Australia’s terrorism law review proposes removing 'religion' from definition
Consensus Summary
Australia’s national security watchdog, the Independent National Security Legislation Monitor (INSLM), has released a landmark 15-month review calling for the removal of 'religion' from the country’s terrorism definition. The current law requires prosecutors to prove that a terrorist act was motivated by advancing a political, religious, or ideological cause. The review, led by Jake Blight, argues that excluding religion would simplify prosecutions and reduce harm to religious minorities, particularly Muslim communities, while still allowing for convictions under a broader 'ideology' category. The proposal has sparked debate, with some analysts warning it could obscure the motivations behind terrorist acts, while others argue it would address discriminatory practices tied to the current definition.
The review follows decades of legal evolution since the September 11 attacks, which prompted Australia to overhaul its counterterrorism laws 25 years ago. Blight’s report highlights disparities in conviction rates, noting that ISIS-inspired cases achieve an 84 per cent success rate in court, while those involving racist or nationalist ideologies are convicted in only half of all cases. The watchdog also points to a troubling rise in youth radicalisation, with two-thirds of terrorism charges this year involving children—a stark increase from just 8 per cent a few years ago. Most of these young offenders are radicalised online, often with no prior family ties to extremism, raising concerns about the effectiveness of current prevention strategies.
Key figures in the debate include Blight, who insists the change would not hinder police work but would reduce the 'false credibility' granted to religiously motivated terrorists. The Attorney-General, Michelle Rowland, has pledged to carefully consider the recommendations, though Home Affairs Minister Tony Burke dismissed the idea of removing 'terrorism' from the definition entirely this week. Muslim advocacy groups, such as the Australian Federation of Islamic Councils, have strongly supported the review, arguing that the current law fuels suspicion and profiling against their community. Meanwhile, Jewish leaders like the Executive Council of Australian Jewry have expressed skepticism, contending that religion often plays a central role in terrorist acts and should not be conflated with ideology.
The two articles diverge on certain details, particularly regarding the government’s stance and the scope of opposition. The ABC emphasizes the pushback from national security agencies like the AFP and ASIO, which have warned of unintended consequences, while the Guardian focuses more on international comparisons, such as the UN’s recommendation to omit religious motives. The Guardian also highlights a specific legal recommendation: separating credible terrorism threats from actual acts, proposing a maximum five-year sentence for threats instead of the current life imprisonment with a six-year minimum. This distinction reflects broader concerns about disproportionate penalties under existing laws, though neither article explores how this might impact enforcement practices.
The review’s release has set the stage for further political and legal deliberations. While the government has not yet committed to any changes, the debate over the terrorism definition underscores broader tensions between counterterrorism effectiveness and the protection of minority rights. Blight’s report also signals an urgent need to address youth radicalisation, particularly through online interventions and potential legal reforms tailored to juvenile offenders. As the government deliberates, the outcome could reshape Australia’s approach to terrorism prosecutions for years to come, balancing security concerns with social cohesion.
✓ Verified by 2+ sources
Key details reported by multiple sources:
- The Independent National Security Legislation Monitor (INSLM) Jake Blight conducted a 15-month review of Australia’s terrorism definition.
- The current terrorism definition requires proving a motivation to 'advance a political, religious, or ideological cause'.
- Blight’s review recommends removing 'religion' from the terrorism definition and broadening 'ideology' to include religious motives.
- The review notes that ISIS-inspired terror cases have an 84 per cent conviction rate, while cases with racist or nationalist ideologies are convicted in half of all cases.
- The report references the September 11 attacks as a key event shaping Australia’s terrorism laws over the past 25 years.
- ASIO’s counter-terrorism caseload is split into 65% religiously-motivated violent extremism and 35% ideologically-motivated extremism.
- The review warns that two-thirds of all those charged with terrorism offences so far this year are children, up from 8 per cent only a few years ago.
