a ‘lawless killing campaign,’ demanding an end to what they describe as unchecked military operations against civilian vessels. The case underscores ongoing tensions between US counter-narcotics efforts and the rights of fishermen in the region.
✓ Verified by 2+ sources
Key details reported by multiple sources:
- The attack occurred on **17 March** when US military drones struck the Ecuadorian fishing vessel *La Negra Francesca Duarte II* in the Pacific Ocean, killing no one but sinking the boat and injuring two fishermen with burns.
- The lawsuit was filed in **US District Court for the Western District of Pennsylvania** on **Monday** (as reported by both sources, with the Guardian specifying it was filed on the same day as the 7News report).
- The fishermen claim they were **kidnapped, restrained with zip ties, and hooded** by US military personnel after the attack, then detained in El Salvador for **several weeks** (Guardian) or **around 24 hours** (7News) before being released by the **end of March**.
- The US military’s **Operation Southern Spear** was announced in **November 2025** to target ‘narco-terrorists’ in the Caribbean and Pacific, with at least **250 people** (Guardian) or **240 people** (7News) killed in subsequent attacks.
- The fishermen were returning from a **two-week fishing trip** when the attack occurred, and the boat was **385 nautical miles** from the port of Manta, Ecuador.
- The lawsuit alleges the attack was **illegal** and occurred without congressional authority, with no evidence the fishermen were linked to drug trafficking.
Points of Difference
Details reported by only one source:
- The boat’s captain, **Hernán Flores**, described the attack in a **June** interview, noting he had commanded the vessel for **about 20 years** and that crew members tried to use an extinguisher before abandoning ship.
- The lawsuit seeks unspecified financial compensation for the attack, **kidnapping, and torture**, and cites the families of **Chad Joseph, 26**, and **Rishi Samaroo, 41**, who were killed in a **January** US strike **three months previously** as part of similar litigation.
- The Pentagon and US Coast Guard **denied involvement** in the attack in a **June** statement, claiming no knowledge of operations against Ecuadorian fishing vessels.
- The fishermen were detained in a **migrant detention center in El Salvador**, which the Guardian describes as ‘not so nice,’ and are now struggling financially with no means to support their families.
- The lawsuit was filed by attorney **Dan Kovalik**, who expects the government to contest it and hopes it will prompt Democratic hearings in **January** when they take control of Congress.
- The fishermen were held on a **Salvadoran ship for seven days** before being taken to El Salvador, where most were placed in a **comprehensive care center for migrants** while two injured men were hospitalized.
- The lawsuit alleges the attack occurred **off the coast of Ecuador** in the **eastern Pacific Ocean**, with no mention of the **385 nautical miles** distance from Manta.
- The 7News article does not mention the **two-week fishing trip** or the **about 20 years** the captain had commanded the boat.
Where the reporting differs
Details that conflict, or appear in only some outlets:
- The Guardian states **250 people** have been killed in subsequent attacks under Operation Southern Spear, while 7News reports **240 people** killed.
- The Guardian specifies the fishermen were detained for **several weeks**, while 7News says they were held for **around 24 hours** before being released by the **end of March**.
- The Guardian mentions the attack occurred **about 385 nautical miles from the port of Manta**, but 7News does not specify the distance from land.
- The Guardian includes details of the boat’s captain, **Hernán Flores**, and his **June** interview, while 7News does not mention him or the interview.
- The Guardian reports the fishermen were detained in a **migrant detention center in El Salvador**, while 7News describes them as being held in a **comprehensive care center for migrants** without specifying the type of facility.
Source Articles
Ecuadorian fishermen who survived US boat strikes sue Trump administration
US military has killed nearly 250 people in attack on ‘narco-terrorism’, and on 17 March, sank the 16 plaintiffs’ boat, leaving two with serious burns More than a dozen Ecuadorian fishermen are suing the US government after they survived a military drone attack in the Pacific ocean earlier this year that sank their boat and left two of them with serious burns from the explosions. The 17 March attack on the La Negra Francesca Duarte II was part of the Trump administration’s Operation Southern Spe
Ecuadorian fishermen sue US President Donald Trump’s administration over ‘illegal’ March boat strike
Two men suffered serious burns when their vessel was engulfed in flames after being mistakenly identified as smuggling drugs.
More Politics stories
Australia's government revises backpacker visa policy amid industry pressure
One Nation proposes drastic cuts to Australia’s refugee and parent visa programs
Australian PM Albanese's hot-mic gaffe at COP31 climate summit in Antalya, Türkiye
Government reverses sale of historic Victoria Barracks amid public backlash
Victoria’s Big Build royal commission investigates CFMEU’s role in 2022 Gap Road stop-work
Trump replaces chief of staff with hardline immigration adviser Stephen Miller after midterm losses
Latest cross-verified stories
Former police officer Beau Lamarre-Condon on trial for double murder of Jesse Baird and Luke Davies
Russell Brand convicted of rape and sexual assault, facing prison and ongoing investigations
Robert Crawford on trial for alleged murder of wife Frances Crawford in 2024 lawnmower incident
Theft of Melbourne Cup and Caulfield Cup trophies during 2026 Spring Racing Carnival
General Pants Co enters voluntary administration, risking 500 jobs and 35 stores
NSW inquest examines neonatal deaths from freebirths and homebirths (2022–2024).
Browse all stories from November 2026 in the archive.