How the outlets covered it
2 outlets reported this story. ABC News published first; The Guardian followed 18 h later.
| Outlet | Published | After first | Headline |
|---|---|---|---|
| ABC News | 19 Nov, 5:35 pm | First | Government urged to drop references to 'religion' in terrorism definition |
| The Guardian | 20 Nov, 11:19 am | +18 h | Religion should be removed from terrorism definition under Australian law as it gives ‘false credibility’, watchdog says |
Who reported which facts
| Fact | ABC | Guardian |
|---|---|---|
| The Independent National Security Legislation Monitor (INSLM) Jake Blight conducted a 15-month review of Australia’s terrorism definition. | ✓ | ✓ |
| The current terrorism definition requires proving a motivation to 'advance a political, religious, or ideological cause'. | ✓ | ✓ |
| Blight’s review recommends removing 'religion' from the terrorism definition and broadening 'ideology' to include religious motives. | ✓ | ✓ |
| The review notes that ISIS-inspired terror cases have an 84 per cent conviction rate, while cases with racist or nationalist ideologies are convicted in half of all cases. | ✓ | · |
| The report references the September 11 attacks as a key event shaping Australia’s terrorism laws over the past 25 years. | · | ✓ |
| ASIO’s counter-terrorism caseload is split into 65% religiously-motivated violent extremism and 35% ideologically-motivated extremism. | ✓ | ✓ |
| The review warns that two-thirds of all those charged with terrorism offences so far this year are children, up from 8 per cent only a few years ago. | ✓ | · |
Times are when each outlet published, from its own feed, in Sydney time. Outlets whose feeds don’t give a publish time are listed last. Ticks show which outlets the analysis found reporting each fact. See how this works.
Points of Difference
Details reported by only one source:
- Home Affairs Minister Tony Burke stated this week that removing 'terrorism' from the definition was 'not on the table' and the prime minister had already ruled it out.
- Attorney-General Michelle Rowland said the government would 'deliberate the findings' of the review and provide a formal response in due course.
- Blight argued that keeping 'religion' in the definition gives ISIS-inspired terrorists 'false credibility' and a recruitment platform.
- The Australian Federation of Islamic Councils (AFIC) called for the 'motive' element of the terrorism definition to be dropped altogether, replaced with a focus on conduct and intent without reference to ideology.
- Blight warned of a surge in youth radicalisation, with most children radicalised online and coming from families with no terrorism history.
- The report recommends separating credible threats of terrorism from actual acts, proposing a maximum sentence of five years for threats (currently life imprisonment with a six-year minimum).
- The UN special rapporteur’s report earlier this year recommended defining terrorism acts by political and ideological causes and omitting religious motives.
- Australia’s special envoy to combat Islamophobia, Aftab Malik, said keeping religion in the definition creates a 'climate of suspicion' around Muslims.
- The Executive Council of Australian Jewry argued that removing religion as a motivating factor makes 'little sense' given many terrorist acts feature religious motifs.
- ASIO’s director-general, Mike Burgess, warned of the rise in violent nationalist extremism in an October submission to a parliamentary inquiry.
Where the reporting differs
Details that conflict, or appear in only some outlets:
- The ABC states that Home Affairs Minister Tony Burke said removing 'terrorism' from the definition was 'not on the table' this week, while the Guardian does not mention this specific statement.
- The ABC notes that the AFP and ASIO have cautioned against changes to the definition, warning of unintended consequences, but the Guardian only mentions ASIO’s warning about violent nationalism.
Source Articles
Government urged to drop references to 'religion' in terrorism definition
A proposal from the national security watchdog argues changing the terrorism definition would simplify legal processes and help prosecute terror threats.
Religion should be removed from terrorism definition under Australian law as it gives ‘false credibility’, watchdog says
Independent National Security Legislation Monitor says reference to religion has ‘contributed to discrimination and violence against religious minorities’ Get our breaking news email , free app or daily news podcast Religion should be removed from Australia’s terrorism definition and making bomb threats should not result in life imprisonment, the country’s national security laws watchdog has said. The highly anticipated report from the Independent National Security Legislation Monitor (INSLM), r
More Politics stories
Former Liberal MP Sharman Stone dies via voluntary assisted dying at 75
Australia's government revises backpacker visa policy amid industry pressure
One Nation proposes drastic cuts to Australia’s refugee and parent visa programs
Australian PM Albanese's hot-mic gaffe at COP31 climate summit in Antalya, Türkiye
Government reverses sale of historic Victoria Barracks amid public backlash
Victoria’s Big Build royal commission investigates CFMEU’s role in 2022 Gap Road stop-work
Latest cross-verified stories
Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang resigns amid affair and espionage scandal
Robert Crawford on trial for alleged murder of wife Frances Crawford in 2024
David Jones department store faces collapse, administration, and mass redundancies
US sanctions Australian Comanchero bikie gang over cartel and terrorism links
Xi Jinping praises Albanese for improving China-Australia relations at APEC summit
NSW inquest examines four neonatal deaths from freebirths and homebirths (2022–2024).
Browse all stories from November 2026 in the archive.